Benson was a great pick at 1.4 (fortunately for you, Smith was reached for at 1.2).
I would have easily taken either Thurman, Rudd, or Moats over Tatupu at 2.13. Your pick of Justin Miller at 3.4 could flop if Ty Law signs with the Jets. Again, I would have grabbed either Thurman, Rudd, or Moats here.
McCoy has potential. The two WLB's in front of him on the PHI depth chart (Adams and Simoneau) are not world beaters, and McCoy has an outside chance of seeing time in '06. I personally would have gambled on Channing Crowder instead, but to each his own.
I think the following owners had the best draft...
1.16--- Carolina Thomas Davis s
2.1---- Jacksonville Matt Jones te
3.16--- Cincinnati Odell Thurman lb
4.1---- NY Giants Corey Webster cb
1.8---- Cleveland Braylon Edwards wr
2.9---- Dallas Marcus Spears de
3.8---- Cleveland Brodney Pool s
4.9---- Atlanta Jonathan Babineaux dt
1.7---- Arizona J.J. Arrington rb
2.10--- Baltimore Mark Clayton wr
3.7---- Detroit Shaun Cody dt
4.10--- Kansas City Craphonso Thorpe wr