Fantasy Football - Footballguys Forums
This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!
*** OFFICIAL *** In-Season Dynasty Trade Thread (1 Viewer)
- Thread starter doowain
- Start date
valhallan
Footballguy
12 team PPR start 1/2/2/1/flex
Gave:
Keenum
Stills
J.Thomas
Got:
Tannehill
Cruz
Ertz
Thought this one might be interesting to some people. I'm normally a contender but injuries have made a championship this year unlikely. Julius was great, but I'm thinking Eifert will become a TE1 next year and it made sense to target a WR upgrade for a run next year. The other guy is the top team but sort of weak at TE. Hated giving up Keenum and Stills but you have to give something to get something. Ertz feels like a good enough sleeper as a consolation.
Gave:
Keenum
Stills
J.Thomas
Got:
Tannehill
Cruz
Ertz
Thought this one might be interesting to some people. I'm normally a contender but injuries have made a championship this year unlikely. Julius was great, but I'm thinking Eifert will become a TE1 next year and it made sense to target a WR upgrade for a run next year. The other guy is the top team but sort of weak at TE. Hated giving up Keenum and Stills but you have to give something to get something. Ertz feels like a good enough sleeper as a consolation.
cstu
Footballguy
I thought you got the best three players in the deal:
Cruz > Thomas
Ertz > Stills
Tannehill > Keenum
valhallan
Footballguy
Not sure I'd agree on the last two. I'd definitely prefer Keenum to Tannehill. Stills is much more impressive than past Saints deep threats (Henderson, Morgan).
In any case, he's a top team filling a need by giving up depth, so naturally the counter-party probably ends up with more value.
In any case, he's a top team filling a need by giving up depth, so naturally the counter-party probably ends up with more value.
Lott's Fingertip
Footballguy
Interested in thoughts on this one:
12 team - 1/2 PPR for WR/TE only, start Q RR WWW T + flex. Max 4 yr contracts.
Blackmon (3yr), Nicks (4), J Reed (4), 2014 1st (middle)
For
Calvin Johnson (3), V Jackson (2)
12 team - 1/2 PPR for WR/TE only, start Q RR WWW T + flex. Max 4 yr contracts.
Blackmon (3yr), Nicks (4), J Reed (4), 2014 1st (middle)
For
Calvin Johnson (3), V Jackson (2)
Andrew74
Footballguy
Flipped himI give: Brady, 2015 1st (should be late)
I get: Welker + 2015 2nd (prob non-playoff)
Team hurt by injuries (esp Julio and Cobb), so looking for WR help to win a title.
EDIT: add that league is 0.5 PPR
Last edited by a moderator:
FreeBaGeL
Footballguy
Last edited by a moderator:
FUBAR
Footballguy
Really don't know about Tannehill vs. Keenum. Short term, give me Keenum but I'm a fan of both. (my two backups behind Stafford FWIW). Stills is worth a lot more than Ertz IMO and it isn't close. I'd also take Thomas over Cruz if there's enhanced TE scoring; if not then it's close IMO. If you needed the WR and not a TE, then it certainly makes sense. I think each of the 3 pieces is very close in value on both sides.cstu said:I thought you got the best three players in the deal:valhallan said:
Cruz > Thomas
Ertz > Stills
Tannehill > Keenum
BearsFan4Life
Footballguy
14 Team - No PPR
3 Weeks ago:
Gave: TRich
Got: DJackson and 2014 2nd Round (mid to late)
Today:
Gave: Pierce and same 2nd Round Pick above
Got: TRich
So really dealt Pierce for DJackson
3 Weeks ago:
Gave: TRich
Got: DJackson and 2014 2nd Round (mid to late)
Today:
Gave: Pierce and same 2nd Round Pick above
Got: TRich
So really dealt Pierce for DJackson
PatsWillWin
Footballguy
cstu
Footballguy
Well done. I actually prefer Foles to Brady and you get 4 years of Randle instead of one year of Brown. Britt doesn't hold much value IMO.
ghostguy123
Footballguy
Agreeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeed. Rice is really good another 2 years or so once he actually gets time off to rest.............those other guys likely never.
JustinHawkins
Footballguy
12 team PPR dynasty league where I am rebuilding
Gave: Gates, Boldin, Fred Jackson
Got: Pettigrew, Dunbar, 1st, 2nd in 2014 (likely late picks)
Gave: Gates, Boldin, Fred Jackson
Got: Pettigrew, Dunbar, 1st, 2nd in 2014 (likely late picks)
JustinHawkins
Footballguy
12 team PPR dynasty
Team A gets: Charles, Trent Richardson, Lance Moore, Myers
Team B gets: Martin, Spiller, Rudolph, Mike James
Who wins in 2014 and beyond??
Team A gets: Charles, Trent Richardson, Lance Moore, Myers
Team B gets: Martin, Spiller, Rudolph, Mike James
Who wins in 2014 and beyond??
