Fantasy Football - Footballguys Forums
This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!
***Official Soccer Discussion Thread*** (1 Viewer)
- Thread starter jpeace121
- Start date
jonessed
Footballguy
Are you even watching the game?
I know what I saw. And the second angle confirmed what I initially thought--dive.
Ursa M
Footballguy
No, I'm at work, which is why I'm following two British commentaries from two independent agencies, both of whom say it was the right call. Perhaps I should just follow the commentary from an ABU like yourself for a completely unbiased opinion.
jonessed
Footballguy
Biased? Against what? Divers?Your second quote actually points to a dive. Why don't you watch the game and then come back and comment.
Last edited by a moderator:
jonessed
Footballguy
You do realize he's not actually watching the game right?'guru_007 said:
prefontaine
Footballguy
It appears they are starting Lichaj on whichever side has the speedier winger. The last game I saw him he played on the right vs Cole/Sturridge and now left vs Valencia. He's not exactly getting the easy assignments but my guess is Mcleish is matching up based on speed. Honestly he's looked both quicker and faster than them all. Amazing for a guy his size.
jonessed
Footballguy
The last time you started this kind of fishing trip you felt that not only was the referee right, but Ferguson was wrong.
When you are caught out-spinning Ferguson your credibility goesThat's a tough call to make in the 89' minute, at Old Trafford.He had position, he has assistant referees, he immediately signaled play on.Good, definitive call, by an up and coming referee.
jonessed
Footballguy
That might benefit him for US placement as well as Klinsmann seems more flexible than Bradley. Bradley really only used him on the left as a last resort.
Last edited by a moderator:
NewlyRetired
Footballguy
I agree. I have him as part of my 23 right now. Should be a good battle between him and Fabian for the starting left back slot.
Last edited by a moderator:
Ursa M
Footballguy
I was posting two commentaries that said it was a penalty and/or it was controversial (which doesn't mean it wasn't). That's it, really.You do realize he's not actually watching the game right?'guru_007 said:
Good Posting Judge
Footballguy
Glad Cuenca's dive yesterday isn't getting this much hate. 
NewlyRetired
Footballguy
US Final 23 and stand by speculation
Notes:
*I have removed Buddle from consideration as he is now being benched by LA. If he can find his form again, I will add him.
*Benny is back from injury and I will keep an eye on him
*Cooper and Wondo are going to give Klinsmann some extra choices. Might even see both of them get picked and bump Boyd
*I am getting nervous about Gooch. If he does not return to action by the end of April/early May I will remove him
Keeper:
1) Tim Howard
2) Brad Guzan
3) Nick Rimando
Right Back
4) Steve Cherundolo
5) Timmy Chandler
Right Center Back
6) Oguchi Onyewu
7) Clarence Goodson
Left Center Back
8) Carlos Bocanegra
9) Tim Ream
Left Back
10) Fabian Johnson
11) Eric Lichai
Utility defender
12) Jonathan Spector
Holding/Defensive/Central Midfielders
13) Michael Bradley
14) Jermaine Jones
15) Maurice Edu
Offensive midfielders/wide players
16) Clint Dempsey
17) Landon Donovan
18) Brek Shea
19) Jose Torres
Forwards
20) Jozy Altidore
21) Herculez Gomez
22) Terrance Boyd
23) The most in form of Chris Wondoloski/CJ Sappong/Kenny Cooper
JK also mentioned he will have a list of stand by players but won't call them into camp.
Stand By
Keeper: Bill Hamid
Defenders: Geoff Cameron/George John/Edgar Castillo/Michael Parkhurst
Midfielders: Sacha Kljestan/Kyle Beckerman/Freddy Adu/Danny Williams/Graham Zusi/Mix Diskerud
Forwards: See 23 above for whom ever is not picked as the last forward.
Notes:
*I have removed Buddle from consideration as he is now being benched by LA. If he can find his form again, I will add him.
