Andre Carter may be the odd man out in Redskins' switch to 3-4 defense
Carter's stats in his lone year as a linebacker were solid -- he was credited with 58 tackles and 4.5 sacks -- but those familiar with the year said he was uncomfortable standing up and lacked the natural instincts to drop back in pass coverage.
As they review tape, Redskins coaches have surely noted this and it's part of the reason Carter is more of a question mark this offseason. He's probably too small to play defensive end in a 3-4 defense, and if the Redskins sign a linebacker such as Larry Foote, Rocky McIntosh could slide over to the outside linebacker slot and Carter would be the odd man out. Just a couple months after one of the most successful seasons of his career -- he had 11 sacks and was credited with 62 total tackles -- Carter could find himself in a place of uncertainty.
I realize that's just speculation. I hope it doesn't work out that way because it doesn't seem like the best use of team personnel. Carter was in the best shape of his career last year and had a very good year. Moving him aside seems counterproductive.
This is what I've been saying. Their personnel is built around a 4-3 lineup, and obviously that's not by accident. Fletcher is tiny for a 3-4 LB, as is Blades. McIntosh is even a tad small as a 3-4 OLB, and also isn't anything special rushing the passer. Carter
is too small to be a 3-4 DE, by at least 30 lbs. Their DT's, with the possible exception of Monty, are 4-3 undertackles who are smaller but quicker upfield, or in the case of Haynesworth is huge but is also meant to penetrate rather than hold the line (and who will rebel at being told to do otherwise - besides, he's paid to be a playmaker rather than a NT). I'm not even convinced that Orakpo is really any good at dropping back into coverage the way that 3-4 OLB's occasionally need to do (and if he's not required to do this, isn't this still a 4-3 defense then?). The only guy who's really a good fit is Daniels by virtue of his ability to be a good, large and strong 3-4 DE, but Daniels is about the last guy you'd want to build a defense around.
This is Haslett building a defense around what he likes rather than what he has. I don't like this plan at all.