What's new
Fantasy Football - Footballguys Forums

Welcome to Our Forums. Once you've registered and logged in, you're primed to talk football, among other topics, with the sharpest and most experienced fantasy players on the internet.

One Year Later: Re-Drafting the 2018 NFL Draft (1 Viewer)

Bracie Smathers

Footballguy
Interesting how they draft based on value of position.

In reverse order from pick #32  down to #1, only listing the top/bottom dozen picks.

Go  to link for full list.  >>>  One Year Later: Re-Drafting the 2018 NFL Draft

32. Baltimore Ravens — WR D.J. Moore 

Moore really came on strong for the Panthers during the second half of the year. The explosive pass catcher hauled in 55 passes for 788 yards — including a jaw-dropping seven-catch, 157-yard effort against the Detroit Lions in Week 11. The Ravens bolstered their receiving corps this past offseason with the additions of Michael Crabtree, John Brown, and Willie Snead, but none of those players boast the ceiling of the 21-year-old Moore.

31. New England Patriots — RB Sony Michel

While the Patriots could use help in other areas, it’s truly hard to argue they made the wrong pick by selecting Michel. The former Georgia runner has been brilliant — especially towards the end of the season. Including the playoffs, Michel has put together six 100-plus yard games on the ground. He would have topped the 1,000-yard rushing mark on the season had he not been forced to miss three games.

30. Minnesota VikingsCB Donte Jackson

The speedy Jackson is a game breaker in every sense. The LSU product is electric with the ball in his hands, and possesses the closing speed to keep up with even the quickest of receivers. The Vikings appeared to have whiffed on UCF corner Mike Hughes. With Xavier Rhodes taking a step back this past season, Minnesota could use all the help it can get in the secondary.

29. Jacksonville JaguarsOG James Daniels

Arguably the most disappointing team of the season, the Jaguars floundered to a 5-11 record just a year after an AFC Championship game appearance. Their lack of offensive identity was troublesome. Ultimately, it led to the breaking down of their star-studded defense — which routinely was put in a position of trying to bail Blake Bortles and the offense out. Adding a road grader like Daniels would help clear some lanes for whichever running back (preferably a healthy Leonard Fournette) they choose to trot out every Sunday.

28. Pittsburgh SteelersS Justin Reid

Reid is a ballhawk on the back end. He’s unafraid of taking calculated risks to force turnovers. He even outplayed marquee free agent and fellow Texans safety Tyrann Mathieu at times. Reid would be able to instantly step in and fill the shoes of veteran Morgan Burnett (who is rumored to want out of Pittsburgh either way).

27. Seattle SeahawksRB Philip Lindsay

No undrafted player has ever rushed for more yards in their rookie season than the Broncos’ first-year stud. The diminutive Lindsay would be adored by a Seahawks fan base whom are all too familiar with players labeled as “too small” (see: Russell Wilson).  His short-area quickness and burst would be a nice change-of-pace for the bruising Chris Carson.

26. Atlanta FalconsWR Courtland Sutton

The Falcons desperately need a true No. 2 receiver opposite Julio Jones. Mohamed Sanu is a great short-yardage route-runner, but lacks the consistency to be much more than a gadget player. Losing Taylor Gabriel hurt more than they expected. Sutton is a big target, and is poised to be a serious threat in the red zone for years to come.

25. Baltimore Ravens RB Nick Chubb

A switch to a run-heavy approach seemed to have worked wonders for a traditionally stagnant Ravens offense. They would love to move up and grab their quarterback of the future in Lamar Jackson, but the price might be too steep. Chubb is an every-down back with the ability to bust any play for a long gain.

24. Carolina PanthersEDGE Marcus Davenport

Carolina’s once-vaunted defense took a nosedive in 2018. The Panthers relied on Cam Newton, Christian McCaffrey and a high-powered offense to keep them in games. However once Newton was injured, the Panthers were finished. Davenport would have been a nice addition to a team that didn’t have a single player finish in the top-20 in sacks this past season.

23. New England PatriotsOG Braden Smith

New England’s original 23rd selection, Georgia guard Isaiah Wynn, was forced to miss the entire season due to a torn Achilles. The unfortunate injury makes one think just how good the Patriots offensive line could have been had Wynn been able to stay healthy. Smith was awesome all year long for a Colts line which made the case as being the best unit in the league.

22. Tennessee Titans — LB Rashaan Evans

Don’t sleep on Tennessee’s defense. After the Chicago Bears, there may not be a team filled with more blue-chip players that haven’t even reached the apex of their potential yet. Evans — along with Harold Landry, Adoree Jackson, and Kevin Byard — make up the core for one of the scariest units in the league.

21. Cincinnati Bengals — EDGE Sam Hubbard

Cincinnati found a steal in the third round. Hubbard has all the tools of an elite pass rusher. He totaled 6.0 sacks on the season. At 6’5″, Hubbard boasts great size, and possesses an excellent first step for a 265-pound lineman. He is the perfect complement to a defensive line that already has two All-Pro talents in Geno Atkins and Carlos Dunlap.

20. Detroit Lions — DT Vita Vea

Original first-round pick Frank Ragnow wasn’t awful in his rookie season. With Matt Patricia at the helm, you would have liked to see Detroit make a more concerted effort in bringing in blue-chip defensive players. Vea has a near-unlimited ceiling, but was a bit of a disappointment in his rookie season. Missing almost the entire summer didn’t help, and Vea has only began to scratch the surface of his immense talents.

 
While I like the idea of redrafting as a way of post-grading draft classes, its hard to do after 1 season. That said, this isn't very good at all in my opinion. I feel like the writer didn't watch a lot of these guys. 

 
if you're doing a redraft, wouldn't you slot the Eagles at #32?  Ravens would not have traded up into the 1st for a WR

 
Too much QB love, and too anchored on the actual draft order. Josh Rosen doesn't belong in the top half of the first, let alone the top 3. And as much as I liked Roquan Smith as a prospect, he has clearly been leapfrogged by Vander Esch and should not go 8 picks ahead of him. Ignoring the team picking, I'll put the top 8 as:

1. Baker Mayfield
2. Denzel Ward
3. Leighton Vander Esch
4. Saquon Barkley
5. Darius Leonard
6. Sam Darnold
7. Derwin James
8. Quenton Nelson

Though pretty much any reshuffling of 2-8 would seem reasonable. After that it becomes much more about potential rather than performance so far.

 
Too much QB love, and too anchored on the actual draft order. 
I agree with the first half of this statement, but shouldn't anchoring be a feature, not a bug? 16 games (or less in many cases) is hardly a large enough sample size to confidently upend the original draft order.

 
I agree with the first half of this statement, but shouldn't anchoring be a feature, not a bug? 16 games (or less in many cases) is hardly a large enough sample size to confidently upend the original draft order.
It's definitely good to take actual draft order into account as well as their performance as rookies, but when you have first round picks who played at a Pro Bowl level as rookies it's pretty hard to justify keeping them behind earlier first rounders who we're still waiting on.

 
It's definitely good to take actual draft order into account as well as their performance as rookies, but when you have first round picks who played at a Pro Bowl level as rookies it's pretty hard to justify keeping them behind earlier first rounders who we're still waiting on.
Yes, tough balancing act on rookie performance and future prospects. Derwin was amazing (and probably should have been taken higher in the first place) so he has to fly up boards as he already looks like a top 5 S in the NFL. Calvin Ridley had a really good year but not dominant and not enough for me to really move him up. I stll like DJ Moore more. 

 

Users who are viewing this thread

Top