Post combine #1 rookie (1 Viewer)

[NorrisB]

 

[moderated]

I'm a huge huge Stewart fan, but i think ya have to go McFadden at this time.

 

[BigTex]

Count me in the minority, I don't think McFadden is the clear #1.

 

[2and2is5]

I'm a huge huge Stewart fan, but i think ya have to go McFadden at this time.

.

 

[ImTheScientist]

I voted Stewart. Although I do think Ray Rice should be on this list.

3-CONE DRILL TIME

Ray Rice 6.65

Kevin Smith 6.74

Jamaal Charles 6.80

Matt Forte 6.84

Jacob Hester 6.85

Anthony Aldridge 6.88

Tashard Choice 6.88

Felix Jones 6.90

Jalen Parmele 6.96

Justin Forsett 6.96

 

[Burning Sensation]

Count me in the minority, I don't think McFadden is the clear #1.

I dont think you are in the minority, i think alot of people dont think he is the clear #1.I do, but most think it is pretty close.

 

[ninerfanatic492000]

whichever RB between mcfadden/mendenhall/stewart ends up in the best situation is your answer. if any of the 3 land on Houston is prolly the best choice.

 

[Burning Sensation]

whichever RB between mcfadden/mendenhall/stewart ends up in the best situation is your answer. if any of the 3 land on Houston is prolly the best choice.

Drafting based on situation is a bad idea, ask the guys who took Michael Bennett over LT, or Kevin Jones over Stephen Jackson.

 

[Moniker]

Count me in the minority, I don't think McFadden is the clear #1.

Neither do I.Personally, I believe that Mendenhall should be the first back taken with Rice 2nd. That would probably put me in a very small minority.

 

[jurb26]

The combine really only solidified what everyone already knew. McFadden is a beast. Elite production on a suspect team in the best conference in college football is what you should be more impressed with though. It's McFadden and by a good margin.

 

[JPeso]

The combine really only solidified what everyone already knew. McFadden is a beast. Elite production on a suspect team in the best conference in college football is what you should be more impressed with though. It's McFadden and by a good margin.

McFadden is still #1, not sure by how much, and the Mendenhall vs. Stewart battle rages on. If there are any winners and losers at the top of the RB class, it is Ray Rice moving in to the 1.4 slot on my board, and the excitement behind Felix Jones falling. Depending on where Felix Jones (Smith, Johnson as well) goes, I could see him moving down to the 1.7.