Portis vs. MBIII (1 Viewer)

[Butt-Head]

Of these NFC East RBs, who would you rather have this season as a RB1 and why?

 

[Hoss_Cartwright]

Yeah, go ahead and trade Portis for MBiii if it's a dynasty league. If it's a redraft don't make the trade

 

[Bri]

Portis strongest

 

[Sweet Love]

Yeah, go ahead and trade Portis for MBiii if it's a dynasty league. If it's a redraft don't make the trade

LOL...was thinking the same thing. I would take Portis for the year based on the fact that Portis really has no competition for carries and Barber has Jones and Choice breathing down his neck. I would be surprised if Dallas has all three going into 2010 (could be Barber being cut/traded) or one of the other guys having a great year and demanding a trade, so it will sort itself out there somehow in a year and Barber will be better 2010 and beyond.

 

[JPeso]

To answer the OP's question, Portis has the stronger year.