Rank the Rookies (1 Viewer)

[fuball]

eo who take starting job and becomes a top back next year?

Reggie still split with Deuce.

White should have the job alone next year, depending on what happens when he gets his shot this year.

Maroney should e the man alone next year

Addai hasnt shown to much this year but who knows

Drew looks good and Taylor will be gone or step aside for Drew

Williams? injuries? who knows

The way i see it

1. White

2. Maroney

3. Drew

4. Bush

5. Williams

6. Addai

Any thoughts?

 

[Sullie]

I voted Addai only because I would have voted Maroney except that the Patriots are such an odd/bizarre team that he could go an entire half as the starter sitting on the sidelines like Dillon did when he first started. I think Addai will learn the offense, he'll be the featured back and I do believe he'll go nuts next year only because Indy has such a powerful offense and weak defense which means they need to score a lot because they give up a lot of points. Bush could be third if NO gets rid of Deuce.

 

[Utter Chaos]

You should have added OTHER for guys like Leon Washington, Jerious Norwood, Mike Bell, Jerome Harrison and Wali Lundy.

I think it could be Leon could be better than all of them.

edit for spelling

 

[redman]

eo who take starting job and becomes a top back next year?Reggie still split with Deuce.White should have the job alone next year, depending on what happens when he gets his shot this year.Maroney should e the man alone next yearAddai hasnt shown to much this year but who knowsDrew looks good and Taylor will be gone or step aside for DrewWilliams? injuries? who knowsThe way i see it1. White2. Maroney3. Drew4. Bush5. Williams6. AddaiAny thoughts?

How can you rate White ahead of Maroney and Addai? Even Drew has shown more during his brief time in the NFL than White, but Maroney and Addai have already shown talent and play for teams that should put them in positions to score a lot of fantasy points.

 

[B Maverick]

eo who take starting job and becomes a top back next year?Reggie still split with Deuce.White should have the job alone next year, depending on what happens when he gets his shot this year.Maroney should e the man alone next yearAddai hasnt shown to much this year but who knowsDrew looks good and Taylor will be gone or step aside for DrewWilliams? injuries? who knowsThe way i see it1. White2. Maroney3. Drew4. Bush5. Williams6. AddaiAny thoughts?

How can you rate White ahead of Maroney and Addai? Even Drew has shown more during his brief time in the NFL than White, but Maroney and Addai have already shown talent and play for teams that should put them in positions to score a lot of fantasy points.

white should be at the end of the list. Henry isnt going away and white hasnt shown anything. Addai is getting to be a bigger part of the offense and Maroney is showing good stuff in NE.switch white and addai.

 

[fsufan]

The way i see it1. White2. Maroney3. Drew4. Bush5. Williams6. AddaiAny thoughts?

what has White done to take the job next year?Addai at 6th?He will take the job this year

 

[code]

The way i see it1. White2. Maroney3. Drew4. Bush5. Williams6. AddaiAny thoughts?

79 votes and you're still the only one who voted White

 

[MLBrandow]

1. MJD

2. Williams

3. Addai

4. Maroney

5. Bush

6. White

I'm a huge LenDale White fan, but he won't get his chance to shine until probably his third year.

 

[Toolboxx]

If we are talking purely where we would draft these players next year, this is the order I would take them.

1. Addai - Will be the unquestioned number one.

2. Maroney - Will Dillon be back next year?

3. MJD - Finding the end zone with limited touches

4. Williams - Would have been higher if not for missed time this year

5. Bush - His game not translating well to the pro level, Duece is still the man

6. White - Limited playing time, bad attitude, and THenry hurting him

 

[zamboni]

Addai hasnt shown to much this year but who knows

I think Addai has been way more impressive than most expected, not just running the ball but from an overall NFL game.He may be not be Edge, but seems to be a pretty near perfect fit for the offense.

 

[Erin Go Bragh]

The way i see it

1. White

2. Maroney

3. Drew

4. Bush

5. Williams

6. Addai

Any thoughts?

what has White done to take the job next year?Addai at 6th?

He will take the job this year

I'm not saying White has done anything to take the job, but I don't think Travis Henry will be standing in his way:Henry article

From the article:

When the Titans restructured Travis Henry's contract this offseason, an $8.3 million roster bonus was added for the 2007 offseason.

No matter how well he's playing, Henry will need to restructure the deal or he will be cut. With LenDale White on deck, there's no way Tennessee would guarantee Henry $8.3 million for next season.

 

[fuball]

The way i see it1. White2. Maroney3. Drew4. Bush5. Williams6. AddaiAny thoughts?

79 votes and you're still the only one who voted White

well, lookslike i got taken. I gave up Edge and Roy Williams forSantana Moss and Lendale. I was convinced i got the better of this deal in Lendale but i guess i was wrong. I also have Drew and like his upside

 

[The_Hunchback]

The only reason I pick Addai is that I figure he will be the only starting RB but also get most of the carries (meaning he doesn't get stuck in RBBC). He might not be the best of these RBs but for next year he has probably the best shot at being on top of the others.

I don't see Dillon going away, at least not completely even if Maroney becomes the starter and I don't think he gets released. I think the same of the others, Drew with either Taylor or Jones, Bush with McAllister, Williams with Foster and White with Henry.