retrospective mock draft using 2009 data (1 Viewer)

[moleculo]

would you guys be opposed to doing an 'everyone plays everyone each week' type of heads up? I think that would help us see more accurately what types of teams perform best in a headtohead league.

it's easy enough to report both results, so sure.

 

[Football Critic]

1.06 --- Superbowl MVP, Drew Brees

 

[moleculo]

guys, to keep this rolling, if you don't make a pick in 24 hours, I'll make one for you. The autopick will be the highest available VBD player.

Is that cool with everyone?

 

[Truman]

Yes.

1.07 Andre Johnson WR

 

[moleculo]

1.08 guppy E Wes Welker

 

[moleculo]

1.09 guppy C Dallas Clark

 

[gonzobill5]

guys, to keep this rolling, if you don't make a pick in 24 hours, I'll make one for you. The autopick will be the highest available VBD player.Is that cool with everyone?

Got it - I'll be on later tonight (after 8) with my pick.

 

[gheemony]

guys, to keep this rolling, if you don't make a pick in 24 hours, I'll make one for you. The autopick will be the highest available VBD player.Is that cool with everyone?

Sure, so long as you said a PM too. sometimes I can't check the board, but I get email notice of PMs.

 

[moleculo]

guys, to keep this rolling, if you don't make a pick in 24 hours, I'll make one for you. The autopick will be the highest available VBD player.Is that cool with everyone?

Sure, so long as you said a PM too. sometimes I can't check the board, but I get email notice of PMs.

no problem. I'll send a PM @ 12 hours (give or take)...cool?

 

[gonzobill5]

1.10 GONZO takes Frank Gore

 

[moleculo]

1.11 moleculo Reggie Wayne

 

[moleculo]

1.12 guppy F Larry Fitzgerald

2.01 guppy F Brandon Marshall

 

[moleculo]

2.02 moleculo Randy Moss

 

[moleculo]

rosters with all play results updated.

An interesting note: Despite Brees being the #1 overall QB, picking Aaron Rodgers over Brees gave 8 more wins in all play . I'm sure this won't stand once rosters fill out, but it's interesting none the less.

 

[gonzobill5]

2.03 GONZO takes Miles Austin

edited due to idiocy

 

[moleculo]

2.04 guppy C Steve Smith (NYG)

2.05 guppy E Peyton Manning

 

[FUBAR]

Can we get some color coding for the picks?

Sure. The draft summary is here, and I'll also keep this list up to date by scratching off names of drafted players. i'll have updates done by 5:30PM Eastern every day.

seems out of date

 

[moleculo]

Can we get some color coding for the picks?

Sure. The draft summary is here, and I'll also keep this list up to date by scratching off names of drafted players. i'll have updates done by 5:30PM Eastern every day.

seems out of date

not any more

 

[Truman]

Roddy White

 

[moleculo]

guys, I will be out of town until tomorrow. A PM has been sent to football critic; hopefully he checks in soon and this can continue.

Thanks

 

[Football Critic]

DESEAN JACKSON - WR - PHI

 

[FUBAR]

2.08 Antonio Gates, TE SDC

 

[moleculo]

2.09 guppy G Vernon Davis

2.10 No Way Jose Vincent Jackson (pick made via PM)

2.11 guppy D Matt Schaub

 

[gheemony]

2.12 Joseph Addai

3.01 Hines Ward

 

[moleculo]

At the end of round 2 - all play standings are as follows:

moleculo 78

fubar 72

guppy D 109

gonzobill5 83

No Way Jose 109

guppy E 111

Football Critic 104

Truman 75

guppy F 76

gheemoney 96

guppy C 64

guppy G 76

 

[moleculo]

3.02 guppy D Sidney Rice

 

[No Way Jose]

No way jose takes Sticky Ricky Williams RB

 

[moleculo]

3.04 guppy G Steven Jackson

 

[moleculo]

Guys - to get this done sometime before the NFL draft, let's PM whomever drafts next.

 

[FUBAR]

3.05 Chad "85" formerly known as Johnson... CIN WR

 

[Truman]

Guys - to get this done sometime before the NFL draft, let's PM whomever drafts next.

How about implementing a draft clock? 6 hours or something.

 

[Football Critic]

3.6 Jamaal Charles

 

[Truman]

Jonathan Stewart

 

[moleculo]

3.08 guppy E Santonio Holmes

3.09 guppy C Marques Colston

 

[gonzobill5]

3.10 GONZO takes Ryan Grant

 

[moleculo]

3.11 moleculo Brent Celek

3.12 guppy F Tony Gonzalez

4.01 guppy F Philip Rivers

4.02 moleculo Tom Brady

 

[moleculo]

at the end of round 3 (round 2 all play in parenthesis):

moleculo (78) 72

fubar (72) 79

guppy D (109) 99

gonzobill5 (83) 89

No Way Jose (109) 101

guppy E (111) 114

Football Critic (104) 97

Truman (75) 76

guppy F (76) 79

gheemoney (96) 97

guppy C (64) 73

guppy G (76) 79

Guppy E is pulling away with Peyton Manning, Wes Welker and Santonio Holmes. Of course, we should expect Guppy E to come back down to earth once he picks a TE and a RB.

 

[gonzobill5]

4.03 Gonzo takes Romo

 

[moleculo]

4.04 guppy C Thomas Jones

4.05 guppy E DeAngelo Williams

 

[Truman]

Rashard Mendenhall

 

[Football Critic]

Anquan Boldin

 

[moleculo]

IMO, this is where the draft starts getting interesting...the easy, safe picks are gone, and now it's about what type of player you think will do well, given injuries, etc.

 

[FUBAR]

4.08 Phillip Rivers, SD QB

 

[moleculo]

4.08 Phillip Rivers, SD QB

taken:

3.11 moleculo Brent Celek

3.12 guppy F Tony Gonzalez

4.01 guppy F Philip Rivers

4.02 moleculo Tom Brady

 

[FUBAR]

4.08 Phillip Rivers, SD QB

taken:

3.11 moleculo Brent Celek

3.12 guppy F Tony Gonzalez

4.01 guppy F Philip Rivers

4.02 moleculo Tom Brady

He wasn't scratched off the list! Not sure how I missed it Brett Favre then.

 

[moleculo]

4.09 guppy G Derrick Mason

4.10 No Way Jose Jason Witten (pick made via PM)

4.11 guppy D Kellen Winslow

 

[moleculo]

Can we get some color coding for the picks?

Sure. The draft summary is here, and I'll also keep this list up to date by scratching off names of drafted players. i'll have updates done by 5:30PM Eastern every day. when I get around to it.

seems out of date

updated, and list updated.

 

[gheemony]

Gheemony

Steve Smith (car)

Greg Jennings

 

[moleculo]

5.02 guppy D Donald Driver

 

[moleculo]

at the end of round 4 (rounds 1 and 2 all play in parenthesis):

moleculo (78) (72) 90

fubar (72) (79) 93

guppy D (109) (99) 90

gonzobill5 (83) (89) 101

No Way Jose (109) (101) 96

guppy E (111) (114) 87

Football Critic (104) (97) 92

Truman (75) (76) 66

guppy F (76) (79) 97

gheemoney (96) (97) 90

guppy C (64) (73) 76

guppy G (76) (79) 77

Big movers: Moleculo, fubar, gonzobill5, guppy F, all saw big gains - not coincidentally, these were the teams that took a QB this round. Four of the bottom 5 teams do not have a QB still, so it looks to me like we can't judge the impact of drafting player X until we all have starting line-ups complete.