I look at the Mack situation this way:
Gruden took over a team that was devoid of talent that surrounded Mack, Cooper and Carr. 2016 was a fluke. Carr caught lightning in a bottle, and when he got hurt the team sank. The core of that team had no talent and no fight without Carr. Where was Mack in that playoff game? He was double teamed, triple teamed, completely neutralized because there was no one else on defense opposing offenses had to worry about. While Mack was winning awards the rest of the defense was garbage.
Gruden had a decision to make. Go the way of the Broncos and pay their stud DE QB money and flounder in mediocrity or trade his elite talent for as much capital as possible go through another complete rebuild. Signing a 10 year contract, the writing was on the wall, this was going to be a long and painful rebuild.
Could he have kept Mack and still molded a playoff team around him? Who knows, but by judging what some other teams are doing around the league ie, Giants and Dolphins, it could be said that Gruden was ahead of the curve in a sense. The NFL is all about wins, if you're not the Champs, you're last. What good is paying an edge rusher $140 mil, if you can't even get out of your own division? The only way the Bears win the trade is if they win a Super Bowl with Mack on the roster. If they don't, and Gruden/Mayock are able to hit on their draft picks and create a culture of winning in Vegas then at least it wouldn't be viewed as a horrible decision. We have to wait and see. Unfortunately for Raiders fans patience is something we don't have much of anymore.
Gruden took over a team that was devoid of talent that surrounded Mack, Cooper and Carr. 2016 was a fluke. Carr caught lightning in a bottle, and when he got hurt the team sank. The core of that team had no talent and no fight without Carr. Where was Mack in that playoff game? He was double teamed, triple teamed, completely neutralized because there was no one else on defense opposing offenses had to worry about. While Mack was winning awards the rest of the defense was garbage.
Gruden had a decision to make. Go the way of the Broncos and pay their stud DE QB money and flounder in mediocrity or trade his elite talent for as much capital as possible go through another complete rebuild. Signing a 10 year contract, the writing was on the wall, this was going to be a long and painful rebuild.
Could he have kept Mack and still molded a playoff team around him? Who knows, but by judging what some other teams are doing around the league ie, Giants and Dolphins, it could be said that Gruden was ahead of the curve in a sense. The NFL is all about wins, if you're not the Champs, you're last. What good is paying an edge rusher $140 mil, if you can't even get out of your own division? The only way the Bears win the trade is if they win a Super Bowl with Mack on the roster. If they don't, and Gruden/Mayock are able to hit on their draft picks and create a culture of winning in Vegas then at least it wouldn't be viewed as a horrible decision. We have to wait and see. Unfortunately for Raiders fans patience is something we don't have much of anymore.