Poll: Better use of roster spot ? (1 Viewer)

[wuchild97]

.5ppr : Not sure i need to gamble on McGuire but i think this week he continues to roll...

 

[Gally]

West is just a guy and if Hunt goes down he will not put up anywhere near the same output.  I would roll with McGuire.  He showed flashes and the Jets seem to like him.  I think he gets more involved as the season goes along and if Powell/Forte miss significant time (which they both seem to do a lot) he could get into RB2 consideration.   

 

[SaintsInDome2006]

I think it depends on your RB2. If you're in trouble there and searching for a fix then getting MGuire to see if he pans out makes sense. If you're set at RB2 and have a solid backup then I'd go West.

 

[Truebluey]

West is just a guy and if Hunt goes down he will not put up anywhere near the same output.  I would roll with McGuire.  He showed flashes and the Jets seem to like him.  I think he gets more involved as the season goes along and if Powell/Forte miss significant time (which they both seem to do a lot) he could get into RB2 consideration.   

This, exactly. Not all handcuffs are capable.

 

[travdogg]

I think it depends on your RB2. If you're in trouble there and searching for a fix then getting MGuire to see if he pans out makes sense. If you're set at RB2 and have a solid backup then I'd go West.

I'd agree with this, though I might also say neither guy and roll with an extra player at another position.