Please help settle a debate... (1 Viewer)

[jmo87usc]

Pick the one RB you'd want in dynasty out of Gurley, Ajayi and Howard.  

This came up with a few leaguemates during trade talks and I'm curious to see outside opinions.  Thanks.  Leave a link

 

[Ratbone]

Gurley, easy choice. Howard is second.  Ajayi distant third. 

 

[Sitch]

Gurley, easy choice. Howard is second.  Ajayi distant third. 

x2

 

[Tybeeman]

I agree with the 1st two responders.

Gurley, Howard, Ajayi

 

[aaj1997]

I agree and it is an easy choice for me as well  - Gurley, Howard, Ajayi

 

[Scot from LV]

Ditto.  Not even close for 1st or 2nd (Gurley, Howard).

 

[Gally]

I would it in the same order as everyone else but it's a lot closer for me. Essentially they are on the same tier for me.            

 

[squistion]

I would it in the same order as everyone else but it's a lot closer for me. Essentially they are on the same tier for me.            

That.

And you can build a compelling argument for each. Gurley seems the safe choice but I wouldn't second guess anyone who picked either Howard or Ajayi.

 

[Florida Man]

Gurley. Generational talent vs two good backs in good situations. Gurley's situation will change and he'll return to form.

 

[jmo87usc]

Gurley. Generational talent vs two good backs in good situations. Gurley's situation will change and he'll return to form.

This is where I am.  I do feel they are currently within a couple of spots of each other, but i think Gurley will have the longest fantasy career as a contributor.