Name your Top Five NFL QB's of All Time (1 Viewer)

[MyAwesomePrizeAlias]

1. Joe Montana2. Joe Namath3. Dan Marino4. Kurt Warner5. John Elway

 

[JZilla]

Brett FavreBrett FavreBrett FavreMichael VickBrett Favre

 

[CamelGod]

1. Joe Montana

2. Joe Namath

3. Dan Marino

4. Kurt Warner

5. John Elway

replace Kurt Warner with Dan Fouts, and you got mine.

 

[Macdaddy_2004]

Peyton ManningTom BradyMike VickCarson PalmerDrew Bledsoe

 

[snogger]

Well, answered over in FFA but here goes again:Tough call cause I didn't get to see some of the oldies so will go off what I was able to see:1. Elway2. Montana3. MarinoAfter that not sure.Favre, Brady, Manning all have their moments guess I'll go4. Manning5.Brady tie Favre

 

[FUBAR]

Just going by what I've seen.1. Joe Montana2. Dan Marino3. Tom Brady4. Steve Young5. John Elway

 

[The_Man]

Any list without Johnny Unitas is wrong

 

[(HULK)]

Brett Favre

Brett Favre

Brett Favre

Michael Vick

Brett Favre

I didn't John Madden was on this board

 

[MyAwesomePrizeAlias]

Any list without Johnny Unitas is wrong

Do you have a list or are you just going to point out errors in other lists?

 

[KevT]

Any list with Vick is wrong. Top five QB of all time, not top five favorite of all time.

 

[Man in the yellow hat]

1. Joe Montana2. Dan MarinoT3. John Elway/Brett Favre5. Johnny Unitas

 

[FUBAR]

Any list without Johnny Unitas is wrong

Just going by what I've seen.

Not having seen him play, I can't vote for him.

 

[Mr. Anonymous]

1. Montana2. Unitas3. Graham4. Baugh5. Elway

 

[SoCalBroncoFan]

1. Joe Montana2. John Elway3. Dan Marino4. Brett Favre5. Johnny Unitas

 

[Ignoramus]

Kurt FREAKING Warner?!?!?!?

He's not even top five amongst those who have played while he has, let alone ALL TIME.

Maybe he's on the Arizona Cardinals' top five, but all-NFL all-time? Laughable.

 

[valhallan]

Any list without Johnny Unitas is wrong

Here's my "too young to have seen Unitas" list:1. Tom Brady

2. Joe Montana

3. Steve Young

4. Dan Marino

5. John Elway

Honorable mentions: Warren Moon, Carson Palmer

 

[MyAwesomePrizeAlias]

Kurt FREAKING Warner?!?!?!?

He's not even top five amongst those who have played while he has, let alone ALL TIME.

Maybe he's on the Arizona Cardinals' top five, but all-NFL all-time? Laughable.

Do you have a list?

Kurt was one of the best QB's I've ever seen. He came out of no where to put up some of the best stats ever made... and he won a super bowl and multiple MVP awards.

His top 5 status is pretty much a lock.

 

[Ministry of Pain]

1. Dan Marino2. Johnny Unitas...the fact I have him and Marino 1 and 2 ought to tell you the type of Qbs I like.3. John Elway4. Brett Favre5. Joe Montana/Tom Brady

 

[Tick]

I'm trying to figure out the angle here. I suspect it will be a "Defend Kurt Warner" thing, but we'll have to see how it plays out.

 

[B Maverick]

def lack of love for Fouts. With out him and Air Coryell, a lot of the offenses we see today arent there.MontanaElwayMarinoFoutsFavreHM to Unitas and MoonPAyton and Brady could move up but for an all time list arent there yet.

