What's new
Fantasy Football - Footballguys Forums

Welcome to Our Forums. Once you've registered and logged in, you're primed to talk football, among other topics, with the sharpest and most experienced fantasy players on the internet.

Oreo: cookie or cream filling (3 Viewers)

What is your favorite part of an Oreo?

  • cookie

    Votes: 65 39.2%

  • cream filling

    Votes: 101 60.8%
  • Total voters
    166
Z

zed2283

Footballguy
It has recently, shockingly, come to my attention that some people actually like the cookie part of an Oreo more than the cream filling. I'd never heard of such a thing. So I decided a poll would be in order.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
Mr. Pickles said:
If I could buy just the cookies, I would. The cream is superfluous fluff.
Click to expand...
You used to be able to. It was used as an ingredient in some pies (crush the cookies to make the pie crust.) Haven't seen them that way for a while, but I have seen the premade oreo crust pie pans, so maybe once they did that there was no need for just the cookie.

 
When the deliciousness of a cookie increases proportionally by the number of times it has been stuffed with cream filling, you know that the cream filling is the favorite.

First, it was the Double-Stuffed Oreo, whose introduction changed the way America looked at Oreos. No longer was a single stuffing of cream filling adequate to satiate our desires. This was no passing fad, as Double-Stuffed Oreos were here to stay. I wondered what might happen if Nabisco dared to take the next step to triple stuffing; however, the Triple-Stuffed Oreo seemed like a pipe dream at the time.

Then, Nabisco went and blew my mind with the recent introduction of the MEGA-Stuffed Oreo. The American public demanded yet another stuffing of cream filling, and Nabisco delivered. The MEGA-Stuffed Oreo was another step of improvement beyond the Double-Stuffed variety.

We can only hope that somewhere out there at the Nabisco R&D facility there is a flavor engineer with the balls to take us to the final frontier - the Quadruple-Stuffed Oreo.

 
The poll is a red herring, since the only proper answer is that they're delicious together. However, the cookie itself has far greater milk dunkability, thus giving it the automatic win by first-round KO.

 
Tiger Fan said:
It blows my mind why they don't sell just the cream filling in a tub
Click to expand...
:goodposting:

When I was a kid, after opening the Oreo, I used to use one side to scrape/pull the creme filling off the other side, then I'd leave the filling on a plate for later. After going through a whole sleeve, I'd have eaten all the cookie halves, then be left with a ball of creme filling bigger than a golf ball. Eat that like an apple. Heavenly.

 
Sarnoff said:
Tiger Fan said:
It blows my mind why they don't sell just the cream filling in a tub
Click to expand...
:goodposting:

When I was a kid, after opening the Oreo, I used to use one side to scrape/pull the creme filling off the other side, then I'd leave the filling on a plate for later. After going through a whole sleeve, I'd have eaten all the cookie halves, then be left with a ball of creme filling bigger than a golf ball. Eat that like an apple. Heavenly.
Click to expand...
I did something similar. I would scrape the cream out with a butter knife and stack them up. Then I would force myself to eat all the remaining cookies before starting in on the stack of cream. Mmmmm...

Really, I'm not even sure why they still sell the regular kind of Oreos, the Double-Stuft are the bomb.

 
Buckfast 1 said:
When the deliciousness of a cookie increases proportionally by the number of times it has been stuffed with cream filling, you know that the cream filling is the favorite.First, it was the Double-Stuffed Oreo, whose introduction changed the way America looked at Oreos. No longer was a single stuffing of cream filling adequate to satiate our desires. This was no passing fad, as Double-Stuffed Oreos were here to stay. I wondered what might happen if Nabisco dared to take the next step to triple stuffing; however, the Triple-Stuffed Oreo seemed like a pipe dream at the time.Then, Nabisco went and blew my mind with the recent introduction of the MEGA-Stuffed Oreo. The American public demanded yet another stuffing of cream filling, and Nabisco delivered. The MEGA-Stuffed Oreo was another step of improvement beyond the Double-Stuffed variety.We can only hope that somewhere out there at the Nabisco R&D facility there is a flavor engineer with the balls to take us to the final frontier - the Quadruple-Stuffed Oreo.
Click to expand...
I haven't seen this. Where can I find them???

 
zed2283 said:
Buckfast 1 said:
When the deliciousness of a cookie increases proportionally by the number of times it has been stuffed with cream filling, you know that the cream filling is the favorite.

