Q Judkins - Dynasty Status (1 Viewer)

[Plowboy]

Rookie Draft tonight in my big $ league. Defending champ with no real roster needs other than to replenish my RB room. 1QB, 1RB, 1WR, 1TE, 3 Flex format, .5 PPR

I traded up from 1.12 to 1.09 to improve the odds of landing a Tier 2 RB (K Johnson, RJ Harvey) but it now looks like Q Judkins could be there. Given the format and my depth, I don't think I will play any of these guys this year I'm tempted to take Judkins at 1.09 and let him sort through all of his issues. Thoughts?

 

[Tree44]

Judkins was certainly a beast at Ole Miss, with a nice year at OSU. Out of the three you're looking at, I think I'd go 1) Harvey 2) Judkins 3) K Johnson. Sounds like Johnson hasn't impressed, makes me question his viability as a legit NFL starter down the road if he can't beat out J Warren. I've seen Judkins plays a lot more and he was a great college RB, but the main thing against him to me is, does anything work out for fantasy in Cleveland? (we know it doesn't in reality). They are called the factory of sadness for a reason. I wouldn't blame you for taking Judkins, but I also think Harvey will be starter in Denver next year, and seems like his pedigree is solid and situation is much better. My 2 cents. If you have any thoughts on superflex leagues, I posted something on that this morning.

 

[Gally]

Take Judkins if you don't mind risk. Take Harvey if you want a safer guy. Johnson would be #3 for me