Pro Bowl QBs (1 Viewer)

[gman74]

Are some of these people really saying Peyton Manning doesn't deserve to be in the Pro Bowl?They can't be serious.Can they?

ask hk

 

[MLBrandow]

I think people are misled about Rivers by the shear fact that he's had those two big comeback wins. Palmer has better numbers RIGHT NOW, and his team is getting hot at the right time.

I agree that if the season ended today, Palmer should be ahead of Rivers. But Rivers should be ahead of Brady.

You should start a new thread on this subject... Rivers or Brady...It'd make a pretty good debate I think.Brady has obviously done more with less, but you can't exactly handicap Rivers because he's performed as well as we expect from a guy handing off to an RB having the greatest season ever.

 

[H.K.]

You are probably right. Im still willing to wager though, despite the fact you are obviously getting the better end of the deal. How much did you want to put down on this one?

Manning will go because its a popularity contest, not because he deserves it.

All talk. Glad to see you can admit you are wrong.

I admit I am wrong all the time...because I normally am, but I did not do so here. Simply recognizing that he will win a popularity contest doesn't mean anything. If handing off to a stud RB is Pro Bowl worthy, then let Manning, Trent Green, and Rivers go from the AFC.

 

[Gamblor]

You are probably right. Im still willing to wager though, despite the fact you are obviously getting the better end of the deal. How much did you want to put down on this one?

Manning will go because its a popularity contest, not because he deserves it.

All talk. Glad to see you can admit you are wrong.

I admit I am wrong all the time...because I normally am, but I did not do so here. Simply recognizing that he will win a popularity contest doesn't mean anything. If handing off to a stud RB is Pro Bowl worthy, then let Manning, Trent Green, and Rivers go from the AFC.

I appreciate you admitting you are wrong. It is big of you.

 

[valhallan]

Wow, all but maybe 4 posts are discussing the AFC quarterbacks.

This thread is a microcosm of the reason the AFC is better than the NFC. The AFC has at least 6 Pro Bowl caliber signal-callers while the NFC can hardly even find 3.

 

[H.K.]

I appreciate you admitting you are wrong. It is big of you.

Ok, you got me!

 

[Maurile Tremblay]

Tomlinson should also get consideration in the AFC.

Good article here: LT: QB or not QB?

 

[H.K.]

Tomlinson should also get consideration in the AFC.

Good article here: LT: QB or not QB?

Too bad he's the only guy in SD throwing to Gates!

 

[Gr00vus]

Tomlinson should also get consideration in the AFC.

Good article here: LT: QB or not QB?

Too bad he's the only guy in SD throwing to Gates!

I'll give you this - you're painfully consistent.

 

[MLBrandow]

You are probably right. Im still willing to wager though, despite the fact you are obviously getting the better end of the deal. How much did you want to put down on this one?

Manning will go because its a popularity contest, not because he deserves it.

All talk. Glad to see you can admit you are wrong.

I admit I am wrong all the time...because I normally am, but I did not do so here. Simply recognizing that he will win a popularity contest doesn't mean anything. If handing off to a stud RB is Pro Bowl worthy, then let Manning, Trent Green, and Rivers go from the AFC.

You do realize that it's because of his amazing abilities that makes these running backs look good. It's not hard to run on a six man front when both safeties are back in coverage.

 

[H.K.]

Tomlinson should also get consideration in the AFC.

Good article here: LT: QB or not QB?

Too bad he's the only guy in SD throwing to Gates!

I'll give you this - you're painfully consistent.

Well, if you're gonna set it up on a tee, of course I'm gonna take a whack at it.

 

[gman74]

You are probably right. Im still willing to wager though, despite the fact you are obviously getting the better end of the deal. How much did you want to put down on this one?

Manning will go because its a popularity contest, not because he deserves it.

All talk. Glad to see you can admit you are wrong.

I admit I am wrong all the time...because I normally am, but I did not do so here. Simply recognizing that he will win a popularity contest doesn't mean anything. If handing off to a stud RB is Pro Bowl worthy, then let Manning, Trent Green, and Rivers go from the AFC.

addia is hardly a stud rb jr

 

[gman74]

You are probably right. Im still willing to wager though, despite the fact you are obviously getting the better end of the deal. How much did you want to put down on this one?

Manning will go because its a popularity contest, not because he deserves it.

All talk. Glad to see you can admit you are wrong.

I admit I am wrong all the time...because I normally am, but I did not do so here. Simply recognizing that he will win a popularity contest doesn't mean anything. If handing off to a stud RB is Pro Bowl worthy, then let Manning, Trent Green, and Rivers go from the AFC.

addai is hardly a stud rb jr

 

[Jules Winnfield]

AFC: Manning, Rivers, Brady

NFC: Brees, Hasselbeck, Romo

I can't put Vick because he isn't a very good QB but I could see Bulger in there when even though they won't even make the playoffs

Fixed it