thriftyrocker
Footballguy
I think most full PPR leagues you can get a top 5. Based on DLF ADP he's worth 1.2 but that will change once rookies get teams. He's worth a lot no matter how you phrase it.I would offer a top 3 pick for himLet me re-focus this a touch on Cooks. Would you pay a top 3 pick for him? I would not. Secondly and different but sort of relevant, I am also not the type of trader who acquires guys like Cooks for the sole purpose of working the phones enough to flip him for other value. I pick my spots and go for certain players I want. I maybe losing out some value in the long run but that is how I operate.Looks like Jordy Nelson might be the most overvalued player in dynasty right now. And he isn't 29, he is 30. 30 when the season starts, so he is 30. No idea how it can be looked at any other way. What, does his value go down on his 30th birthday, meaning you value him more right now?? i sure hope not. That's just silly.
Cooks, based on his ADP, can probably be traded for a top 3 pick.
Pick 1 can pretty easily be traded for a couple fairly early 1sts in most leagues, say picks 4 and 5.
Either can be traded straight up for a really good and valuable player.
I can't fathom even considering trading both for Nelson. Not when I know I can get a better/younger/more valuable player than Nelson for the same package.
Looks some some are commanding 2012 Calvin type stud package for him.
I can understand someone deciding to send pick 1 for Nelson. I wouldnt fault someone too much. Adding Cooks just makes it a very bad trade.
Last edited by a moderator: