Every Suggs owner =
Droughns owner =
Droughns is only going to be insurance for if/when Suggs gets hurt.
I think some people who are giddy to have won the debate about who's better, William Green and Lee Suggs don't see Suggs for what he is. He may be better than Green but he ain't great. Beating out Green is no big deal. Beating out a guy that had more production in a single season than Suggs has had in a career is not going to be that easy. Keep in mind that I was leading the charge on the Lee Suggs is better than William Green threads saying Green blows. But Suggs is going to have a tough battle holding onto the starting job of RD is traded to Cleveland.
Have you seen the two play?William Green as a physical specimen is impressive. Perfect size. Great speed. Great power. Explosive. So why does he stink?
Well, clearly personal issues are a big part of it. (Duh) But past that, even if Green was a model citizen, I don't believe that Green would have ever been a big time player. His biggest flaw is a lack of vision. For a RB, this is often a critical flaw and it proved true for Green.
I often saw Green have an opportunity to either make a cut and take a big gain or run toward approaching defenders. He always ran towards the defenders. At times, he would freeze and just wait to get tackled. Sometimes he would do this just short of the first down line. His instincts as a RB are just plain terrible. Great athlete, awful runner.
Suggs is nearly his opposite. He isn't the same athlete that Green is. But his instincts are top-shelf. At times, Suggs almost seems like he has eyes in the back of his head or a sixth sense. If there is a crease anywhere, Suggs could find it. On top of that, Suggs has lightning speed and explosiveness.
Suggs achilies heel is clearly his lack of durability. Its a major weakness. Neck stinger, turf toe, etc. He got his chance, but perhaps to being fragile, perhaps due to circumstance, he couldn't answer the call.
But are we to believe that Droughns is better. Droughns is a guy that was cast aside in favor of Tatum Bell. A good RB for the system perhaps, but certainlly not an elite talent. In Suggs can stay healthy he should dispatch Droughns without a second thought.
If the Browns were serious about revamping the running game they would be debating Cadillac, Ronnie Brown and Benson. As it is, they are debating cheap insurance policies in case Suggs can't step up to the plate.
My thinking is that Suggs get another chance. If he's injured or ineffctive Droughns will get a chance. If neither is effective it'll be a round 1 RB in 06.
But Suggs gets first bite at the apple in 05.