 

[Lowen1]

Any list without Johnny Unitas is wrong

Correct...1. Johnny Unitas

2-11 (no particular order)

Sammy Baugh

Otto Graham

George Blanda

Dan Marino

Dan Fouts

Y.A. Tittle

Fran Tarkenton

Bart Starr

Joe Montana

John Elway

Here is a list of all of the quarterbacks in the Hall of Fame:

George Blanda (Also PK) 1949-1958, 1960-1975

Terry Bradshaw 1970-1983

Len Dawson 1957-1975

John Elway 1983-1998

Dan Fouts 1973-1987

Otto Graham 1946-1955

Bob Griese 1967-1980

Sonny Jurgensen 1957-1974

Jim Kelly 1986-1996

Bobby Layne 1948-1962

Dan Marino 1983-1999

Joe Montana 1979-1994

Joe Namath 1965-1977

Bart Starr 1956-1971

Roger Staubach 1969-1979

Fran Tarkenton 1961-1978

Y.A. Tittle 1948-1964

Johnny Unitas 1956-1973

Norm Van Brocklin 1949-1960

Bob Waterfield 1945-1952

Steve Young 1985-1999

Sammy Baugh (QB) 1937-1952

Earl (Dutch) Clark (QB) 1931-1932, 1934-1938

Jimmy Conzelman (QB) # 1920-1929

John (Paddy) Driscoll (QB) 1920-1929

Arnie Herber (QB) 1930-1940, 1944-1945

Sid Luckman (QB) 1939-1950

Clarence (Ace) Parker (QB) 1937-1941, 1945-1946

Edited to add John Elway to my 2-11 category.

 

[Ministry of Pain]

Kurt FREAKING Warner?!?!?!?

He's not even top five amongst those who have played while he has, let alone ALL TIME.

Maybe he's on the Arizona Cardinals' top five, but all-NFL all-time?  Laughable.

Do you have a list?

Kurt was one of the best QB's I've ever seen. He came out of no where to put up some of the best stats ever made... and he won a super bowl and multiple MVP awards.

His top 5 status is pretty much a lock.

A lock...no way. Warner threw it into "windows"...he threw a lot of interceptions...top 5?

 

[B Maverick]

Kurt FREAKING Warner?!?!?!?

He's not even top five amongst those who have played while he has, let alone ALL TIME.

Maybe he's on the Arizona Cardinals' top five, but all-NFL all-time?  Laughable.

Do you have a list?

Kurt was one of the best QB's I've ever seen. He came out of no where to put up some of the best stats ever made... and he won a super bowl and multiple MVP awards.

His top 5 status is pretty much a lock.

you are taking a 3 year guy over QBs who had similar to more success over longer periods of time?

 

[Fla\/\/ed]

1. Joe Montana2. Dan Marino3. John Elway4. Brett Favre5. Bart Starr6. Johnny Unitas7. Steve Young8. Dan Fouts9. Tom Brady10. Troy Aikman

 

[MyAwesomePrizeAlias]

1. Dan Marino

2. Johnny Unitas...the fact I have him and Marino 1 and 2 ought to tell you the type of Qbs I like.

3. John Elway

4. Brett Favre

5. Joe Montana/Tom Brady

Favre doesn't belong on this list. He always had a great supporting cast. This year proves that he can't do much without All Pro players around him. At least Warner is doing something this year with less than Favre has to support him.

 

[Fla\/\/ed]

1. Dan Marino

2. Johnny Unitas...the fact I have him and Marino 1 and 2 ought to tell you the type of Qbs I like.

3. John Elway

4. Brett Favre

5. Joe Montana/Tom Brady

Favre doesn't belong on this list. He always had a great supporting cast.

WRONG! Go check out his supporting cast in the early and mid 90s prior to their two Super Bowls.

 

[MelvinTScupper]

Peyton Manning

Tom Brady

Mike Vick -

Carson Palmer - it's a little early for this one

Drew Bledsoe -

 

[MelvinTScupper]

1. Dan Marino

2. Johnny Unitas...the fact I have him and Marino 1 and 2 ought to tell you the type of Qbs I like.

3. John Elway

4. Brett Favre

5. Joe Montana/Tom Brady

Favre doesn't belong on this list. He always had a great supporting cast. This year proves that he can't do much without All Pro players around him. At least Warner is doing something this year with less than Favre has to support him.

actually, Favre should be above Unitas.

 

[MyAwesomePrizeAlias]

Kurt FREAKING Warner?!?!?!?

He's not even top five amongst those who have played while he has, let alone ALL TIME.

Maybe he's on the Arizona Cardinals' top five, but all-NFL all-time?  Laughable.

Do you have a list?

