Pick Swap (1 Viewer)

[TheBottomLine]

10-team PPR, start QRRWWWTFK plus full IDP (start 11 defensive guys)

I have been offered:

His 1.05, 2.09, Willie Snead

for 

My 1.08, 1.09

I already have a pretty deep group of WRs (OBJ, Keenan, Adams, Robinson, Thielen, Sammy, Crabtree, Godwin, Robby A, Enunwa), so Snead would be just another depth piece, though I do like him.

How are people viewing the value of that 1.05?   Guy picking at 3 is pretty desperate at WR so I could see him reaching for a WR instead of taking Chubb or Michel, so one of them could be there at 5.  

 

[snoochieboochies]

I think the talent of RBs in this draft class is very heavy and reaches to the 1.05, but their contribution will largely depend on how well they are matched with the teams scheme. Chubb, Freeman, Michel, and Johnson can all be argued at or around the Fournette and CMC arena from last year. Assuming Barkley and Guice go 1 and 2, and Mr desperate goes WR at 3 then you still have loads of talent to pick from. Once the draft is done you will likely have a consensus number 3 due to the rbs ahead of the rookie, scheme, team, etc. 

In the Footballguys mock draft just posted, they took ridley and moore at 8 and 9. You are really deep at WR and dont need the help. But Freeman and Johnson fell to the 11 and 12 spots so. For me the decision should be made without considering Snead. You dont need him and likely wont start him ever. The 1.05 > 1.08+1.09 in my book. With the second rounder and snead you easily win this trade. If you like snead he is a good addition, but i would prefer you swap him out for a position you need more talent at.  

 

[beerbuff]

Snoochie has some great points, however I think I'd rather just keep the 1.08 and 1.09. Like you said you don't need Snead and with 2 high picks you can get both a good offensive and defensive player that will likely give your team an immediate upgrade.

 

[snoochieboochies]

Snoochie has some great points, however I think I'd rather just keep the 1.08 and 1.09. Like you said you don't need Snead and with 2 high picks you can get both a good offensive and defensive player that will likely give your team an immediate upgrade.




 

I answered only thinking about offensive players. My mistake. Missed the IDP first time over, so please take that into consideration. 

 

[fightingillini]

Snead is irrelevant given your WRs, so I would just keep the 1.08 and 1.09, or counter with a the 1.05, 2.09, and a different player at a position of need (should be possible since you play full IDP)

 

[Gally]

The  offer as constructed isn't good enough to give up the 1.08 and 1.09.  Snead is useless for you as other's have said and moving up 3 spots while losing a round on the second pick doesn't seem worth it. 

I hold tight unless you can tweak it a bit.