Rank Your Top 10 RBs and WRs (1 Viewer)

[RageRhino]

Curious to see how values have changed. I'll post mine after a few others chime in.

RB

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

WR

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

 

[fsufan]

Curious to see how values have changed. I'll post mine after a few others chime in.

RB

1 LT

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

WR

1 Holt

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

 

[JuniorNB]

Curious to see how values have changed. I'll post mine after a few others chime in.

RB

1 LT

2 Portis3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

WR

1 Holt

2 S. Smith

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

 

[Steve Dallas]

Assuming it's a PPR league:

RB

1 LT

2 Portis

3 KJones

4 LJ

5 Steven Jackson

6 Frank Gore

7 Ronnie Brown

8 Westbrook

9 Tiki Barber

10 Tatum Bell

WR

1 Holt

2 Steve Smith

3 TO

4 Roy Williams

5 Marvin Harrison

6 Lavernues Coles

7 Boldin

8 Donald Driver

9 Reggie Williams

10 Andre Johnson

 

[dawgtrails]

I'll play

RB

1 LT

2 LJ

3 Jax

4 Portis

5 Tiki

6 Rudi

7 K Jones

8 Westbrook

9 Tatum Bell

10 R Brown

WR

1 Holt

2 Smith

3 TO

4 R Williams

5 A Johnson

6 D Jackson

7 Harrison

8 Boldin

9 Housh

10 Driver

 

[Cowboys#1]

rb

1. l. tomlinson

2. f. gore

3. s. jackson

4. c. portis

5. l. johnson

6. t. bell

7. b. westbrook

8. j. jones

9. r. johnson

10. w. parker

wr

1. t. holt

2. t. owens

3. b. berrian

4. c. johnson

5. s. smith

6. a. boldin

7. l. coles

8. m. harrison

9. d. jackson

10. r. wayne

 

[dawgtrails]

This was a lot harder than I thought it would be, but here go. ETA: For PPR leagueTomlinson L, SD 1 Westbrook B, PHI 2Johnson L, KC 3Johnson R, CIN 4Parker W, PIT 5Portis C, WAS 6McAllister D, NO 7Gore F, SF 8Brown R, MIA 9Alexander 10Holt T, STL 1Jackson D, SEA 2Burress P, NYG 3Boldin A, ARI 4Berrian B, CHI 5Coles L, NYJ 6Smith S, CAR 7Moss S, WAS 8Houshmandzadeh T, CIN 9Walker J, DEN 10

No Steven Jackson? No TO, R Williams, Harrison? I don't see Burress or S Moss being that high

 

[PizzaDeliveryGuy]

RB

1 Tomlinson

2 Portis

3 Jackson

4 Barber

5 Parker

6 L. Johnson

7 Alexander

8 Gore

9 Bell

10 R. Johnson

WR

1a Smith

1b Holt

3 Harrison

4 Williams

5 Coles

6 A. Johnson

7 Wayne

8 D. Jackson

9 S. Moss

10 Owens

I honestly think you can take 5-10 on the RBs add Westbrook, Dunn, McGahee, and the Jones boys and tier them together.

 

[Yitbos69]

RB

1LT

2LJ

3SJAX

4Portis

5Ronnie

6Tiki

7Rudi

8Parker

9KJ

10Gore

WR

1Holt

2Smith

3Roy

4A.Johnson

5Harrison

6Boldin

7CJ

8Santana Moss

9DJ

10Plax

 

[Flyin Pigs]

RB:

1. LT

2. Portis

3. Larry

4. Steve Jackson

5. Westbrook (I think he misses seome time - no inj bumps him to #2)

6. Rudi

7. K Jones

8. Tiki

9. Gore

10. Ronnie Brown

WR:

1. Holt

2. S Smith

3. Roy Williams

4. D Jackson

5. Marvin Harrison

6. Lav Coles

7. Boldin

8. Berrian

9. Plax

10. TO

YMMV

 

[kncks12]