Kurt was one of the best QB's I've ever seen. He came out of no where to put up some of the best stats ever made... and he won a super bowl and multiple MVP awards.

His top 5 status is pretty much a lock.

you are taking a 3 year guy over QBs who had similar to more success over longer periods of time?

His first full season, 1999, may go down as the greatest ever by a quarterback. He had no experience before this. That is a lock in my book for the top 5 All Time.

 

[Fla\/\/ed]

1. Dan Marino

2. Johnny Unitas...the fact I have him and Marino 1 and 2 ought to tell you the type of Qbs I like.

3. John Elway

4. Brett Favre

5. Joe Montana/Tom Brady

Favre doesn't belong on this list. He always had a great supporting cast. This year proves that he can't do much without All Pro players around him. At least Warner is doing something this year with less than Favre has to support him.

actually, Favre should be above Unitas.

 

[valhallan]

I'm trying to figure out the angle here. I suspect it will be a "Defend Kurt Warner" thing, but we'll have to see how it plays out.

Looks like you're correct.

 

[MyAwesomePrizeAlias]

1. Dan Marino

2. Johnny Unitas...the fact I have him and Marino 1 and 2 ought to tell you the type of Qbs I like.

3. John Elway

4. Brett Favre

5. Joe Montana/Tom Brady

Favre doesn't belong on this list. He always had a great supporting cast.

WRONG! Go check out his supporting cast in the early and mid 90s prior to their two Super Bowls.

I have. It is overflowing with Pro-Bowlers.

 

[Mungo Burrows]

Any list without Johnny Unitas is wrong

Just going by what I've seen.

Not having seen him play, I can't vote for him.

Then don't reply in a "top five...all-time" thread.How about...

Johnny Unitas

Joe Montana

Otto Graham

Dan Marino

John Elway

 

[valhallan]

1. Dan Marino

2. Johnny Unitas...the fact I have him and Marino 1 and 2 ought to tell you the type of Qbs I like.

3. John Elway

4. Brett Favre

5. Joe Montana/Tom Brady

Favre doesn't belong on this list. He always had a great supporting cast.

WRONG! Go check out his supporting cast in the early and mid 90s prior to their two Super Bowls.

I have. It is overflowing with Pro-Bowlers.

I'll have some of whatever he's smokin!!

 

[Fla\/\/ed]

1. Dan Marino

2. Johnny Unitas...the fact I have him and Marino 1 and 2 ought to tell you the type of Qbs I like.

3. John Elway

4. Brett Favre

5. Joe Montana/Tom Brady

Favre doesn't belong on this list. He always had a great supporting cast.

WRONG! Go check out his supporting cast in the early and mid 90s prior to their two Super Bowls.

I have. It is overflowing with Pro-Bowlers.

Overflowing? Oh really?

 

[Mr. Mojo]

1. Joe Montana

2. Dan Marino

3. John Elway

4. Brett Favre

5. Bart Starr

6. Johnny Unitas

7. Steve Young

8. Dan Fouts

9. Tom Brady

10. Troy Aikman

Replace Troy Aikman with Roger Staubach.Aikman would only make the Top 10 Most Overrated QBs list.

 

[Fla\/\/ed]

1. Dan Marino

2. Johnny Unitas...the fact I have him and Marino 1 and 2 ought to tell you the type of Qbs I like.

3. John Elway

4. Brett Favre

5. Joe Montana/Tom Brady

Favre doesn't belong on this list. He always had a great supporting cast.

WRONG! Go check out his supporting cast in the early and mid 90s prior to their two Super Bowls.

I have. It is overflowing with Pro-Bowlers.

I'll have some of whatever he's smokin!!

He may not be smoking....it may be genetic.

 

[The_Man]

1. Unitas -- despite playing in an era when pass defenses had huge advantages over those of today, he is still #6 all-time for TDs, #10 for yards, and holds the record of 48 straight games with a TD pass.2. Montana3. Marino4. Elway5. Sonny Jurgensen

 

[snogger]

Any list without Johnny Unitas is wrong

Just going by what I've seen.

Not having seen him play, I can't vote for him.

Then don't reply in a "top five...all-time" thread.How about...

