Thunderlips said:
I thought the show was well done execpt for Kristen Ritter. She was a little too deadpan and didn't seem to have a good range of emotions. She did snark, sarcasm and contrite well......but when it came time for her to really showcase some emotion(which I think was important with the character).....she fell flat.
Interesting. My initial reaction is that I'm not sure it would fit the character for her to show too much other emotions. I felt like the snark, etc, were her way of dealing with the world. That it should be pretty rare when you get something else, and even then it would be reined in and reluctant.
Example, the handling of "I love you" was very fitting for the character. If it was a big emotional buildup it would have felt like it was just there for the sake of having one in the show rather than because it fit her.
Another example, you knew she loved Luke but couldn't/wouldn't let it show overtly. And that is one of her flaws as a character. That was part of what gave me empathy for her and had me liking the character. (Edit to add: It also is what made that scene when she snuggles up to Luke's unconscious body more of a powerful moment. A rare time she was comfortable letting her guard down and her emotions for him truly show because he wasn't able to witness it.)
Overall, I think bottling up those emotions kept the character feeling more real to me.