Last edited by a moderator:
BearsFan4Life
Footballguy
Couple recent deals:
14 team devy PPR:
Team A gets: Jeffery
Team B gets: Andre Brown, Amendola
12 team PPR:
Team A (rebuilding) gets: Crab, E.Sanders, T.Wright
Team B (contender, been hit hard by injuries to Julio, Rodgers, ineffectiveness of T-Rich) gets: Antonio Brown, R.Jennings
14 team devy PPR:
Team A gets: Jeffery
Team B gets: Andre Brown, Amendola
12 team PPR:
Team A (rebuilding) gets: Crab, E.Sanders, T.Wright
Team B (contender, been hit hard by injuries to Julio, Rodgers, ineffectiveness of T-Rich) gets: Antonio Brown, R.Jennings
ConnSKINS26
Footballguy
Cheap for Jeffery.
Concept Coop
Footballguy
I'd take Martin and Spiller; unless we're playing "one of these things...", in which case Trent is the easy answer.
JustinHawkins
Footballguy
12 team PPR dynasty
I gave: Trent Richardson, Woodhead, 1st and 3rd in 2014 (should be very late, 1.11 or 1.12)
I got: Julius Thomas, Sproles, 1st in 2014 (guessing 1.4-1.8 range)
Trying to win the title this year and wanted long term TE replacement for Gates. Weekly starters for title run in bold:
RG3, Big Ben
Morris, Bernard, Sproles, DeAngelo
Calvin, AJGreen, Garçon, A.Brown, Patterson, Woods, Da'Rick Rogers, Kerley
Julius Thomas, Gates, Rivera, F.Davis, Fauria
I gave: Trent Richardson, Woodhead, 1st and 3rd in 2014 (should be very late, 1.11 or 1.12)
I got: Julius Thomas, Sproles, 1st in 2014 (guessing 1.4-1.8 range)
Trying to win the title this year and wanted long term TE replacement for Gates. Weekly starters for title run in bold:
RG3, Big Ben
Morris, Bernard, Sproles, DeAngelo
Calvin, AJGreen, Garçon, A.Brown, Patterson, Woods, Da'Rick Rogers, Kerley
Julius Thomas, Gates, Rivera, F.Davis, Fauria
Last edited by a moderator:
Because Spiller's been so much more awesome than Trent, in addition to being 5 years older?
Concept Coop
Footballguy
He's not 5 years older, but the awesome part: yes. I'll take the guy not producing due to an injury over the guy not producing due to ability.
Last edited by a moderator:
Concept Coop
Footballguy
It won't matter how young Richardson is if he can't stick in the league, or, at least, a starting role. Even his biggest fans should see that as a potential outcome.
ConnSKINS26
Footballguy
Excellent. I'm trying to do similar things with Martin in one league. Putting out feelers of Martin+ for any of Green, Dez, Demaryius, Gronk.
Concept Coop
Footballguy
Heavy lineup reqs, as in number of starters required?
I'm torn. I really like Dez, and like the idea of adding to Martin to get him. I just don't like trading Austin right now. I still see plenty of potential there.
I can see both sides.
ConnSKINS26
Footballguy
Brady side by a mile in that format, unless you're a really big Manuel fan and/or that pick gets you Bridgwater.
ghostguy123
Footballguy
msudaisy26
Footballguy
Give me Jeffery. I like Brown and Amendola but they can't stay healthy. Give me Crabtree side. Jennings has no value in my league for some reasonSitch said:
msudaisy26
Footballguy
cstu
Footballguy
I don't have a problem with packaging Martin with someone to get a top WR, but that's selling way low on Austin. Even if you don't believe in him he'll still fetch a high price to someone.
deadlyrange0321
Footballguy
12 team PPR, 1QB 1RB 1WR 1TE 3FLEX
Team A trades:
Ben Roethlisberger
Stevie Johnson
2014 1st Rd Pick (Currently would be 1.10)
Team B trades:
Cordarrelle Patterson
Team A trades:
Ben Roethlisberger
Stevie Johnson
2014 1st Rd Pick (Currently would be 1.10)
Team B trades:
Cordarrelle Patterson
cstu
Footballguy
I'm still going to go with the Manuel side. Not certain how good he'll be but I'd rather take my chances on him than Brady.
ConnSKINS26
Footballguy
In Superflex, getting Brady for this price could win you a championship or two. Plus you're getting the added bonus of a possible Rice bounce-back which is > Miller.
12 team 1PPR QRRWWWT
Gave Randall Cobb, mid 2nd
Got DeSean Jackson, 4th
Currently sitting 4th in the standings with a good team but the Cobb injury hurt and I have been playing WR2-3 committee with Douglas/Sanders/Williams/Hartline. Only one gr ahead of the teams going all the way back to 8th so I felt the need to shore up my WR2 spot and make a run. Team getting Cobb is currently in last
Gave Randall Cobb, mid 2nd
Got DeSean Jackson, 4th
Currently sitting 4th in the standings with a good team but the Cobb injury hurt and I have been playing WR2-3 committee with Douglas/Sanders/Williams/Hartline. Only one gr ahead of the teams going all the way back to 8th so I felt the need to shore up my WR2 spot and make a run. Team getting Cobb is currently in last
ConnSKINS26
Footballguy
I understand why you did it, but I love that trade for the last place guy getting Cobb.