*Benny is back from injury and I will keep an eye on him
*Cooper and Wondo are going to give Klinsmann some extra choices. Might even see both of them get picked and bump Boyd
*I am getting nervous about Gooch. If he does not return to action by the end of April/early May I will remove him
Keeper:
1) Tim Howard
2) Brad Guzan
3) Nick Rimando
Right Back
4) Steve Cherundolo
5) Timmy Chandler
Right Center Back
6) Oguchi Onyewu
7) Clarence Goodson
Left Center Back
8) Carlos Bocanegra
9) Tim Ream
Left Back
10) Fabian Johnson
11) Eric Lichai
Utility defender
12) Jonathan Spector
Holding/Defensive/Central Midfielders
13) Michael Bradley
14) Jermaine Jones
15) Maurice Edu
Offensive midfielders/wide players
16) Clint Dempsey
17) Landon Donovan
18) Brek Shea
19) Jose Torres
Forwards
20) Jozy Altidore
21) Herculez Gomez
22) Terrance Boyd
23) The most in form of Chris Wondoloski/CJ Sappong/Kenny Cooper
JK also mentioned he will have a list of stand by players but won't call them into camp.
Stand By
Keeper: Bill Hamid
Defenders: Geoff Cameron/George John/Edgar Castillo/Michael Parkhurst
Midfielders: Sacha Kljestan/Kyle Beckerman/Freddy Adu/Danny Williams/Graham Zusi/Mix Diskerud
Forwards: See 23 above for whom ever is not picked as the last forward.
Last edited by a moderator:
jonessed
Footballguy
You would have to find a La Liga watcher that isn't a Barca fan around here. I think that pretty much leaves just Z.Glad Cuenca's dive yesterday isn't getting this much hate.
Steve Tasker
Footballguy
What's an "ABU"?
I didn't see the dive either, I was in the car. The Sirius/XM announcers didn't make it sound that bad, but they were pretty clearly biased in favor of United. I'll have to see it to judge for myself.
Steve Tasker
Footballguy
I pretty much agree with all of this, my only real question is why Rimando ahead of Hamid? Hamid is the first potential successor to Howard that we've seen emerge, I think - why not bring him in for some experience? Is it because he looked poor in the Olympic qualifying? Is he still hurt from that injury (I don't actually know, though I'm guessing it's not serious cause you have him in the stand-by list)?I don't have a problem with Rimando, but he's a known commodity at this point and he's 32. If I were selecting a team to take to the World Cup today, I'd agree that Rimando should be in it. Just wondering your thoughts...
Also, I think it says a lot about the overall quality (which is to say - not very high quality at this point at the international level) of the USMNT strikers if you consider the volatility in the position. Altidore is and should be the top guy, and I'd think that Agudelo stays in the picture if healthy. But consider that 2 of the 4 strikers that the USMNT took to the 2010 Cup have barely featured at all for the USMNT since then (Findley, Buddle....Buddle has made some appearances, but has Findley? I honestly can't recall any caps for him since the Cup), and the 3rd (Gomez) was on the absolute fringe of the squad until going on a tear. Just a few months ago we were lamenting the lack of really ANY good strikers for the USMNT, and now heading into qualifying, the USMNT has 4 of the strikers in the best form that I can ever recall a group of strikers having at the same time (Altidore, Gomez, Cooper, Wondo). And after all that, you've got the ultimate wildcard in Boyd, who hasn't even featured for his club at the senior level yet might bump one of the 4 listed above.
Last edited by a moderator:
Ursa M
Footballguy
ABU = Anybody But United. Apart from being the best supported team in the world (with the exception of maybe Barca), they are also the most hated, by a country mile.What's an "ABU"?
Steve Tasker
Footballguy
Also, the guys on the radio this morning had an interesting brief discussion at halftime of United/Villa. Chelsea have 4 games in 10 days against world-class competition (Spurs today, Barca, Arsenal, Barca). What do you do if you're the manager? The in-studio Chelsea fan/season-ticket holder says that he would play is best XI against Barcelona and that staying alive in the Champions League should be the top priority. What would you do? I know Christo in particular has stressed that he holds winning the league in higher regard than winning the Champions League. But Chelsea isn't going to win the league....but in all likelihood, they're not going to get past Barca anyway even if they play their best side. Tough decisions.
