opinions wanted on fairness of a deal (1 Viewer)

[After the Rain]

I'm not sure if this is the right place or not but I would be happy to post elsewhere if this is the inappropriate forum. For now, I'll go ahead and try here.

There was a trade made on Saturday that has raised some controversy. Team A (experienced owner) made a trade where they gave up Julius Jones, Ahman Green, Roddy White and Jerry Porter. Team B (new owner) gave up Brian Westbrook, Maurice Morris, Reggie Brown, and Mercedes Lewis.

The trade leaves Team A with the following:

RB (start 2)--Westbrook, T Jones, M Morris, K Keith, A Peterson (Chi)

WR (start 3)--Fitz, S Smith, Galloway, Calvin Johnson

Team B has the following now:

RB--Henry, A Green, J Jones, D Ward, Dayne

WR--don't recall exactly but White will be an every week starter, Porter may or may not start each week.

Team A gains a lot in their starting lineup, making them very strong. Team B gets some more starters but loses the best player (by far).

Do those who are taking issue with the trade have a legitimate gripe?

Thanks in advance!

 

[beavers]

I'm not sure if this is the right place or not but I would be happy to post elsewhere if this is the inappropriate forum. For now, I'll go ahead and try here.There was a trade made on Saturday that has raised some controversy. Team A (experienced owner) made a trade where they gave up Julius Jones, Ahman Green, Roddy White and Jerry Porter. Team B (new owner) gave up Brian Westbrook, Maurice Morris, Reggie Brown, and Mercedes Lewis.The trade leaves Team A with the following:RB (start 2)--Westbrook, T Jones, M Morris, K Keith, A Peterson (Chi)WR (start 3)--Fitz, S Smith, Galloway, Calvin JohnsonTeam B has the following now:RB--Henry, A Green, J Jones, D Ward, DayneWR--don't recall exactly but White will be an every week starter, Porter may or may not start each week.Team A gains a lot in their starting lineup, making them very strong. Team B gets some more starters but loses the best player (by far).Do those who are taking issue with the trade have a legitimate gripe?Thanks in advance!

You were a member since 2003 and you don't know if this is the right forum?

 

[Wu-banger]

B gets decent players to make overall team better .....

A gets 1 great player to make his lineup better....

both teams improved themselves , thats the goal of any trade.

 

[eom]

I don't think I want any of those players.