This was a lot harder than I thought it would be, but here go. ETA: For PPR leagueTomlinson L, SD 1 Westbrook B, PHI 2Johnson L, KC 3Johnson R, CIN 4Parker W, PIT 5Portis C, WAS 6McAllister D, NO 7Gore F, SF 8Brown R, MIA 9Alexander 10Holt T, STL 1Jackson D, SEA 2Burress P, NYG 3Boldin A, ARI 4Berrian B, CHI 5Coles L, NYJ 6Smith S, CAR 7Moss S, WAS 8Houshmandzadeh T, CIN 9Walker J, DEN 10

Very confused by this list of receivers! First, You have S. Smith #7, did you happen to see what he did to the Ravens yesterday? Yes they are a top Defense! I would not have Burress number 3 by any stretch of the imagination, D Jax is def. going to lose balls to Branch and I don't think he will be 2, but could be top 10. How Roy Williams and Andre Johnson are not in your top 10 is beyond me? And also TO has a better chance of being there than Walker IMO.

 

[dawgtrails]

This was a lot harder than I thought it would be, but here go. ETA: For PPR leagueTomlinson L, SD 1 Westbrook B, PHI 2Johnson L, KC 3Johnson R, CIN 4Parker W, PIT 5Portis C, WAS 6McAllister D, NO 7Gore F, SF 8Brown R, MIA 9Alexander 10Holt T, STL 1Jackson D, SEA 2Burress P, NYG 3Boldin A, ARI 4Berrian B, CHI 5Coles L, NYJ 6Smith S, CAR 7Moss S, WAS 8Houshmandzadeh T, CIN 9Walker J, DEN 10

Very confused by this list of receivers! First, You have S. Smith #7, did you happen to see what he did to the Ravens yesterday? Yes they are a top Defense! I would not have Burress number 3 by any stretch of the imagination, D Jax is def. going to lose balls to Branch and I don't think he will be 2, but could be top 10. How Roy Williams and Andre Johnson are not in your top 10 is beyond me? And also TO has a better chance of being there than Walker IMO.

Dude, I could rip anyone's Top 10 as well. Where's yours? And the question was from here out. I don't want players on loosing teams. We also didn't discuss scoring system, starting quals, etc.Deep breath. Drink the Decaf.

Your list is whacked though

 

[RageRhino]

This was a lot harder than I thought it would be, but here go. ETA: For PPR leagueTomlinson L, SD 1 Westbrook B, PHI 2Johnson L, KC 3Johnson R, CIN 4Parker W, PIT 5Portis C, WAS 6McAllister D, NO 7Gore F, SF 8Brown R, MIA 9Alexander 10Holt T, STL 1Jackson D, SEA 2Burress P, NYG 3Boldin A, ARI 4Berrian B, CHI 5Coles L, NYJ 6Smith S, CAR 7Moss S, WAS 8Houshmandzadeh T, CIN 9Walker J, DEN 10

Very confused by this list of receivers! First, You have S. Smith #7, did you happen to see what he did to the Ravens yesterday? Yes they are a top Defense! I would not have Burress number 3 by any stretch of the imagination, D Jax is def. going to lose balls to Branch and I don't think he will be 2, but could be top 10. How Roy Williams and Andre Johnson are not in your top 10 is beyond me? And also TO has a better chance of being there than Walker IMO.

Dude, I could rip anyone's Top 10 as well. Where's yours? And the question was from here out. I don't want players on loosing teams. We also didn't discuss scoring system, starting quals, etc.Deep breath. Drink the Decaf.

Your list is whacked though

I'm sure it is, I put it together in less than 10 mins. I pay the $29.99 just like everyone else so I don't spend days making lists. Just hoping for open conversation to tweek the list and that's what I got (also kills some time). At least people are giving reasons and opinions.

i like your list. i have 2 of your top 10 RBs and 3 of your top 10 WRs, sweet. i hope you are right!

