It is not nitpicking when a guy is not even worthy of being discussed at the top players at their position. That is a wrong statement that deserves clarification for anyone who would make it because Bell has not nor is he considered in that light by anyone but you.
You have not backed up the statement either. Instead resting on some imaginary laurels. WTG.
Huh? I just proved how he wasn't far from Gio, who you chose to crown instead, in the passing game. You are debating against pretty simple math in the matter, not me. He also outproduced Gio's raw totals while playing less games. Pardon me for thinking a player with those credentials has equal-greater upside as the other for 2014. Your statement needs clarification if aything.
Maybe I am debating against incorrect math. That is why I put numbers up there to make that more clear.
Here is FFtoday PPR results from 2013-
1. Jamaal Charles KC 15 259 1,288 12 104 70 693 7 382.1 25.5
2. Matt Forte CHI 16 288 1,341 9 95 75 592 3 340.3 21.3
3. LeSean McCoy PHI 16 314 1,607 9 64 52 540 2 332.7 20.8
4. Knowshon Moreno DEN 16 242 1,039 10 74 60 548 3 296.7 18.5
5. Marshawn Lynch SEA 16 301 1,257 12 44 36 316 2 277.3 17.3
6. DeMarco Murray DAL 14 217 1,124 9 66 53 348 1 260.2 18.6
7. Reggie Bush DET 14 223 1,006 4 80 54 506 3 247.2 17.7
8. Eddie Lacy GB 15 284 1,178 11 44 35 257 0 244.5 16.3
9. Chris Johnson TEN 16 279 1,077 6 52 42 345 4 244.2 15.3
10. Adrian Peterson MIN 14 279 1,266 10 40 29 171 1 238.7 17.1
11. Fred Jackson BUF 16 207 896 9 65 46 375 1 233.1 14.6
12. Danny Woodhead SD 16 106 425 2 87 76 605 6 227.0 14.2
13. Giovani Bernard CIN 16 170 695 5 71 56 514 3 224.9 14.1
14. Joique Bell DET 16 166 650 8 69 53 547 0 220.7 13.8
15. Le'Veon Bell PIT 13 244 860 8 66 45 408 0 219.8 16.9
http://www.fftoday.com/stats/playerstats.php?Season=2013&GameWeek=&PosID=20&LeagueID=107644
Bell finished as RB 15 in PPR last season. He was outscored by Fred Jackson, Joique Bell, Woodhead and Bernard who were all time share RB.
Bell finished 10th overall for offensive snaps of all RB at 677 (despite missing the 1st 3 games)
Bernard finished 17th overall for offensive snaps of all RB at 614.
What has made Bell a valuable RB to have (and do not get me wrong I do like Bell) is the high volume of touches and the short yardage TD. Both of those things are threatened to be reduced I think with the Steelers bringing in Blount who is at minimum a good power goal line RB.
Meanwhile Bernard with Hue Jackson as the OC now is expected to have a greatly increased workload.
The idea of Bell being better in PPR is somewhat strange to me as well considering there are many other RB who I expect to outperform him in that scoring system. Not that Bell is a bad passing option. He isn't. But he is not as adept in this aspect of his game as Bernard or many other RB in the league (as shown from last seasons numbers). Honestly what made Bell valuable is mostly the short yardage TD he put up last season, not his passing numbers.
FF numbers sorted by receptions-
1. Pierre Thomas NO 16 147 549 2 84 77 513 3 213.2 13.3
2. Danny Woodhead SD 16 106 425 2 87 76 605 6 227.0 14.2
3. Matt Forte CHI 16 288 1,341 9 95 75 592 3 340.3 21.3
4. Darren Sproles NO 15 53 220 2 89 71 604 2 177.4 11.8
5. Jamaal Charles KC 15 259 1,288 12 104 70 693 7 382.1 25.5
6. Knowshon Moreno DEN 16 242 1,039 10 74 60 548 3 296.7 18.5
7. Ray Rice BAL 15 214 660 4 73 58 321 0 180.1 12.0
8. Giovani Bernard CIN 16 170 695 5 71 56 514 3 224.9 14.1
9. Reggie Bush DET 14 223 1,006 4 80 54 506 3 247.2 17.7
10. Joique Bell DET 16 166 650 8 69 53 547 0 220.7 13.8
11. DeMarco Murray DAL 14 217 1,124 9 66 53 348 1 260.2 18.6
12. LeSean McCoy PHI 16 314 1,607 9 64 52 540 2 332.7 20.8
13. Jacquizz Rodgers ATL 15 97 333 2 62 52 341 2 143.4 9.6
14. Chris Ogbonnaya CLE 16 48 239 0 75 48 343 2 118.2 7.4
15. Shane Vereen NE 8 44 208 1 69 47 427 3 134.5 16.8
16. Fred Jackson BUF 16 207 896 9 65 46 375 1 233.1 14.6
17. Le'Veon Bell PIT 13 244 860 8 66 45 408 0 219.8 16.9
http://www.fftoday.com/stats/playerstats.php?Season=2013&GameWeek=&PosID=20&LeagueID=107644&order_by=Rec&sort_order=DESC
In terms of receptions Bell finished 17th of all RB in 2013 despite getting more snaps than the majority of these RB. So I am not sure why you would consider that scoring format to be an advantage for Bell. I think he finishes better in standard leagues honestly.
Bell also did not score any TD in the passing game while all of these RB scored at least once except for Joique Bell and Rice.
So I am completely baffled at your assertion that Leveon Bell be considered not only a top PPR but potentially THE top RB in PPR. The simple math does not suggest that will be the case at all.
Then you followed that up saying I should have McCoy at the top of RB in PPR. Personally I think Sproles will eat into his targets in the passing game so while McCoy is certainly a top RB (unlike Bell) he may not get as many receptions in 2014 as he did last season.
Saying that Bernard and Bell are similar in passing stats also does not seem right to my simple math.
Bell 45 receptions 408 yards 0TD
Bernard 56 receptions 514 yards 3TD
McCoy 52 receptions 540 yards 2TD
Using my simple math Bernards receiving numbers look much closer to McCoy than they do to Bell.
RB with similar passing numbers as Bell were-
Fred Jackson 46 receptions 375 yards 1TD
Andre Ellington 39 receptions 371 yards 1TD
eta- On a talent and potential basis I see Bernard as being the more talented player. Bernard reminds me a bit of DeAngelo Williams with better pass protection and receiving skills (Although Williams has been underutilized in this and every other aspect of his opportunity).
Bell on the other hand seems like a player who's potential has already been pretty much maxed out in terms of opportunity.
Both are 22 year old players so I think both of their skill levels should improve as they develop.
Here are the percentage of snaps the 2 RB played in 2013 by game-
L. Bell PIT 0% 0% 0% 76% 72% 79% 77% 68% 68% 79% 70% 91% 83% 79% 86% 81%
64.4% of the total offensive snaps.
G.Bernard CIN 36% 34% 54% 74% 49% 58% 49% 46% 48% 67% 48% 50% 55% 77% 56% 63%
54.3% of the total offensive snaps.
Bell averaged 77.61% of the total offensive snaps in the 13 games that he played.