Johnny Unitas

Joe Montana

Otto Graham

Dan Marino

John Elway

We vote by what we see. Never having had the chance to see Unitas and some of the old timers I can only rank MY Best "All Time" based on what I have seen.

 

[Fla\/\/ed]

1. Joe Montana

2. Dan Marino

3. John Elway

4. Brett Favre

5. Bart Starr

6. Johnny Unitas

7. Steve Young

8. Dan Fouts

9. Tom Brady

10. Troy Aikman

Replace Troy Aikman with Roger Staubach.Aikman would only make the Top 10 Most Overrated QBs list.

It was either Aikman or Scott Mitchell.

 

[MyAwesomePrizeAlias]

1. Joe Montana

2. Dan Marino

3. John Elway

4. Brett Favre

5. Bart Starr

6. Johnny Unitas

7. Steve Young

8. Dan Fouts

9. Tom Brady

10. Troy Aikman

Replace Troy Aikman with Roger Staubach.Aikman would only make the Top 10 Most Overrated QBs list.

It was either Aikman or Scott Mitchell.

Save the schtick for another thread Pal. This is top 5 discussion only.

 

[FUBAR]

Any list without Johnny Unitas is wrong

Just going by what I've seen.

Not having seen him play, I can't vote for him.

Then don't reply in a "top five...all-time" thread.How about...

Johnny Unitas

Joe Montana

Otto Graham

Dan Marino

John Elway

Then people really ought to start voting for Sammy Baugh.

 

[Dr. Octopus]

Just going to list the ones that I've seen play1. Joe Montana2. John Elway3. Terry Bradshaw4. Dan Marino5. Tom BradyETA: Honorable mentions to Dan Fouts and Brett Favre (my two personal favorites from a fan perspective).

 

[Tick]

I'm trying to figure out the angle here.  I suspect it will be a "Defend Kurt Warner" thing, but we'll have to see how it plays out.

Looks like you're correct.

Almost - there's always the flip side, which appears to be "Attack Brett Favre" - works for me.

 

[B Maverick]

Kurt FREAKING Warner?!?!?!?

He's not even top five amongst those who have played while he has, let alone ALL TIME.

Maybe he's on the Arizona Cardinals' top five, but all-NFL all-time?  Laughable.

Do you have a list?

Kurt was one of the best QB's I've ever seen. He came out of no where to put up some of the best stats ever made... and he won a super bowl and multiple MVP awards.

His top 5 status is pretty much a lock.

you are taking a 3 year guy over QBs who had similar to more success over longer periods of time?

His first full season, 1999, may go down as the greatest ever by a quarterback. He had no experience before this. That is a lock in my book for the top 5 All Time.

One good season is all it takes? Are you the same guy that ranks Dilfer over Marino since Dilf won a SB and Marino didnt?

Greatness for an all time list has to be over time. One season does not make you a best ever.

 

[BroadwayG]

1. Lynn Dickey2. Brett Favre3. Bart Starr4. Randy Wright5. Don Majkowski

 

[Dr. Octopus]

Any list without Johnny Unitas is wrong

Just going by what I've seen.

Not having seen him play, I can't vote for him.

Exactly if I vote for a guy I've never seen play, then it really isn't MY list. I'd just be going off from what I've been told, read about or general concencus. I beleive Unitas to be one of the greats based on what I have heard, but can't list him.

 

[MyAwesomePrizeAlias]

Greatness for an all time list has to be over time. One season does not make you a best ever.

Well, I had him on several FF teams in '99. So that season gets extra weight in my rankings.

 

[Fla\/\/ed]

1. Lynn Dickey

2. Brett Favre

3. Bart Starr

4. Randy Wright

5. Don Majkowski

Don't foget...Vince Ferragamo

John Hadl

Jerry Tagge

Jim Del Gaizo

and David Whitehurst

 

[SuperJohn96]

Kurt FREAKING Warner?!?!?!?

He's not even top five amongst those who have played while he has, let alone ALL TIME.

Maybe he's on the Arizona Cardinals' top five, but all-NFL all-time? Laughable.

1. Jim Hart2. Neil Lomax

3. Charley Johnson

4. Jake Plummer

5. Kurt Warner

ool