First, it was the Double-Stuffed Oreo, whose introduction changed the way America looked at Oreos. No longer was a single stuffing of cream filling adequate to satiate our desires. This was no passing fad, as Double-Stuffed Oreos were here to stay. I wondered what might happen if Nabisco dared to take the next step to triple stuffing; however, the Triple-Stuffed Oreo seemed like a pipe dream at the time.

Then, Nabisco went and blew my mind with the recent introduction of the MEGA-Stuffed Oreo. The American public demanded yet another stuffing of cream filling, and Nabisco delivered. The MEGA-Stuffed Oreo was another step of improvement beyond the Double-Stuffed variety.

We can only hope that somewhere out there at the Nabisco R&D facility there is a flavor engineer with the balls to take us to the final frontier - the Quadruple-Stuffed Oreo.
Click to expand...
I haven't seen this. Where can I find them???
Click to expand...
MEGA STUF Oreoshttp://www.amazon.com/gp/aw/d/B00BBKGVNI/ref=redir_mdp_mobile

I think they are generally available at most grocery stores, although they are supposedly only a limited time item.

 
zed2283 said:
Sarnoff said:
Tiger Fan said:
It blows my mind why they don't sell just the cream filling in a tub
Click to expand...
:goodposting:

When I was a kid, after opening the Oreo, I used to use one side to scrape/pull the creme filling off the other side, then I'd leave the filling on a plate for later. After going through a whole sleeve, I'd have eaten all the cookie halves, then be left with a ball of creme filling bigger than a golf ball. Eat that like an apple. Heavenly.
Click to expand...
I did something similar. I would scrape the cream out with a butter knife and stack them up. Then I would force myself to eat all the remaining cookies before starting in on the stack of cream. Mmmmm...

Really, I'm not even sure why they still sell the regular kind of Oreos, the Double-Stuft are the bomb.
Click to expand...
When I was kid, (7-8 years old) I licked all the cream off the cookies, then put the cookies back in the bag,

I received one of the worst beatings in my life for that move.

 
Buckfast 1 said:
When the deliciousness of a cookie increases proportionally by the number of times it has been stuffed with cream filling, you know that the cream filling is the favorite.First, it was the Double-Stuffed Oreo, whose introduction changed the way America looked at Oreos. No longer was a single stuffing of cream filling adequate to satiate our desires. This was no passing fad, as Double-Stuffed Oreos were here to stay. I wondered what might happen if Nabisco dared to take the next step to triple stuffing; however, the Triple-Stuffed Oreo seemed like a pipe dream at the time.Then, Nabisco went and blew my mind with the recent introduction of the MEGA-Stuffed Oreo. The American public demanded yet another stuffing of cream filling, and Nabisco delivered. The MEGA-Stuffed Oreo was another step of improvement beyond the Double-Stuffed variety.We can only hope that somewhere out there at the Nabisco R&D facility there is a flavor engineer with the balls to take us to the final frontier - the Quadruple-Stuffed Oreo.
Click to expand...
:goodposting: This guy understands the world.

 
Buckfast 1 said:
When the deliciousness of a cookie increases proportionally by the number of times it has been stuffed with cream filling, you know that the cream filling is the favorite.First, it was the Double-Stuffed Oreo, whose introduction changed the way America looked at Oreos. No longer was a single stuffing of cream filling adequate to satiate our desires. This was no passing fad, as Double-Stuffed Oreos were here to stay. I wondered what might happen if Nabisco dared to take the next step to triple stuffing; however, the Triple-Stuffed Oreo seemed like a pipe dream at the time.Then, Nabisco went and blew my mind with the recent introduction of the MEGA-Stuffed Oreo. The American public demanded yet another stuffing of cream filling, and Nabisco delivered. The MEGA-Stuffed Oreo was another step of improvement beyond the Double-Stuffed variety.We can only hope that somewhere out there at the Nabisco R&D facility there is a flavor engineer with the balls to take us to the final frontier - the Quadruple-Stuffed Oreo.
Click to expand...
Of course, no matter how much they put in, we're all going to do the same thing. Take 2 cookies, remove a wafer from each one, then put the 2 wafers with cream together to double the white stuff.