 

[JuniorNB]

This was a lot harder than I thought it would be, but here go. ETA: For PPR leagueTomlinson L, SD 1 Westbrook B, PHI 2Johnson L, KC 3Johnson R, CIN 4Parker W, PIT 5Portis C, WAS 6McAllister D, NO 7Gore F, SF 8Brown R, MIA 9Alexander 10Holt T, STL 1Jackson D, SEA 2Burress P, NYG 3Boldin A, ARI 4Berrian B, CHI 5Coles L, NYJ 6Smith S, CAR 7Moss S, WAS 8Houshmandzadeh T, CIN 9Walker J, DEN 10

Very confused by this list of receivers! First, You have S. Smith #7, did you happen to see what he did to the Ravens yesterday? Yes they are a top Defense! I would not have Burress number 3 by any stretch of the imagination, D Jax is def. going to lose balls to Branch and I don't think he will be 2, but could be top 10. How Roy Williams and Andre Johnson are not in your top 10 is beyond me? And also TO has a better chance of being there than Walker IMO.

Dude, I could rip anyone's Top 10 as well. Where's yours? And the question was from here out. I don't want players on loosing teams. We also didn't discuss scoring system, starting quals, etc.Deep breath. Drink the Decaf.

Your list is whacked though

Just imagine if someone started this thread in late August and some clown decided to put Berrian in his top five. Or TJ Housh ahead of Chad.Point is, why bother arguing with someone else's projections? It's all just a crapshoot.

 

[fsufan]

This was a lot harder than I thought it would be, but here go. ETA: For PPR leagueTomlinson L, SD 1 Westbrook B, PHI 2Johnson L, KC 3Johnson R, CIN 4Parker W, PIT 5Portis C, WAS 6McAllister D, NO 7Gore F, SF 8Brown R, MIA 9Alexander 10Holt T, STL 1Jackson D, SEA 2Burress P, NYG 3Boldin A, ARI 4Berrian B, CHI 5Coles L, NYJ 6Smith S, CAR 7Moss S, WAS 8Houshmandzadeh T, CIN 9Walker J, DEN 10

Very confused by this list of receivers! First, You have S. Smith #7, did you happen to see what he did to the Ravens yesterday? Yes they are a top Defense! I would not have Burress number 3 by any stretch of the imagination, D Jax is def. going to lose balls to Branch and I don't think he will be 2, but could be top 10. How Roy Williams and Andre Johnson are not in your top 10 is beyond me? And also TO has a better chance of being there than Walker IMO.

Dude, I could rip anyone's Top 10 as well. Where's yours? And the question was from here out. I don't want players on loosing teams. We also didn't discuss scoring system, starting quals, etc.Deep breath. Drink the Decaf.

Your list is whacked though

Just imagine if someone started this thread in late August and some clown decided to put Berrian in his top five. Or TJ Housh ahead of Chad.Point is, why bother arguing with someone else's projections? It's all just a crapshoot.

 

[dawgtrails]

Well why bother making lists if we can't discuss them?

Gee, this is fun, let's all make a list and post it so we can all look at it and not comment.

This is a discussion board, not a list making board.

The guy brought up some questionable wide receivers he had in his list. No need to attack him...how about trying to educate him. Or try to explain why you would have such outliers in the list.

When someone leaves out a Harrison, or has S Smith lower than most would...don't get all offended when someone questions it. Back it up. Maybe you're right, maybe not. That's not the point though.

 

[Deranged Hermit]

Curious to see how values have changed. I'll post mine after a few others chime in.

Here's mine:

RB

1 LT

2 Portis

3 Rudi

4 LJ

5 Westbrook

6 Tiki

7 S. Jackson

8 Parker

9 Gore

10 Alexander

WR

1 Holt

2 S. Smith

3 Housh

4 Boldin

5 Roy

6 Berrian

7 Harrison

8 Burress

9 Coles

10 Wayne

 

[TLEF316]

personally, i think you guys who have berrian in the top 5 are dreaming. the guy has had a few good games and all of a sudden he is better than steve smith(after what smith did yesterday) i realize that no list will be perfect, but i cant believe how quickly some of you are guzzling that kool-aid

 

[dawgtrails]

Well why bother making lists if we can't discuss them?Gee, this is fun, let's all make a list and post it so we can all look at it and not comment.This is a discussion board, not a list making board.The guy brought up some questionable wide receivers he had in his list. No need to attack him...how about trying to educate him. Or try to explain why you would have such outliers in the list.When someone leaves out a Harrison, or has S Smith lower than most would...don't get all offended when someone questions it. Back it up. Maybe you're right, maybe not. That's not the point though.

