Pedroia or Hill? (1 Viewer)

[Galileo]

Which of these two would you prefer to keep and what could I expect to get in trade for the other from the team listed below?

I Rodriguez

R Howard

F Lopez

A Ramirez

J Peralta

C Beltran

Jason Bay

M Kemp

J Votto

Bench: I Stewart, R Ankiel

A Wainwright

B Lidge

B Myers

B Wilson

C Qualls

D Haren

G Meche

Bench

J Maine

K Escobar

K Davies

M Garza

M Scherzer

U Jimenez

My team:

C- Suzuki

1B - Delgado

2B - Hill

SS - J. Reyes

3B - Cantu

OF - Granderson, Lee, Duncan

DH - Pedroia

Bench - Kubel, Blalock, Atkins, Guerrero, Wieters

Pitching (start 7)

SP - Beckett, Cain, Gallaraga, Volquez, A. Reyes, Pelfrey, Lackey

RP - Bell, Broxton, Rodney

 

[cosjobs]

I'd try to get Kemp for Pedroia

 

[Galileo]

Hey "wine" how are you doing? (Galileo here)

While I could use the outfielder, I think this guy is much more likely to want to deal pitching if anything...

Also, as a follow up, I am thinking of picking up Hughes and/or Edwin Jackson...who would I cut loose to do this? Reyes? Pelfrey? I still think these guys can be productive this year even though Pelfrey is off to a horrific start. Also Lowell is available on waivers is he worth a pick up over Atkins?

 

[cosjobs]

Hey "wine" how are you doing? (Galileo here)While I could use the outfielder, I think this guy is much more likely to want to deal pitching if anything...Also, as a follow up, I am thinking of picking up Hughes and/or Edwin Jackson...who would I cut loose to do this? Reyes? Pelfrey? I still think these guys can be productive this year even though Pelfrey is off to a horrific start. Also Lowell is available on waivers is he worth a pick up over Atkins?

I'm good, thanksIMO he does not have a P worth pedroia.I like Hughes/Jackson both better than Pelfrey/Reyes, but you might could bundle those two with Pedrioa to bring in a quality player in return.

 

[Galileo]

Hey "wine" how are you doing? (Galileo here)While I could use the outfielder, I think this guy is much more likely to want to deal pitching if anything...Also, as a follow up, I am thinking of picking up Hughes and/or Edwin Jackson...who would I cut loose to do this? Reyes? Pelfrey? I still think these guys can be productive this year even though Pelfrey is off to a horrific start. Also Lowell is available on waivers is he worth a pick up over Atkins?

I'm good, thanksIMO he does not have a P worth pedroia.I like Hughes/Jackson both better than Pelfrey/Reyes, but you might could bundle those two with Pedrioa to bring in a quality player in return.

Wolf is another pitcher on waivers I am looking at to replace Reyes...I need to submit waivers by 5 PM today.I'd love to land Haren in some sort of deal from this other player. He has won the league a couple years in a row...he won't give up talent too easily.

 

[Galileo]

Does something like this seem plausible?

Pedroia/Delgado for Votto/Haren

 

[harryhood]

Picked up Hill due to the hot start and thought he would give me some early season help. He has been so consistent, but big Aprils are often times fools gold. Is this a guy who is peaking and can put up a monster season if healthy or is he a classic sell high scenario?

Before getting KTFO last year with that bad concussion, his 2007 was pretty nice. Did this guy just get overlooked in drafting?

I have a shot to land Roberts for Hill and Jair in a H2H points league but I have seen a lot of people saying they are holding this guy all year. Pedroia can definitely fetch more in a trade if you have them both, which like the OP, I do.

 

[Redwes25]

Picked up Hill due to the hot start and thought he would give me some early season help. He has been so consistent, but big Aprils are often times fools gold. Is this a guy who is peaking and can put up a monster season if healthy or is he a classic sell high scenario?Before getting KTFO last year with that bad concussion, his 2007 was pretty nice. Did this guy just get overlooked in drafting?I have a shot to land Roberts for Hill and Jair in a H2H points league but I have seen a lot of people saying they are holding this guy all year. Pedroia can definitely fetch more in a trade if you have them both, which like the OP, I do.

I drafted him in a very deep mixed league as my starting 2B thinking that last year was just a fluke injury year. I think expecting '07 numbers is what you will get and no way he keeps it up.