 
Rayderr said:
Buckfast 1 said:
When the deliciousness of a cookie increases proportionally by the number of times it has been stuffed with cream filling, you know that the cream filling is the favorite.First, it was the Double-Stuffed Oreo, whose introduction changed the way America looked at Oreos. No longer was a single stuffing of cream filling adequate to satiate our desires. This was no passing fad, as Double-Stuffed Oreos were here to stay. I wondered what might happen if Nabisco dared to take the next step to triple stuffing; however, the Triple-Stuffed Oreo seemed like a pipe dream at the time.Then, Nabisco went and blew my mind with the recent introduction of the MEGA-Stuffed Oreo. The American public demanded yet another stuffing of cream filling, and Nabisco delivered. The MEGA-Stuffed Oreo was another step of improvement beyond the Double-Stuffed variety.We can only hope that somewhere out there at the Nabisco R&D facility there is a flavor engineer with the balls to take us to the final frontier - the Quadruple-Stuffed Oreo.
Click to expand...
Of course, no matter how much they put in, we're all going to do the same thing. Take 2 cookies, remove a wafer from each one, then put the 2 wafers with cream together to double the white stuff.
Click to expand...
Of course! Nothing can stop the innate human drive to achieve higher ratios of cream filling to chocolate cookie in Oreos.
 
Has anyone in history ever opened an Oreo, scraped out all the cream filling, stacked the two dry chocolate cookies back on top of each other, and then eaten the resulting un-stuffed Oreo?

I can't imagine such an abomination.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
Buckfast 1 said:
When the deliciousness of a cookie increases proportionally by the number of times it has been stuffed with cream filling, you know that the cream filling is the favorite. First, it was the Double-Stuffed Oreo, whose introduction changed the way America looked at Oreos. No longer was a single stuffing of cream filling adequate to satiate our desires. This was no passing fad, as Double-Stuffed Oreos were here to stay. I wondered what might happen if Nabisco dared to take the next step to triple stuffing; however, the Triple-Stuffed Oreo seemed like a pipe dream at the time. Then, Nabisco went and blew my mind with the recent introduction of the MEGA-Stuffed Oreo. The American public demanded yet another stuffing of cream filling, and Nabisco delivered. The MEGA-Stuffed Oreo was another step of improvement beyond the Double-Stuffed variety. We can only hope that somewhere out there at the Nabisco R&D facility there is a flavor engineer with the balls to take us to the final frontier - the Quadruple-Stuffed Oreo.
Click to expand...
I tried to like the mega-stuffed oreo, but it simply isn't the same as a double stuff. The double stuff is, IMO, the best cookie out there from mass production. Mega-stuffed cream filling just didn't taste the same to me. I prefer double stuff all day.

 
Jayrok said:
Buckfast 1 said:
When the deliciousness of a cookie increases proportionally by the number of times it has been stuffed with cream filling, you know that the cream filling is the favorite. First, it was the Double-Stuffed Oreo, whose introduction changed the way America looked at Oreos. No longer was a single stuffing of cream filling adequate to satiate our desires. This was no passing fad, as Double-Stuffed Oreos were here to stay. I wondered what might happen if Nabisco dared to take the next step to triple stuffing; however, the Triple-Stuffed Oreo seemed like a pipe dream at the time. Then, Nabisco went and blew my mind with the recent introduction of the MEGA-Stuffed Oreo. The American public demanded yet another stuffing of cream filling, and Nabisco delivered. The MEGA-Stuffed Oreo was another step of improvement beyond the Double-Stuffed variety. We can only hope that somewhere out there at the Nabisco R&D facility there is a flavor engineer with the balls to take us to the final frontier - the Quadruple-Stuffed Oreo.
Click to expand...
I tried to like the mega-stuffed oreo, but it simply isn't the same as a double stuff. The double stuff is, IMO, the best cookie out there from mass production. Mega-stuffed cream filling just didn't taste the same to me. I prefer double stuff all day.
Click to expand...
It's all about the ratio
 
