What's new
Fantasy Football - Footballguys Forums

Welcome to Our Forums. Once you've registered and logged in, you're primed to talk football, among other topics, with the sharpest and most experienced fantasy players on the internet.

PFW Grades (1 Viewer)

Rozelle

Moderator
Joel Buchsbaum did this for Pro Football Weekly through 2002. Joel passed in January of 2003. Buschbaum story

Nolan Nawrocki has been PFW's draft anayst since.

Some feel Buschbaum was as good as it gets and without him content is marginal at best.

Hope formats hold true

PFW Grades

6.50 - 6.99

Sure 1st rounder, who has a chance to become a Pro Bowl caliber player

6.00 - 6.49

Should become a quality NFL player

5.50 - 5.99

Has a chance to become a quality NFL player. Should be 1st day pick.

5.10 - 5.49

Has a better than average chance to make a NFL team.

YEAR Name College Grade

2000 LaVar Arrington Penn State 8.01

2006 A.J. Hawk Ohio St. 6.80

2005 Johnson, Derrick Texas 6.56

2004 Williams, D.J. Miami (Fla.) 6.55

2005 Ware, Demarcus Troy State 6.55

2006 Ernie Sims Florida St. 6.55

2000 Brian Urlacher New Mexico 6.50

2006 Kamerion Wimbley Florida State 6.45

2006 Chad Greenway Iowa 6.30

2003 Bailey, Boss Georgia 6.20

2006 DeMeco Ryans Alabama 6.15

2000 Julian Peterson Michigan State 6.11

2000 John Abraham South Carolina 6.10

2002 Harris, Napoleon Northwestern 6.10

2000 Keith Bulluck Syracuse 6.05

2004 Dansby, Karlos Auburn 6.05

2004 Thomas, Dontarrious Auburn 5.99

2006 Roger McIntosh Miami (FL) 5.95

2000 Barrett Green West Virginia 5.90

2004 Lehman, Teddy Oklahoma 5.90

2004 Boulware, Michael Florida State 5.90

2005 Blackstock, Darryl Virginia  5.90

2006 Bobby Carpenter Ohio St. 5.90

2005 Ruud, Barrett Nebraska 5.85

2001 Polley, Tommy Florida State 5.80

2006 Manny Lawson NC State 5.80

2006 Thomas Howard U.T.E.P. 5.80

2000 Raynoch Thompson Tennessee 5.75

2005 Burnett, Kevin Tennessee 5.75

2000 Mark Simoneau Kansas State 5.70

2000 Corey Moore Virginia Tech 5.60

2003 Barnett, Nick Oregon State 5.60

2000 Na’il Diggs Ohio State 5.59

2001 Hodge, Sedrick North Carolina 5.59

2001 Caver, Quinton Arkansas 5.56

2001 Steele, Markus USC 5.55

2005 Beck, Jordan Cal Poly 5.55

2001 Westmoreland, Eric Tennessee 5.51

2000 Marcus Washington Auburn 5.50

2001 Greenwood, Morlon Syracuse 5.50

2002 Rasheed, Saleem Alabama 5.50

2002 Smith, Raonall Washington State 5.50

2002 Thornton, David North Carolina 5.50

2005 Hill, LeRoy Clemson 5.50

2006 Jon Alston Stanford 5.50

2006 Clint Ingram Oklahoma 5.50

2005 McCoy, Matt San Diego State 5.46

2002 Leber, Ben Kansas State 5.45

2004 Williams, Demorrio Nebraska 5.45

2005 Boley, Michael Southern Mississippi 5.45

2006 Brian Iwuh Colorado 5.45

2000 Ian Gold Michigan 5.40

2002 Calmus, Rocky Oklahoma 5.40

2003 Hobson, Victor Michigan 5.40

2003 James, Bradie LSU 5.40

2003 Grant, William “Cie” Ohio State 5.40

2004 Fox, Keyaron Georgia Tech 5.40

2004 Cooper, Marquis Washington 5.40

2005 Cole, Trent Cincinnati 5.40

2005 Newberry, Jared Stanford 5.40

2006 A.J. Nicholson Florida St. 5.39

2005 Wortham, Cornelius Alabama 5.37

2001 Huff, Orlando Fresno State 5.35

2002 Fujita, Scott California 5.35

2003 Thompson, Chaun West Texas A&M 5.35

2004 Chillar, Brandon UCLA 5.35

2006 Omar Gaither Tennessee 5.35

2000 Antonio Wilson Texas A&M-Commerce 5.30

2002 Bentley, Kevin Northwestern 5.30

2003 McDonald, LaMarcus Texas Christian 5.30

2003 Tinoisamoa, Pisa Hawaii 5.30