And as I type this, Drogba scores a great goal.
And as I type this, Drogba scores a great goal.
prefontaine
Footballguy
I find it odd how as this topic has reared it's head for the second time in a week, this is the defense of homerism both times. There's really not a lot of hate here for anyone. A dive by any other name is still a dive and it has nothing to do with what color shirt the diver is wearing.'Ursa M said:ABU = Anybody But United. Apart from being the best supported team in the world (with the exception of maybe Barca), they are also the most hated, by a country mile.'Steve Tasker said:What's an "ABU"?'Ursa M said:
prefontaine
Footballguy
They're out of the EPL race, an almost impossible task in CL. So put your best XI out today and then see if they've still got enough gas in the tank to get a result against Barca mid-week.
And right before half-time, too. What a morale killer for Spurs.
jonessed
Footballguy
You are going to come here and start calling people out as innately biased for an opinion on a play you haven't even seen? Do you have any idea how hypocritcal that sounds?'Ursa M said:ABU = Anybody But United. Apart from being the best supported team in the world (with the exception of maybe Barca), they are also the most hated, by a country mile.'Steve Tasker said:What's an "ABU"?'Ursa M said:
Last edited by a moderator:
jonessed
Footballguy
Spurs have had their chances. A lot of times in these close matches it simply comes down to who can finish. Possession doesn't mean squat if you can't finish.And right before half-time, too. What a morale killer for Spurs.
Last edited by a moderator:
CL is the highest regarded trophy in the World.No team/manager/supporter holds a league title in higher regard than CL trophy.If Chelsea had their choice it would be:CL Trophy 1CL qualifying 2FA cup 3
prefontaine
Footballguy
the other side of the coin is that their odds of winning CL are very low. And it's entirely possible if you put all your eggs in the champions league basket you come up completely empty. You have to weigh your odds here. For this reason, I don't think it's a straightforward call. Personally given their form and the cup situation, I'd go for top 4/FA and punt CL this season. But Roman would have sacked me long ago.
jonessed
Footballguy
The fact that Terry is playing today with cracked ribs seems to indicate they like their odds here more than the Barca match.Their chances in CL are slim to none this year. I can't see how the League isn't first priority probably followed by the FA Cup.
Steve Tasker
Footballguy
I think I recall Christo saying this in this very thread (I don't mean to put words in his mouth if he didn't). I'd think you're right in that almost all people would hold the CL in higher regard than the league, and Chelsea has a chance (albeit very slim) to win the CL and no chance to win the league, so in that sense your decision makes sense. But finishing top 4 has a significant financial impact as well.
I was hoping that someone who has lived over there (Eephus, Christo [i think?], etc.) had an opinion on it. From an American standpoint, being removed from the actual "daily life" of European football, I view the CL as the ultimate title as well. Just wondering if others had a different perspective.
Last edited by a moderator:
prefontaine
Footballguy
goal line technology please
Steve Tasker
Footballguy
Almost certainly didn't go in.
Steve Tasker
Footballguy
That one did, though. I do hate Spurs, but they don't deserve to be losing this game after that phantom goal.
prefontaine
Footballguy
I hate that rule but if Bale is not there, Cech is sent off yeah? Then shouldn't he be sent off anyway?
Steve Tasker
Footballguy
I think he sprained his ###### on that one
ffldrew
Footballguy
He went for the ball and Abedyor went over the core of his body - IMO if the arm went out to get him then yes - but Cech looked like he went straight for the ball - and actually got part of it.
derek245583
Footballguy
I dont even pretend to know half as much about soccer as most here, but this is what I thought...How does a goal disallow a sending off?Tottenham should get the option...penalty kick and a red card or take the goal and play on
prefontaine
Footballguy
It's not Chelsea's fault that the ref has made a mess of this, but I do find myself rooting for Spurs now (plus always want an epic match)
Similar threads
