flapgreen said:
KCitons said:
My other thought is this. If Trestman is a QB genius, then Cutler should be able to elevate his play beyond anything we have seen in past years. He will have the talent around him to accomplish it. If he continues to make mistakes that holds the team back going forward, then I believe McCown, or any number of other QB could accomplish an 8-8 to 10-6 season with this team.
When you factor in Cutlers durability, what are you really getting for your money. His time in Chicago has already proved that you need a quality backup if you hope to make it through the season.
What's the alternative? Do you think know putting McCown back out there and trying to draft the next great qb is a better alternative? Impossible to predict which qbs will be even a top 20 guy for the long haul. What if they put McCown back out there and we miss on the next pick? Another 5 years down the drain. Do you think McCown has what it takes to take them to a championship? How many years would it take his replacement to get to that level? It's a lot of years to wait on something that may not happen.
one thing I noticed for McCown backers, they use the last season of McCown compared the the whole career of Cutler. but if you want to be objective lets compare the whole career of both.
Josh - 50TD 45 INT - 77.5 QBR - in 11 seasons 8,827 yards - Age 34 - QB record 16-22 - Seasons with more INTs then TD, 5
Jay - 150TD 112 INT - 84.6 QBR - in 8 seasons 23,937 yards - Age 30 - QB record 56-48 - Seasons with more INTs then TD, 0