Thanks and here's my reason for leaving out Harrison. Indy hasn't shown the high-powered offence they were with Edge so the WR are getting covered more. Also, I worry about WRs with bad hammys and Smith has two bad hammys.

See, now that wasn't too hard just kiddin manI worry too about hamstrings, but man, he is damn good. Steve Smith is a legit MVP candidate, he really changes that team.

 

[Banger]

personally, i think you guys who have berrian in the top 5 are dreaming. the guy has had a few good games and all of a sudden he is better than steve smith(after what smith did yesterday) i realize that no list will be perfect, but i cant believe how quickly some of you are guzzling that kool-aid

Michael Clayton '04 = Berrian '06

 

[Deranged Hermit]

personally, i think you guys who have berrian in the top 5 are dreaming. the guy has had a few good games and all of a sudden he is better than steve smith(after what smith did yesterday) i realize that no list will be perfect, but i cant believe how quickly some of you are guzzling that kool-aid

:checkslist:Whew, good thing I had him at 6. After Holt and Smith things are wide open at WR. Heck, there are at least 5 more WR I could argue should make my top 10 but didn't.

 

[yinzer]

Since I dont have any PPR leagues, heres what I think for standard scoring

RB

1LT

2Portis

3Rudi

4Parker (Its about time ppl quit bashing FWP and respect he's got game)

5LJ

6Ronnie

7Westbrook

8SJax

9Gore

10Tiki (almost Deuce or KJ, but Tiki will get some TD's sometime soon)

WR

1Holt

2Smith

3RoyW

--from here on out, I find it pretty difficult w/o PPR and considering how many surprises are high now and how many preseason Top 10's aren't in the Top 20, but here it goes--

4DJax

5Burress

6Colston

7Owens

8Boldin

9Andre

10Houshamazoo

And like I said, after looking through all the posts, Id say only about 1/3 had Willie Parker in their top 10, and most who did from #8-10. I can see a downgrade from #4 where I have him for PPR leagues, but in my leagues he's currently #4 and thats without the ground game really even getting going until yesterday, the offense in disarray, and playing teams like SD and JAX in their first 5 games. Besides LT and Portis, Id say he's the only other Top 5 lock (except in PPR leagues)

 

[kncks12]

This was a lot harder than I thought it would be, but here go. ETA: For PPR leagueTomlinson L, SD 1 Westbrook B, PHI 2Johnson L, KC 3Johnson R, CIN 4Parker W, PIT 5Portis C, WAS 6McAllister D, NO 7Gore F, SF 8Brown R, MIA 9Alexander 10Holt T, STL 1Jackson D, SEA 2Burress P, NYG 3Boldin A, ARI 4Berrian B, CHI 5Coles L, NYJ 6Smith S, CAR 7Moss S, WAS 8Houshmandzadeh T, CIN 9Walker J, DEN 10

Very confused by this list of receivers! First, You have S. Smith #7, did you happen to see what he did to the Ravens yesterday? Yes they are a top Defense! I would not have Burress number 3 by any stretch of the imagination, D Jax is def. going to lose balls to Branch and I don't think he will be 2, but could be top 10. How Roy Williams and Andre Johnson are not in your top 10 is beyond me? And also TO has a better chance of being there than Walker IMO.

Dude, I could rip anyone's Top 10 as well. Where's yours? And the question was from here out. I don't want players on loosing teams. We also didn't discuss scoring system, starting quals, etc.Deep breath. Drink the Decaf.

I was going to make a list, but as I scrolled down and saw yours it became entertaining to me. Well here is mine....Rip away!RB's in PPR1. LT2. Westbrook3. LJ4. Portis5. S. Jackson6. Tiki (just because of lack of GL carries)7. Kevin Jones8. C. Taylor9. R. Brown10. GoreWR's1. S. Smith2. T. Holt3. Williams4. TO5. Coles6. Harrison7. A. Johnson8. C. Johnson9. House10. Boldin

 

[kncks12]

