Bracie Smathers
Footballguy
Josh Larky
@jlarkytweets
Josh Dobbs tonight: 232 passing yards Malik Willis (3 starts): 234 passing yards
@jlarkytweets
Josh Dobbs tonight: 232 passing yards Malik Willis (3 starts): 234 passing yards
Fantasy Football - Footballguys Forums
Welcome to Our Forums. Once you've registered and logged in, you're primed to talk football, among other topics, with the sharpest and most experienced fantasy players on the internet.
QB Malik Willis, TEN (1 Viewer)
- Thread starter Lehigh98
- Start date
crushedspirit
Footballguy
As many of us were saying, it was a game to find out if Dobbs can start, not to rest Willis.
-OZ-
Footballguy
I’ll hang on to him in my SF dynasty for sure. But wouldn’t in start 1 formats with small benches.
He always was going to be a project and boom/bust.
-OZ-
Footballguy
Honestly, I think he’ll be an interesting backup for most of his career. Good kid, I’m definitely cheering for him to succeed. But he’s exactly who many of us thought he was a year ago.
I have a sinking feeling he’s a Titan
grateful zed
Footballguy
Trade bait.
Maybe weak trade bait but too many were too high on him last April that he's surely worth something even a late pick
-OZ-
Footballguy
“Fallen out” implies he was ever favored. There was hope but nobody really expected him to do it which is why he fell to the 3rd. Not to mention drafted by a guy fired mid season.
If I were the GM of pretty much any team, but especially one where QB rushing was a part of the offense, I would gladly pay that for Willis.
Its kind of amazing how much he's getting judged off of 2 games, when the book on him was very clearly not ready year 1. Maybe he'll never be much of a passer, but man, most 6th round picks aren't even useful special teams players. I'd gladly give that up even if its just for a Taysom Hill-ish QB.
Really late to this one, but I thought if Willis were truly open to playing RB, he would have been drafted higher than he was as a QB. A few anonymous GM's implied he was the best runner in last year's draft after Hall/Walker.
I mean whatever we heard over the years of this guy or that guy not being able to do xyz so he'll play another position....that described Willis.
I am developing a positive attitude since he has been reported as working with different QB trainers this off-season
I do think the Titans will entertain trade offers. There's a lot of talk of them wanting a young QB and a lot how he's not the guy so...it seems a reasonable conclusion.
Not re-signing Dobbs was dumb as they'll just wind up adding a similar veteran player after the draft. The QB room has to offer something for Tannehill and there must be someone to run the scout team.
I'm expecting Penn State guy or Stetson Bennett late or UDFA. I also think they're better than advertised. They can go on the PS and there's that potential rule change so getting a "let's see what he can do" UDFA seems probable.
Its easy to imagine the new GM doesn't want a project in Malik but I don't buy that he'll dump him. He was a third that fell in the draft so maybe they can get a third or fourth. It's so hard to gauge this time of year when everyone is drooling over metrics. He could be Akili Smith but there's certainly a chance another GM loves his speed and arm.
I am developing a positive attitude since he has been reported as working with different QB trainers this off-season
I do think the Titans will entertain trade offers. There's a lot of talk of them wanting a young QB and a lot how he's not the guy so...it seems a reasonable conclusion.
Not re-signing Dobbs was dumb as they'll just wind up adding a similar veteran player after the draft. The QB room has to offer something for Tannehill and there must be someone to run the scout team.
I'm expecting Penn State guy or Stetson Bennett late or UDFA. I also think they're better than advertised. They can go on the PS and there's that potential rule change so getting a "let's see what he can do" UDFA seems probable.
Its easy to imagine the new GM doesn't want a project in Malik but I don't buy that he'll dump him. He was a third that fell in the draft so maybe they can get a third or fourth. It's so hard to gauge this time of year when everyone is drooling over metrics. He could be Akili Smith but there's certainly a chance another GM loves his speed and arm.
-OZ-
Footballguy
They aren’t trading Willis. Especially not for a 6th. I do think they may add a late round pick (Cunningham, Dugan?) or a UDFA (Tyson Bagent?), unless they get Hooker in the 2nd. I’d be quite okay with a QB room of Tannehill, Hooker and Willis if that means they get Paris or Skoronski.
I’d personally like to see Willis do a decent Taysom Hill impression. That would make him easily worth the 3rd round pick imo.
