What's new
Fantasy Football - Footballguys Forums

This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

NFL Writers Mock (1 Viewer)

massraider

Footballguy
http://www.ibabuzz.com/raidersblog/2008/04...gholston-again/

Thought for a moment I had a chance to get Chris Long in silver and black, only to be thwarted by the Atlanta Falcons.

So once again, I opted for Ohio State defensive end Vernon Gholston on behalf of the Raiders in a mock first round made up of NFL writers conducted Monday by conference call.

It works like this _ when your turn comes up, give a brief overview of the needs of the team you cover, how many selections they have in the draft and if there is a chance of a deal to move up or down. Then make the choice and give your reasoning.

With the No. 1 pick, Alex Marvez of Fox Sports, a former Dolphins beat writer, took Michigan tackle Jake Long. Miami has not had a shutdown left tackle since Richmond Webb and could select Long and move Vernon Carey to the right side.

If a deal cannot be reached with Long, Marvez believes Miami would opt for Virginia end Chris Long, who is considered less of a projection than Gholston.

At No. 2, I was mildly surprised when Jim Thomas of the St. Louis Post-Dispatch took LSU defensive tackle Glenn Dorsey for the Rams in a close call over Chris Long.

With Atlanta at No. 3, and in need of a quarterback to replace Michael Vick, I started to think maybe Chris Long would be available and was prepared to seize the opportunity to add an instant every-down starter.

Alas, D. Orlando Ledbetter of the Atlanta Journal-Constitution is of the belief the Falcons aren’t that high on Ryan and will use one of their later picks to get a quarterback such as Louisville’s Brian Brohm or Michigan’s Chad Henne. Chris Long went to the Falcons at No. 3.

At No. 4, I opted for Gholston as I had in a previous draft, believing his stunning athletic gifts and pass rushing ability would be put to use instantly. Even if Gholston didn’t play fulltime, assuming the Raiders can get Derrick Burgess back to double figures in sacks, he could give Oakland their best pass rush in years _ and making the quarterback go down, and go down hard, is a time-honored Raiders tradition.

Yes, I passed up Darren McFadden, for reasons I’ll give in another blog at some point leading up to the draft.

Here’s how the rest of the first round ended up:

5. Kansas City: DT Sedrick Ellis, USC

6. New York Jets: RB Darren McFadden, Arkansas

7. New England: G-T Branden Albert, Virginia

8. Baltimore: QB Matt Ryan, Boston College

9. Cincinnati: OT Jeff Otah, Pitt

10. New Orleans: CB Leodis McKelvin, Troy

11. Buffalo: WR Devin Thomas, Michigan State

12. Denver: OT Ryan Clady, Boise State

13. Carolina: RB Jonathan Stewart, Oregon

14. Chicago: OT Chris Williams, Vanderbilt

15. Detroit: DE Derrick Harvey, Florida

16. Arizona: CB Dominique Rodgers-Cromartie, Tennessee State

17. Minnesota: DE Philip Merling, Clemson

18. Houston: CB Mike Jenkins, South Florida

19. Philadelphia: Aqib Talib, Kansas

20. Tampa Bay: WR DeSean Jackson, Cal

21. Washington: WR Malcolm Kelly

22. Dallas: RB Rashard Mendenhall, Illinois

23. Pittsburgh: DT Ketwan Balmer, North Carolina

24. Tennessee: RB Felix Jones, Arkansas

25. Seattle DE Lawrence Jackson, USC

26. Jacksonville: S DaJuan Morgan, North Carolina State

27. San Diego: OT Gosder Cherlius, Boston College

28. Dallas: CB Brandon Flowers, Virginia Tech

29. San Francisco: DE Quentin Groves, Auburn

30. Green Bay: QB Joe Flacco, Delaware

31. Vacant _ forfeited by New England

32. New York Giants: LB Jerod Mayo, Tennessee

Note: Got off of the conference call after 20 selections, at which time USC linebacker Keith Rivers had not been selected. As it turned out, a few more picks went off the board without Rivers being selected. Because of the oversight, it was decided Rivers would come off the board altogether on the presumption he would have been selected earlier.

 
I've said it before and I'll say it again, no one inside the state of Georgia thinks that the falcons "need" to take a qb at the #3 spot. Not the fans, not the players, and most importantly not the front office. Chris redman gives them a solid qb for this season and ryan may not be any better than any of the qbs that atlanta could draft later. Not to mention that the HC is a defensive guy and the GM used four of the pats five first round picks to take a defensive player

 
Interesting that Detroit doesn't take a RB, but Tennessee does. The exact opposite of what I (and most people) suspect will happen.

 
I've said it before and I'll say it again, no one inside the state of Georgia thinks that the falcons "need" to take a qb at the #3 spot. Not the fans, not the players, and most importantly not the front office. Chris redman gives them a solid qb for this season and ryan may not be any better than any of the qbs that atlanta could draft later. Not to mention that the HC is a defensive guy and the GM used four of the pats five first round picks to take a defensive player
I agree, Redman, harrington and a 2nd rounder is both financially wiser and makes more sense for the team talent-wise.Carolina is in the same boat, a 1st round RB would be stupid, but a 3rd round RB would be smart.
 
Only two that look out of place are Felix Jones to TENN, and Joe Flacco to GB. I don't think we'll see Kelly in the first two rounds, but I've been surprised before.

 
Only two that look out of place are Felix Jones to TENN, and Joe Flacco to GB. I don't think we'll see Kelly in the first two rounds, but I've been surprised before.
This is a big strange one. If you want to shatter whatever confidence Rodgers might have, this would do it. There is no way GB can draft a 1st round QB and keep Rodgers, IMO
 
Ughhh,

I swore I would not look at any more mocks but I fell for it.

19. Philadelphia: Aqib Talib, Kansas - c'mon the dude tested positive more times then Ricky Williams, no way he gets picked in the first.

 
you're kidding with Chris Redman . . . right???
Nope, he threw at least two TDs in four of his five starts and threw for at least 250 yards in three of his last four starts(twice throwing for nearly 300 yards). Not too shabby for a guy who hadn't played in the NFL in two years. Yes, atlanta didn't face tough competion when he started but IIRC this year the falcons only face four teams over .500. And finally I will add that ppl who bash redman are juding him based on his time in baltimore where I will admit he stunk up the joint but derek anderson didn't do too well with them either.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
you're kidding with Chris Redman . . . right???
Nope, he threw two TDs in four of his five starts and threw for at least 250 yards in three of his last four starts(twice throwing for nearly 300 yards). Not too shabby for a guy who hadn't played in the NFL in two years. Yes, atlanta didn't face tough competion when he started but this year the falcons only face four teams over .500. And finally I will add that ppl who bash redman are juding him based on his time in baltimore where I will admit he stunk up the joint but derek anderson didn't do too well with them either.
Chris Redman did an excellent job last season, but it will be interesting to see him adapt to a new system he's unfamiliar with.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top