BobbyLayne
Footballguy
It's leafy and quiet. Boring scene and mediocre restaurants It's been expensive on a psf for as long as I can remember, but it's cheaper than DUMBO or much of Manhattan. Very good schools.Brooklyn Heights is great - Best neighborhood by far... Under 30 minutes door - door to just about any location, great restaurants, nice neighborhoods... The piers there are completing amazing too. I'm married with a child so my likes and someone elses may not match up, but I love it there.
http://www.pierhouseny.com/ - They haven't even started building this yet, but I inquired about what the cost would be - $12 - $1500 a foot and it is already 70% sold. Unfortunately this neighborhood is priced higher than some areas in Manhattan.
I lived in FiDi and Chelsea when I first came to NYC in the late 90s, spent 8 fantastic years in Boerum Hill - 25 x 40 private garden - and the last 5 years in Hell's Kitchen.
I'm not into comparing neighborhoods. I love where I'm at, great amenities, über convenience in every respect except my kids go to school in the W Village, and I'm inextricably intertwined with HK.
There are a LOT of great neighborhoods in NYC.