Non PPR trade offer (1 Viewer)

[geddy1001]

All,

I was offered Antonio Brown, JMixon and Jamal Williams for my Saquan and Keenan Allen. Initially it seemed more of a quantity for quality but am now intrigued. what do you all think?

Currently other RB's are JHoward, LMiller, MMack and MBrieda

My other Wr's are Alenn Robinson, DBaldwin and QEnunwa

Thanks!

 

[beerbuff]

Williams is garbage. The difference between Keenan and Antonio is negligible but there could be a big gap between Barkley and Mixon so no. Stay put.

 

[geddy1001]

Thanks!

 

[Gally]

Williams is garbage. The difference between Keenan and Antonio is negligible but there could be a big gap between Barkley and Mixon so no. Stay put.

I wouldn't say the gap between Brown and Keenan is negligible but it isn't the gap between Saquan and Mixon.  I do agree that Williams doesn't have any value in this deal. 

Based on the OP's roster I would want a WR included instead of Williams as that is his weak spot in the lineup.  With Howard, Saquon (or Mixon) and Miller RB should be fine but with Baldwin's injury issues and still questions in Chicago and NYJ another WR option might be helpful.  Depending on what that piece could be I would be tempted to make the deal.