From the 2 scouting reports, which CB would you rather have:
Player A:
Read & React: Reads routes well and starts to close when receivers throttle down to catch curl or hitch. Sniffs out bubble screens. Gets fooled on double moves and misdirection when receivers and backs sell their routes. Recognizes run immediately in man or zone coverage and gets around the receiver to make the play.
Man Coverage: His size makes him a prototypical outside corner, able to stay with NFL pass-catchers down the sideline. Usually matches up with opponent's biggest receiver. Shows relatively quick feet when in the slot. Mirrors receivers on most straight-line routes but struggles to stop and return on throws behind him. Stays too high in his pedal, however, lets receivers eat up cushion too quickly. Needs to play more physically; usually plays well off the receiver, fails to land his hands when on the line. Gets pushed around too easily, allowing separation outside.
Zone Coverage: Practiced as a zone defender. Comes off of initial target a bit late, but gets to the ball in a hurry once he picks up the quarterback's read. Adjusts to jerk routes and can change his angle on the fly. Gets a hand on passes thrown over his head when underneath. Lacks great suddenness to change direction with quick slot receivers over the middle.
Closing/Recovery: A bit slow transitioning forward to plant and drive, but likes to make big hits and is tough for receivers to escape when he closes. Owns only adequate hands for the interception; picks off some easy passes but drops high and wide throws when in position to make the play. Able to knock away passes by swiping his long arm in front of receivers and winning jump balls. Lacks recovery speed if beaten off the line and does not gain ground running down the field.
Run Support: Solid run defender on the edge. Not afraid to take on large outside receivers and reacts quickly to get around potential blockers to make the tackle on running plays to his side of the field. Gets outside of the blocker to funnel plays back inside, but could do a better job shedding blocks when he's not able to elude them. Takes deep angles to be a last line of defense.
Tackling: Inconsistent tackler who displays the length and aggressiveness to wrap up ballcarriers but lacks great strength. Like to hit running backs on the edge and usually leads with a shoulder. Gives good effort, coming off his man to help teammates and laying out to make ankle tackles. Blitzes effectively due to his straight-line speed and size. Height can be a detriment against smaller, quicker ballcarriers; will leave his feet instead of dropping his hips to wrap and tackle. Gets dragged for extra yardage by stronger receivers.
Player B:
Read & React: Has excellent speed and quickness to close on plays in front of him. Senses double moves and stays with his man down the sideline. Uses his straight-line speed to reach plays away from him to help pull down ballcarriers downfield. Can be slow to read receivers' eyes, but usually recovers to make a tackle or get a hand on the ball.
Man Coverage: Typically played man, up on the line and also well off to prevent big plays. Has lateral and straight-line quickness and is able to run with any receiver down the field or over the middle. Mirrors routes very well, can stop and start as well as any corner in the country. He has receiver-like hands on interceptions, excellent hand-eye coordination and body control to knock away passes in front of the receiver without drawing a flag. High-points jump balls using good position, height and vertical leap. Athletic enough to recover when he's a step late recognizing a pass coming in his direction. Must stay in his backpedal longer, gets high too quickly out of his stance, flips his hips early, and stays on the balls of his feet -- all of which will allow NFL receivers to get open on quick cuts and inside slants.
Zone Coverage: Though potentially better in man, has a chance to play in an NFL zone system. Fluid enough to get into his zone quickly, keeps his head on a swivel to see receivers in his area. Good closing speed to balls in front or to the side of him, able to get to the ball before receiver secures the ball. Capable tackler on plays in front of him to prevent yards after the catch.
Closing/Recovery: Closes with a burst but plays under control, whether attacking receivers in front of him or on the blitz. Good recovery speed to get back to receiver if he is beat initially inside or down the sideline. Times jumps well to knock away high passes or get in front of the receiver without interfering.
Run Support: Not the most physical cornerback, but is aggressive to the ball against the run and bubble screens. Very effective cut tackler to knock down backs coming in his area. Gets to the ballcarrier's outside shoulder to force plays to the linebackers and safeties inside. His slight frame allows larger, aggressive receivers to push him around on the edge despite his willingness mix it up. Works to get through those blocks, sometimes getting to the ballcarrier despite being held up initially.
Tackling: Likes to throw his body into the play but lacks strength and is very inconsistent in his fundamentals. Makes open-field tackles against receivers and as a gunner on special teams units. Closes quickly, mirroring lateral movement, and breaking down to get a hand on elusive ballcarriers. Capable of planting receivers when staying square and moving his feet through the ball. Will chase plays on his side of the field. Throws a shoulder into running backs when supporting the run near the line, but fails to consistently keep his head up and wrap, allowing them to bounce off to extend the play. Larger receivers and quarterbacks can shed his tackle attempts when he does not stay square and low.