Poll: If you won your DYNASTY league last year, who was your QB? (1 Viewer)

[Touchdown There]

If you started one QB for 13 or more of the 16 fantasy weeks, which QB led your DYNASTY team to a championship?

No IDP leagues or 2 QB leagues, please.

 

[Shane Falco]

Peyton in one and Rodgers in the other (voted Peyton)

My 2nd place team was a combo of McNabb and Palmer

 

[thriftyrocker]

The leagues I won with Vick I started the year with Schaub in 1 and Rodgers in the other and only switched later in the year. So I guess he technically doesn't count for me based on OP's 13 game threshold.

Another league I won I started Brady all but his bye week.

 

[Touchdown There]

I modified the poll to allow for a second or third selection if you won a few leagues.

 

[eakfootball]

This wasn't my team, but in my main league it was David ****in Garrard.

 

[Jersey35]

I voted Rodgers, but Vick started 7 games for me, scoring 145 points, whereas Rodgers started 9 games for me, scoring 140.

 

[Go Pack]

Carson Palmer in my championship start one QB dynasty. IDP with 20+ starters so I was able to make up points at other positions. I traded for Romo this offeason though

Also won a start 2 QB dynasty with Rodgers/Roethlisberger and a bit of McNabb while Ben was suspended

 

[jeremyx13]

Used Matt Ryan and I paired him with Roddy White. My Rb's were Charles and MJD for the most part. Took over a team that had been dead last previous year and I traded to get Ryan and Charles if I remember correctly.

 

[doowain]

Peyton in one and Rodgers in the other (voted Peyton)My 2nd place team was a combo of McNabb and Palmer

I won it all with this combo

 

[doowain]

Won another with Tebow. And it was Mcnabb/Palmer up to the week Tebow took over.

 

[quickhands]

vick

 

[tones]

IDP league start 17 Carson Palmer.

 

[Touchdown There]

Won another with Tebow. And it was Mcnabb/Palmer up to the week Tebow took over.

This would be QBBC, which is an option on the poll.

 

[FUBAR]

If you started one QB for 13 or more of the 16 fantasy weeks, which QB led your DYNASTY team to a championship?

No IDP leagues or 2 QB leagues, please.

why would this matter?

 

[sihaokills]

Had Rivers in two championships I won

 

[Touchdown There]

If you started one QB for 13 or more of the 16 fantasy weeks, which QB led your DYNASTY team to a championship?

No IDP leagues or 2 QB leagues, please.

why would this matter?

Because IDP leagues remove QB value. Standard leagues have 8-10 starters. If your QB is one starter in 17 (example IDP league used from this thread) the position is de-valued. 1/10th is a higher percentage of points than 1/17th, so IDP leagues skew the results of information I am looking for.

 

[J-Dawg]

Other - Ben Roethlisberger

 

[Shane Falco]

Peyton in one and Rodgers in the other (voted Peyton)

My 2nd place team was a combo of McNabb and Palmer

I won it all with this combo

I wish I was in your league

If you started one QB for 13 or more of the 16 fantasy weeks, which QB led your DYNASTY team to a championship?

No IDP leagues or 2 QB leagues, please.

why would this matter?

Because IDP leagues remove QB value. Standard leagues have 8-10 starters. If your QB is one starter in 17 (example IDP league used from this thread) the position is de-valued. 1/10th is a higher percentage of points than 1/17th, so IDP leagues skew the results of information I am looking for.

Well nevermind then. I graduated from non-IDP leagues

 

[doowain]

Won another with Tebow. And it was Mcnabb/Palmer up to the week Tebow took over.

This would be QBBC, which is an option on the poll.

Do I really have to explain this?I'm pretty sure you can't vote more than once in this poll.Read: I had already voted.

 

[HPD]

If you started one QB for 13 or more of the 16 fantasy weeks, which QB led your DYNASTY team to a championship?

No IDP leagues or 2 QB leagues, please.

why would this matter?

Because IDP leagues remove QB value. Standard leagues have 8-10 starters. If your QB is one starter in 17 (example IDP league used from this thread) the position is de-valued. 1/10th is a higher percentage of points than 1/17th, so IDP leagues skew the results of information I am looking for.

That's just silly.

 

[Prinefan]

Made 4 Super Bowls. Won 2, lost 2.

Won with Ryan and Rodgers.

Lost with Vick and Rivers.

 

[Touchdown There]

I am just trying to get a feel for the value of a top notch dynasty QB. Looks like the top 6 QBs account for 53% of dynasty wins. All other QBs or QBBC strategy account for 47% of dynasty wins. Seems pretty even, but there are only 6 QBs in the top half of fantasy scoring and there are 26 other starting QBs in the league.

 

[craxie]

I am just trying to get a feel for the value of a top notch dynasty QB. Looks like the top 6 QBs account for 53% of dynasty wins. All other QBs or QBBC strategy account for 47% of dynasty wins. Seems pretty even, but there are only 6 QBs in the top half of fantasy scoring and there are 26 other starting QBs in the league.

But in a 12-team league, there are only 12 starting QBsso the top 50% of QBs account for 53% of the wins, looks like marginal valueObviously this doesn't account for other size leagues, teams that have 2 of the top 6, etc

 

[Lash]

started with Big Ben, traded for Vick when he was hurt

 

[BigTex]

Dynasty, Cutler was lights out week 16!!!!

Redraft, Ryan brought home the bacon

 

[metoo]

Palmer at the beginning then Big Ben.

 

[Packers4ever]

Ryan

Romo and then Vick

Culter then Big Ben then traded for Brees.

 

[Kree]

Roethlisberger, Hill as backup.

 

[bronco fan]

I was the Champion of one league, and runner up in another with Cutler.

 

[Wayne8348]

Flacco in one league and Big Ben in the other.

Wayne

 

[Skeletore Eh]

surprised to not see Shaun Hill yet

 

[domvin]

Cutler in one dynadty. I played shaun hill 3 maybe 4 times

Fitz, marshall, boldin, welker, vernon, mendy and forte were the other key cogs

 

[IHEARTFF]

Seems QB didn't much matter towards winning leagues last year. I'm guessing it had more to do with players like Brandon Lloyd, Peyton Hillis, Darren McFadden, Arian Foster.