Last edited:
Charles Robinson wrote that...pretty much all I've said over n over except the QB room and slow news day? I got to hear the Titans on national radio some. Did you?
This one guy was comparing Willis to Daniel Bellinger. The Giants have Waller and now the concept could be to move on, but why? They added a couple young TEs that were good last year with Bellinger most promising. He showed all you want to see- blocking, toughness, catches with players draped on him, even the injuries that were too often but he came back strong. So why? He's making fourth round money for three more years, why?
Willis is questionable but he's put the work in that they requested and then some. Why?
He said ya gotta offer them a third for Bellinger or maybe it takes more. A second for Willis. Maybe there's a roster hole and a key player could be traded instead. No one is moving off a young known talent that's cheap just because.
I get all that and that's a fair point for sure but Willis would have to be third then. I can make a strong argument they need a capable backup QB play and the probability it's utilized.
The QB room for Tannehill stunk last year and it seems they're aware as they shifted coaches and played games with titles to add two more to work with the QBs and offense. Maybe all that was for a rookie and not Tannehill? Maybe it was for Willis? Adding a coach Ridder said was helpful is interesting too.
I think they did the last paragraph for some reason. What reason though?
I don't want Levis.
I don't want Richardson if it means giving up a ton of picks as they have so many needs now as is.
Maybe it's for Tannehill or Willis? Maybe some other rookie that reasonably is drafted without trading a ton?
I am NOT a Tim Kelly fan. I am a fan of the guy that stole the passing game job from him in Houston. Maybe Vrabel wanted all these offensive minds to help his buddy as best he could?
Quoting again....
I'm forever wondering why Taamu isn't in the NFL and especially why he's not a Titan when he moved to TEN 2-3 years ago and worked out with their WRs often. If nothing else that is at least a practice squad QB. What more do they want?
Anywho....
I love the XFL goalline/red zone offense he's in and I want the Titans to do it so badly. Have you seen it?
Taamu can run pretty good but is the passer. D'Eriq King can run well and is a so so passer. One of them is the QB.
Are they running or passing?
From there, they are gloriously confusing to the defense. Why is a TE in the backfield? Why an extra lineman? Why is King out wide and Taamu at QB? Why is a RB shifting and not in the backfield?
I love it!
It's not at all fancy. Which QB then either a guy lines up weird or a simple shift. That's it. But the doubt at a spot where the defense can't think and has to just react....it's fantastic.
The Titans simply need to steal this with Willis and Tannehill. Not to mention how a D probably has to gear up and get set to try and stonewall Henry.
That doubt is so awesome. Oh I wish the Titans would steal it
-OZ-
Footballguy
I’m pretty sure the only guy who had faith in him at the start was fired last fall.
I just hope Malik can be a decent backup and add a wrinkle every so often.
ericttspikes
Footballguy
He's a smart guy with wheels and a big arm. He played in an elementary system and was considered a project. No one with the Titans can coach this guy up?
-OZ-
Footballguy
In all honesty, when’s the last time the titans coached up a player early in his career to have a successful career as a starter? Tim Kelly hasn’t shown that ability any better.
Mister CIA
Footballguy
He really needs to latch on as QB3 with the right coach and in the right system. What little I've seen of him reminds me of a Jalen Hurts knockoff.
Bears and Ravens should both be interested if the price is almost (or even) free.
Maybe distant future. I'd be shocked if he didn't get some chance(s) elsewhere, and if failing that, a look at RB/WR. Dude's 6-1 220 and runs 4.4. He's got the build to make a switch if need be.
-OZ-
Footballguy
Titans really need a WR 🤔
Drake Hater
Footballguy
Not sure why he's not worth a roster spot to run some Taysom Hill style plays as a change of pace. Seems like some teams could make that work.
Craig_MiamiFL
Footballguy
He has no business as a primary backup. Maybe can cut his teeth on a practice squad if he's hellbent being QB-only on a team like Ravens/Bears.
Only way he should see an NFL field anytime soon is if he can develop as a gimmick type.
It was embarrassing what he did in his starting trial. Made a lot of teams look smart passing on him in draft.
Agree
Texans didn't let him continue to ride "I was Deshaun Watson's OC" so the Titans did and now their offense looks like the Texans
The value for him in the third was that he's cheap, high ceiling, and can wait til he develops.