2003 Nattiel, Michael Florida 5.30

2004 Gardner, Gilbert Purdue 5.30

2006 Jamar Williams Arizona St. 5.27

2000 Sekou Sanyika California 5.25

2001 Stewart, Matt Vanderbilt 5.25

2002 Witherspoon, Will Georgia 5.25

2003 Clemons, Chris Georgia 5.25

2004 Tufts, Sean Colorado 5.25

2005 McMillan, David Kansas 5.25

2005 Welsh, Jonathan Wisconsin 5.25

2006 William Kershaw Maryland 5.25

2004 Bockwoldt, Colby Brigham Young 5.23

2005 Harris, Marques Southern Utah 5.23

2006 James Anderson Virginia Tech 5.23

2004 Joe, Leon Maryland 5.21

2005 Speegle, Nick New Mexico 5.21

2002 Allen, James Oregon State 5.20

2002 Knight, Bryan Pittsburgh 5.20

2002 Atkinson, Algie Kansas 5.20

2003 Moore, Eddie Tennessee 5.20

2004 Osunde, Uyi Connecticut 5.20

2004 Pope, Kendyll Florida State 5.20

2004 Johnson, Landon Purdue 5.20

2004 Richmond, Greg Oklahoma State 5.20

2004 Hollowell, T.J. Nebraska 5.20

2004 Hickman, Bryan Kansas State 5.20

2005 Cooper, Roger Montana State 5.20

2005 Hagler, Tyjuan Cincinnati 5.20

2006 Kevin Simon Tennessee 5.20

2006 Keith Ellison Oregon St. 5.20

2002 Boiman, Rocky Notre Dame 5.19

2003 Williams, Sam Fresno State 5.19

2004 Green, Roderick Central Missouri State 5.19

2005 Goddard, Johnathan Marshall 5.19

2005 Claridge, Ryan UNLV 5.19

2005 Wake, Derek Penn State 5.19

2005 Wallace, Rian Temple 5.19

2004 Jones, Maurice South Florida 5.18

2006 Terna Nande Miami (OH) 5.17

2006 Brandon Johnson Louisville 5.17

2004 Sommersell, Andre Colorado State 5.16

2005 Jones, Marcus Louisville 5.16

2000 James Cotton Ohio State 5.15

2002 Rogers, Nick Georgia Tech 5.15

2002 Bullard, Courtland Ohio State 5.15

2002 Stevenson, Dominique Tennessee 5.15

2003 Abdullah, Khalid Mars Hill (Pa.) 5.15

2003 Odom, Joe Purdue 5.15

2003 Lee, Chad Louisville 5.15

2003 Briggs, Lance Arizona 5.15

2004 Harrell, Jonathan Northern Iowa 5.15

2004 Pope, Derrick Alabama 5.15

2001 Allen, Brian Florida State 5.14

2005 Kinney, James Missouri 5.14

2005 Benoit, Sarth Connecticut State 5.13

2000 Shannon Taylor Virginia 5.12

2002 Mallard, Wesley Oregon 5.12

2004 Colas, Cols Virginia Tech 5.12

2004 Brown, Isaac Washington State 5.12

2001 Glenn, Jason Texas A&M 5.10

2001 Bradley, Roylin Texas A&M 5.10

2002 Sykes, Jashon Colorado 5.10

2002 Duckett, John Virginia 5.10

2003 Penright, Jerrod Texas A&M 5.10

2003 Loyd, Jeremy Iowa State 5.10

2003 Wimbush, Recardo Georgia Tech 5.10

2003 Shanle, Scott Nebraska 5.10

2004 Lewis, Alexander Wisconsin 5.10

2004 McClover, Darrell Miami (Fla.) 5.10

2004 Williams, Renauld Hofstra 5.10

2004 Maxwell, Jim Gardner-Webb (N.C.) 5.10

2005 Woodfin, Zac UAB  5.10

2005 Enzor, Jamar Cincinnati 5.10

2006 Travis Williams Auburn 5.10

 
Last edited by a moderator:

Weiner Dog

Footballguy
Wow! :eek: I had no idea Sims would be ranked higher than guys like Urlacher, J Peterson, Abraham and Bulluck. I know there's talk of him going in the mid-1st to the Vikes, but he's leapfrogging some elite ballers.

I'm also surprised Wimbley is regarded higher than all the LB's listed above (except Urlacher). The guy could/would be a terror as an OLB in a 3-4 (ala Merriman and Ware), but I would have guessed he'd be more in the 6.00-range.

 

Rozelle

Moderator
On up the PFW scale

9.00-9.99 A once in a lifetime player (e.g. Elway, LT)

8.00-8.99 Perennial All-Pro

7.50-7.99 Future All-Pro

7.00-7.49 Should become a Pro Bowl caliber player

 

Users who are viewing this thread

Top