Pick 1 Offensive Franchise Player with most value (1 Viewer)

[eddy13]

Ok guys scoring system is 10 points for a td, 1 point for every 10 yards combined... bonus points of 5 for 100 yard rusher and for 175 combined.....

Now this is a Auction Draft and we get to franhise 1 player from the follwoing season... Now truth is I need to franchise the player with the highest auction value..... Why you ask is because if I franchise a offensive player and we get to bring him up at auction.. Now are rule is as follows if at the auction his name comes up and people start bidding and I decide not to keep my franchise player because I feel I do not want to pay his going rate then I simply get 20 percent of the players value that gets added to my cap.. For instance if he goes for 30 bucks then the owner who stoled my franchise player for 30 bucks has to give me 6 additional dollars... The other option is I win the bid and keep him at 30....

Might be complicated but I need to pick one of these 2 guys that holds the most value.... So who would it be Mcgahee or Dom Davis.... Who would go for more in a Auction!

 

[Traders2001]

McGahee by 25 miles , Davis will playyy a few games re-injure his knee and lose his ob.

 

[diesel7982]

Ok guys scoring system is 10 points for a td, 1 point for every 10 yards combined... bonus points of 5 for 100 yard rusher and for 175 combined.....

Now this is a Auction Draft and we get to franhise 1 player from the follwoing season... Now truth is I need to franchise the player with the highest auction value..... Why you ask is because if I franchise a offensive player and we get to bring him up at auction.. Now are rule is as follows if at the auction his name comes up and people start bidding and I decide not to keep my franchise player because I feel I do not want to pay his going rate then I simply get 20 percent of the players value that gets added to my cap.. For instance if he goes for 30 bucks then the owner who stoled my franchise player for 30 bucks has to give me 6 additional dollars... The other option is I win the bid and keep him at 30....

Might be complicated but I need to pick one of these 2 guys that holds the most value.... So who would it be Mcgahee or Dom Davis.... Who would go for more in a Auction!

Whoever the ACF tells you to pick.

 

[MLBrandow]

Since the bills are destined to be terrible for the next decade, I'd go with the RB of the team on the rise.

I take the guy who averaged 120ypg for his career behind a terrible OL, and whose missed games are the result of said bad OL, rather than some habitual affinity for injury.

 

[eddy13]

Ok guys scoring system is 10 points for a td, 1 point for every 10 yards combined... bonus points of 5 for 100 yard rusher and for 175 combined.....

Now this is a Auction Draft and we get to franhise 1 player from the follwoing season...  Now truth is I need to franchise the player with the highest auction value.....  Why you ask is because if I franchise a offensive player and we get to bring him up at auction.. Now are rule is as follows  if at the auction his name comes up and people start bidding and I decide not to keep my franchise player because I feel I do not want to pay his going rate then I simply get 20 percent of the players value that gets added to my cap.. For instance if he goes for 30 bucks  then the owner who stoled my franchise player for 30 bucks has to give me 6 additional dollars...  The other option is I win the bid and keep him at 30.... 

Might be complicated but I need to pick one of these 2 guys that holds the most value....  So who would it be Mcgahee or Dom Davis....  Who would go for more in a Auction!

Whoever the ACF tells you to pick.

OK So in a Auction who would go for more Mcgahee or Dom Davis.. Your reply will get mine!

 

[slayer666]

Who would go for more in a Auction!

I think given the recent reports on Davis' knee that McGahee would end up costing more $$$$$ in an auction format.

 

[mightyeskimo]

Willis. No question.

 

[-OZ-]

Willis. No question.

Now, it's possible that Dom is the better value, but I doubt there's any league where Dom goes for more right now.

 

[Musesboy]

McGahee would be my choice too. He actually put up numbers that justified his draft position in the first eight games (185/790/4), but the line fell apart and the experiments at QB killed his second half value. Mularkey did not use him as well as he could. The Bills should be improved this year. Losman will be more experienced and the players will feel like he won the right to lead them. Less trick plays with a new OC should lead to McGahee pounding the ball more. Maybe they will learn to leave him in the game on third down too. There is a lot of room for improvement but he has the ability.

Davis is good when healthy but the continual rumors over his knee have me very worried about his long term value.

If I could choose either for the same auction value, I would grab McGahee in an instant.

 

[KnowledgeReignsSupreme]

You guys are being lenient today.