Woodside was picked up by Atlanta.
Tannehill had elective surgery.
They wanted to see- whether they admit it or not- they wanted to see what Willis can do.
Keep in mind it's a run Henry then run him some more offense.
Fields I thought was done super early and then he started running and everything clicked. I'm still not confident in his passing but wooh did the light turn on there.
QBs make 30-60 mil. Willis is dirt cheap. There is no rush.
I love the XFL defenders red zone offense.
There's no reason they can't mimic that- they won't, but they should.
Taamu can run, but he probably throws.
DEriq King can throw, but he probably runs.
It's simple and brilliant with one tiny nuance added.
The Titans did do this with Mariota and Tannehill and it worked for them.
One thing people always forget is Mariota had best ever type red zone stats. (Nothing else and I don't blame them for giving Arthur or Henry the credit) This should be dug into hard. He was a superb ad libbing QB in college but didn't do it much in the NFL so throw that concept away. Why did he convert such a high percentage and have a rate of like 30 TDs and 2 INTs? He's not Brady. Let the insults pile in. So then why?
Saints and Hill could definitely benefit from XFL offense or this research too.
Maybe young Jonnu and Delaine double threat? Henry of course. Mariota racing diagonal to the end zone and where to position S and LB? The big WRs Arthur coveted?
Arthur was so good as a TE coach/red zone coordinator that they made him OC. It's disturbing egotism to NOT call his plays and/or techniques that had everyone raving about him. Foolish by the Titans
Brunell4MVP
Footballguy
His value is ZERO. Don't fool yourself TEN fans, it is and if it was higher he wouldn't have gone from a #1 potential pick to end of the 3rd round ... that means teams watched and he stunk. And it's also why he couldn't get playing time from Jaret Stidham at AUB. I watched him a good bit at Liberty ... he was better than his competition but not very good overall. I got no problem with TEN taking a shot on him. QBs are often worth getting into camp and seeing what they have. But at this point you can't call plays for someone that is the 3rd best QB on your team. How'd that work for NO ... Taysom Hill still sucked. Those guys belong deep on the bench. Just stick Willis on practice squad and see what happens.
-OZ-
Footballguy
🤷 many of us said the same thing over a year ago.
I don’t mind taking the risk in the 3rd even if it meant missing out on Dylan Parham or Kerby Joseph
“What we’d asked Malik to do is come back with a presence to him,” Vrabel said. “Making sure that when you’re the quarterback of one of 32 franchises, there’s a certain demeanor and way you have to carry yourself, and a presence, leadership. There’s a lot that goes into that other than just delivering a football.
“You [do] have to be really good at delivering the football, being accurate and making great decisions, and making sure it goes where it’s supposed to go. I felt like he did that [so far in offseason workouts]. He came back and was into it. There was certainly a bounce to him, and he’s continued to do that. It’s early on in the evaluation period, but that’s what he’s done.”
Glennon article
“You [do] have to be really good at delivering the football, being accurate and making great decisions, and making sure it goes where it’s supposed to go. I felt like he did that [so far in offseason workouts]. He came back and was into it. There was certainly a bounce to him, and he’s continued to do that. It’s early on in the evaluation period, but that’s what he’s done.”
Glennon article
Yeah absolutely but also he's never been really good at delivering the football, accurate, or making great decisions.
That well regarded QB coach he went to in February and March did good with him.
The little the reporters were able to watch (and it's shamefully low) of OTAs, they're all seeing an improved player too.
It's no training camp, preseason, or the regular season so there's plenty more to improve upon but he got this step accomplished.
I don't expect he plays in 2023. Unless he does something super impressive, I expect some fictitious camp battle next year that Levis wins and Willis is probably the backup. Still, I feel like the guy does deserve some credit for putting the work in and improving
An excellent day including work with the ones.
Reporters grasping-
There was that one pass. His touch could have been better.
I haven't changed my view at all on him not playing in 2023.
We are however deep enough to say- great job by the QB coaches he worked with and by him putting the work in. It's evident and kudos. That's it for now.
Reporters grasping-
There was that one pass. His touch could have been better.
I haven't changed my view at all on him not playing in 2023.
We are however deep enough to say- great job by the QB coaches he worked with and by him putting the work in. It's evident and kudos. That's it for now.