Guster said:
Jayrok said:
Buckfast 1 said:
When the deliciousness of a cookie increases proportionally by the number of times it has been stuffed with cream filling, you know that the cream filling is the favorite. First, it was the Double-Stuffed Oreo, whose introduction changed the way America looked at Oreos. No longer was a single stuffing of cream filling adequate to satiate our desires. This was no passing fad, as Double-Stuffed Oreos were here to stay. I wondered what might happen if Nabisco dared to take the next step to triple stuffing; however, the Triple-Stuffed Oreo seemed like a pipe dream at the time. Then, Nabisco went and blew my mind with the recent introduction of the MEGA-Stuffed Oreo. The American public demanded yet another stuffing of cream filling, and Nabisco delivered. The MEGA-Stuffed Oreo was another step of improvement beyond the Double-Stuffed variety. We can only hope that somewhere out there at the Nabisco R&D facility there is a flavor engineer with the balls to take us to the final frontier - the Quadruple-Stuffed Oreo.
Click to expand...
I tried to like the mega-stuffed oreo, but it simply isn't the same as a double stuff. The double stuff is, IMO, the best cookie out there from mass production. Mega-stuffed cream filling just didn't taste the same to me. I prefer double stuff all day.
Click to expand...
It's all about the ratio
Click to expand...
But I don't think they use the same product for the filling in the mega stuffed. Or maybe I got a lame bag.

 
Cookie is better, and the original ones have the best ratio by far.

Original >> Double Stuf >> Mega Stuf

Now, Nutter Butters... that's a whole 'nother ball of filling.

 
You need both + milk for the magic to happen.

Double-stuff is a waste, and Mega Stuff is honestly a waste of resources. Just a "normal stuff" provides the correct cookie/icing ratio.

Oh, and Golden Oreos are the ambrosia of the Gods. Other than those, only the originals are worth my time.

 
Anyone can make that cream. It's the cookie part that sets Oreo apart from the competition.

 
zed2283 said:
Rohn Jambo said:
I suggest you guys kick the habit:

http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-2462624/Oreos-addictive-cocaine-Connecticut-College-scientists.html
Click to expand...
Dumb scientists. Rats (and people) prefer Oreos to ricecakes, so that makes them as addictive as cocaine. Riiiight... reading down to the bottom makes it look like another way they are trying to support their ridiculous notion that obesity be classified as a disease.
Click to expand...
It's true, man. Just the other day I saw some woman whoring her self so she could get her fix of Oreos.

 
I don't see these lasting long.


Oreo Thins Will Make You Feel Less Guilty About Eating The Entire PackageThe Huffington Post | By Carly Ledbetter
07/06/2015 12:05 am EDT

Updated: 07/06/2015 12:59 am EDT

Brace yourselves -- a new Oreo is hitting the shelves and this cookie has downsized. Welcome to the world, Oreo Thins:
Oreo announced the new, slimmer version of itself on Monday, though the new treat won't actually hit stores until July 13. Thins will come in three different varieties -- Original, Golden and Mint flavors -- with a suggested retail of $4.59.

The new Oreo Thins really do live up to their sleek name. The classic cookie is 12.5 mm thick, while this new cookie is 7.5mm thick. To get a better idea of how the cookies looks, from left to right, here's a Double Stuf Oreo, regular Oreo and the new Oreo Thins:

Despite its small size, multiple Huffington Post editors agreed that the Thin looks and tastes exactly like a regular Oreo, without feeling like a "diet" cookie (you know, those "fun" snack-sized Oreos that look and taste nothing like the real thing).

It may be hard to get over the somewhat-icky name, but the Thins aren't really a "diet" cookie at all, if that's what you're going for. According to the packaging, four Oreo Thins have 140 calories, 6 grams of fat and 12 grams of sugar, while three regular Oreos have 160 calories, 7 grams of fat and 14 grams of sugar. Either way you look at it, Oreos aren't ever going to be "healthy," but they will always be delicious.
Click to expand...
 
Last edited by a moderator:
The real Oreo question is which flavor is the best.

I vote smores, but birthday cake is pretty good too. Don't like the peanut butter or reese's versions.

 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

KarmaPolice
FBG Movie Club - DotM: Akira Kurosawa
2
Replies
57
Views
717
KarmaPolice
KarmaPolice
Zow
  • Poll
Could you eat the same thing every single day for at least one meal the rest of your life?
2 3
Replies
144
Views
4K
Pip's Invitation
Pip's Invitation
Max Power
32-Hour Work Week
3 4 5
Replies
239
Views
5K
Max Power
Max Power

Users who are viewing this thread

Total: 3 (members: 0, guests: 3)
Top