This was a lot harder than I thought it would be, but here go. ETA: For PPR leagueTomlinson L, SD 1 Westbrook B, PHI 2Johnson L, KC 3Johnson R, CIN 4Parker W, PIT 5Portis C, WAS 6McAllister D, NO 7Gore F, SF 8Brown R, MIA 9Alexander 10Holt T, STL 1Jackson D, SEA 2Burress P, NYG 3Boldin A, ARI 4Berrian B, CHI 5Coles L, NYJ 6Smith S, CAR 7Moss S, WAS 8Houshmandzadeh T, CIN 9Walker J, DEN 10

Very confused by this list of receivers! First, You have S. Smith #7, did you happen to see what he did to the Ravens yesterday? Yes they are a top Defense! I would not have Burress number 3 by any stretch of the imagination, D Jax is def. going to lose balls to Branch and I don't think he will be 2, but could be top 10. How Roy Williams and Andre Johnson are not in your top 10 is beyond me? And also TO has a better chance of being there than Walker IMO.

Dude, I could rip anyone's Top 10 as well. Where's yours? And the question was from here out. I don't want players on loosing teams. We also didn't discuss scoring system, starting quals, etc.Deep breath. Drink the Decaf.

I was going to make a list, but as I scrolled down and saw yours it became entertaining to me. Well here is mine....Rip away!RB's in PPR1. LT2. Westbrook3. LJ4. Portis5. S. Jackson6. Tiki (just because of lack of GL carries)7. Kevin Jones8. C. Taylor9. R. Brown10. GoreWR's1. S. Smith2. T. Holt3. Williams4. TO5. Coles6. Harrison7. A. Johnson8. C. Johnson9. House10. Boldin

YOUR LIST SUCKS! YOU SO STUPID! Just kidding.It's not easy I know. You want to look at the numbers, but then you find it hard to leave a guy like Chad or Harrison out. Since you have Chad in front of House, I'm guessing your more of the "outlook" type. I haven't seen enough to call him the "out right go-to guy" this year.

Agreed, but I am just going forward saying Chad has to get it going. He looked good yesterday, they just were not near endzone enough. I don't own the guy in any league, I just like him.

 

[avoiding injuries]

NO PPR

1. LT

2. LJ

3. FWP

4. S Jax

5. Portis

6. Tiki

7. Tatum

8. Rudi

9. Willis

10. KJ

1. Holt

2. Smith

3. Roy

4. A Johnson

5. TO

6. Harrison

7. C Johnson

8. Boldin

9. D Jax/Branch (not sure which one)

10. Horn (breakout game yesterday?)

 

[shadyridr]

I think Reggie Williams needs to be in more top 10s

 

[mad sweeney]

For those of you that have Rudi in your top 10:

Do you still have him there with the loss of Levi Jones and the possible return of Chris Perry? Does his line woes change your ranking?

 

[Bollywood]

From week 7 onwards...

PPR

1. Westbrook

2. Portis

3. LT2

4. S Jax

5. Tiki

6. KJ

7. Tatum

8. Rudi

9. LJ

10. Alexander

1. S. Smith (C0-MVP w/ McNabb)

2. Big Game

3. Roy

4. A Johnson

5. Boldin

6. Harrison

7. Coles

8. Jennings

9. Wayne

10. Either "Where you at 85?" or "TJ Whosyourmama"

 

[dawgtrails]

I'm gonna rework my list. Do it such that #1 RB is someone I wouldnt trade for anyone, #2 I would trade only for #1, #3 would only tade for either #1, or #2....etc. PPR league.

1. LT

2. LJ

3. Jax

4. Tiki

5. Westbrook

6. Portis

7. Rudi

8. K Jones

9. R Brown

10. Tatum

1. Holt

2. S Smith

3. Roy

4. Boldin

5. Harrison

6. A Johnson

7. TO

8. D Jax

9. Coles

10. Housh

Heck, while I'm at it...heres the QBs

1. Manning

2. McNabb

3. Bulger

4. Hasselback

5. Eli

6. Palmer

7. Brees

8. Kitna

9. Brady

10. Favre

 

[rascal]

I own Tiki, Westbrook, and K Jones in a PPR. I wish you guys would quit mentioning them as the fantasy gods are taking notice.

Thanks.

I hear Lamont Jordan is going to be a stud.