Dr. Octopus said:
Weren’t they right so far?
Guy couldn’t beat out Peyton Barber as a second year player.
He pretty solidly beat out Barber last year IMO.
Unlike 2018 where RoJo was going through some rookie growing pains, Barber was the better back.
But I disagree about your take on 2019. RoJo took a solid step forward, improving across multiple areas and just looked more explosive and effective than Barber. For anyone who owned either of these backs over the last year plus, what was interesting/baffingly frustrating was how Arians played them. It was completely inconsistent, with some games where they split carries, and some games where one back got the lion's share of carries.
I would have argued that RoJo solidly won the job based on performance and "look" on the field, but Arians flip-flopped starters even if RoJo had a much more productive game or lookes more consistent.
Grahamburn said:
Can’t argue that too much. Adding Fournette certainly isn’t better for Jones. However, I don’t think LF is going to be someone who relegates RJ to the bench. My guess is he takes the reps they penciled in for McCoy.
Fournette is also one of the worst blocking backs in the league. He won’t last long if he’s getting Brady hit. Jones had issues with blocking too, but has been reported to have worked on it a great deal.
And it’s going to take some time to get Fournette up to speed. If Jones looks great out of the gate it’s going to be tough for Arians to move away from him.
I don't think it's wrong at all to think Jones holds value as Fournette gets up to speed. I don't think anyone looks to buy into a player's value for just two weeks. There are two ways this can go, IMO, neither good for Jones:
1) Full blown committee -- Fournette early down and short yard/red zone back, RoJo as passing down back (the point about LF's pass pro woes are very poignant -- his 37.3 pass-blocking grade was 6 worst in all of football last year). This takes both touches and TDs away from Jones, and the impact offsets any value he might retain in PPR.
2) Arians rides hot hands as he has shown to do, and Fournette (who may not be great in pass pro but does have a great set of hands) becomes the lion's share guy as a proven 3-down back, relegating Jones to CoP.
Both seem equally likely, both equally killing RoJo's opportunity -- and thus his fantasy value.