Rank these QB's going forward (1 Viewer)

[Judge Smails]

If you had to add to your roster using the following, how would you rank 'em?

Ben Roethlisberger (vs. Cincy, @ NE, vs. DAL, @ Balt, @ Ten)

Sage Rosenfels (vs. CLE, vs. JAX, @ GB, vs. TEN, @ OAK)

Matt Cassell (@ MIA, vs. PIT, @ SEA, @ OAK, vs. AZ)

Kerry Collins (vs. JETS, @ DET, vs. CLE, @ HOU, vs. PIT)

 

[greenline]

Cassel

Collins

Roethlisberger

Rosenfels.

Basing this by weighting playoffs heavier. Sage's playoff schedule is tough.

 

[Angry Beavers]

Cassell

Collins

Roth

Rosenfels

I started a similar topic... who else other than Cassell would you like to have in the playoffs this year?

 

[Sigmund Bloom]

Cassel

Sage (as long as you dont get penalized too heavily for turnovers)

Ben

Collins (although he might be #1 in week 15)

 

[travdogg]

Ben, I think he's going to be good down the stretch.

Cassel

Sage, if you don't lose points for turnovers maybe he should be above Cassel.

Collins

 

[Judge Smails]

A little surprised at the results so far. Teams seem to be stacking the line against TN, forcing Collins to throw (his attempts have been way up). They have opened up the playbook, have decent big WR's and a good tight end, and TN has by FAR the best passing schedule of those listed above. Ben's schedule is bad - it's even dicey playing him vs. the Bengals this week. Cassel? Was last week a mirage? Are games that might look good (@Oak) really bad matchups when more closely inspected (D can get fired up in the Black Hole).

 

[greenline]

A little surprised at the results so far. Teams seem to be stacking the line against TN, forcing Collins to throw (his attempts have been way up). They have opened up the playbook, have decent big WR's and a good tight end, and TN has by FAR the best passing schedule of those listed above. Ben's schedule is bad - it's even dicey playing him vs. the Bengals this week. Cassel? Was last week a mirage? Are games that might look good (@Oak) really bad matchups when more closely inspected (D can get fired up in the Black Hole).

Oakland is a bad matchup but Sea and ARZ are great. I based it on the whole picture and weighted the three playoff weeks accordingly. I still wouldn't touch Sage with that schedule.

 

[Black]

CasselSage (as long as you dont get penalized too heavily for turnovers)BenCollins (although he might be #1 in week 15)

How's about ranking some other nubs:Orton JAC NO GB Thigpen @DEN SD MIA Hasselback NE @STL NYJ Delhomme TB DEN @NYG