Do you mean why would someone give up Martin AND Austin for Dez, or why would anyone give up Dez in that trade?
msudaisy26
Footballguy
Like this trade for both sidesJustinHawkins said:
Yes, number of starters is high. QB, 2RB, 3WR, TE, 2 Flx. This adds to the side getting multiple players. On the other hand, I forgot to mention that the rosters are only 20, so this benefits the single player. Overall, when dealing with players of this caliber (where the worst player is as good as Austin), the starting requirements have a greater impact than the short rosters imo (i.e., advantage Martin/Austin). Every team has holes, so filling those holes with Austin-caliber players is a big plus.
In terms of value, I think Martin + a late 1st / early 2nd would have been about the right value. I value Austin more than a late 1st (by a decent amount), so I view my side having given more than it received. It was not a surprise that the trade was accepted pretty quickly.
I like Austin as well. I view it more of a buy high on Dez rather than selling low on Austin. For example, I would not have sold Austin for a mid 1st rounder and solving for Austin in this equation would equate Austin at a late 1st, early 2nd value. In reality, I didn't move Austin's value down to that level. I bumped Dez's up from the typical valuation.
Adam Harstad
Moderator
Adam Harstad
Moderator
Going to go against the grain here, but give me Charles/Richardson. TRich has serious red flags, but honestly, it's not like either Martin *OR* Spiller have been impressing this year, which makes Charles the only bonafide no-question stud on either side.
Adam Harstad
Moderator
The fact that I have no idea which side of the trade you're questioning is probably a pretty good sign that that was a fair trade.
msudaisy26
Footballguy
Trade deadline had these deals go down. I would appreciate any feedback.
Team A gives Sproles
Team B gives a 2014 first team is 7 - 3 probably won't get a bye, so pick should be from 7 to 10
Team C gives Christine Micheal and Randall Cobb
Team D gives Julio Jones Both teams are out of the playoff race barring a miracle team D is a Lynch/Turbin owner
Team E gives Vernon Davis
Team F gives Terrance Williams and a 2014 2nd rounder should be top 3 in the second round.
Team G gives Chris Ivory
Team H gives T. Wright and 2014 3rd should be top 4 in the 3rd
Team I give Justin Blackmon, Ryan Tannehill
Team J gives Tom Brady and Dwayne Bowe
Team A gives Sproles
Team B gives a 2014 first team is 7 - 3 probably won't get a bye, so pick should be from 7 to 10
Team C gives Christine Micheal and Randall Cobb
Team D gives Julio Jones Both teams are out of the playoff race barring a miracle team D is a Lynch/Turbin owner
Team E gives Vernon Davis
Team F gives Terrance Williams and a 2014 2nd rounder should be top 3 in the second round.
Team G gives Chris Ivory
Team H gives T. Wright and 2014 3rd should be top 4 in the 3rd
Team I give Justin Blackmon, Ryan Tannehill
Team J gives Tom Brady and Dwayne Bowe
12 team 1PPR QRRWWWT
Gave Randall Cobb, mid 2nd
Got DeSean Jackson, 4th
Currently sitting 4th in the standings with a good team but the Cobb injury hurt and I have been playing WR2-3 committee with Douglas/Sanders/Williams/Hartline. Only one gr ahead of the teams going all the way back to 8th so I felt the need to shore up my WR2 spot and make a run. Team getting Cobb is currently in last
Losing the 2nd hurts a little, but I still have two 1st and one 2nd so I can have my fun with the draft
Gave Randall Cobb, mid 2nd
Got DeSean Jackson, 4th
Currently sitting 4th in the standings with a good team but the Cobb injury hurt and I have been playing WR2-3 committee with Douglas/Sanders/Williams/Hartline. Only one gr ahead of the teams going all the way back to 8th so I felt the need to shore up my WR2 spot and make a run. Team getting Cobb is currently in last
I would probably draft Cobb ahead of Djax during the offseason, but I consider them equals now. IMO, The only advantage Cobb has is his age, but that's made up by the fact that DeSean is producing top 5 numbers right now and it fills a HUGE hole for me. Iv also never really believed Cobb was a special talent. I think DeSean is better but Rodgers is obviously much better than Foles/Vick.
Losing the 2nd hurts a little, but I still have two 1st and one 2nd so I can have my fun with the draft
Adam Harstad
Moderator
A/B seems like a classic win/win between rebuilding and contending teams. In a vacuum, give me the pick.
Give me Julio.
Barring any unusual scoring or roster requirements, give me Williams and the pick.
Give me Ivory.
Give me Brady/Bowe.
