What's new
Fantasy Football - Footballguys Forums

This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Revis Island (1 Viewer)

flapgreen

Footballguy
In a league where success seems to be based on offensive output, this guy stands alone. It's nothing short of amazing what he does every week, basically by himself on one side of the field. I can't think of many corners in my lifetime that have done what he has done. Champ and Deon are the only ones that come to mind. I love watching him play, or at least rarely seeing him on screen because they don't waste time showing his side of the field. It's a beautiful thing seeing someone perform at this level. Awesome! ;)

 
In a league where success seems to be based on offensive output, this guy stands alone. It's nothing short of amazing what he does every week, basically by himself on one side of the field. I can't think of many corners in my lifetime that have done what he has done. Champ and Deon are the only ones that come to mind. I love watching him play, or at least rarely seeing him on screen because they don't waste time showing his side of the field. It's a beautiful thing seeing someone perform at this level. Awesome! ;)
It's hard for me to judge, since I've only seen it on tv.It seems most QBs just quit and don't throw the ball in his direction, there's not question he's a good CB.But I think a lot of it is reputation now, I think QBs are just too afraid to throw in his direction.I remember in the Detroit game, he made a great play on a pass to CJ, and Stafford just stopped throwing it that way.I find it hard to believe Megatron couldn't get any separation the entire game.
 
In a league where success seems to be based on offensive output, this guy stands alone. It's nothing short of amazing what he does every week, basically by himself on one side of the field. I can't think of many corners in my lifetime that have done what he has done. Champ and Deon are the only ones that come to mind. I love watching him play, or at least rarely seeing him on screen because they don't waste time showing his side of the field. It's a beautiful thing seeing someone perform at this level. Awesome! ;)
It's hard for me to judge, since I've only seen it on tv.It seems most QBs just quit and don't throw the ball in his direction, there's not question he's a good CB.But I think a lot of it is reputation now, I think QBs are just too afraid to throw in his direction.I remember in the Detroit game, he made a great play on a pass to CJ, and Stafford just stopped throwing it that way.I find it hard to believe Megatron couldn't get any separation the entire game.
You're talking about NFL QBs, most with pretty big egos. If there was any chance of success at throwing his direction, I think they would at least be trying it. :unsure:
 
it's a bit like Woodson covering half the field for Michigan. no one went his way.

so to do it on a professional level is truely remarkable and us recognizing it shows that it's not the norm!

 
He's truly great; future HOF most likely.

But, it amazes me the amount of pulling, pushing, and hand jabbing he gets away with down field. Like most superstars, he apparently has his own set of rules.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
Nah, he's just average. At least, that's what TO said, and I guess TO showed him up.
TO beat Revis for a sure TD then the safety came from the other side to tip it away at the last second. That being said it is easier to attack the other part of the Jets defense than to go at Revis. Why throw at their best defender? And Palmer looked bad again last night. Still seems a bit shell shocked.
 
Quick question:

Is he really that much better than Nnamdi? Or is it just due to the ridiculous hype he gets.

 
Revis is back to being Revis. Best CB in the league in my opinion hands down.

I'm a Packers fan but I think Revis got royally jobbed last year in the DPOY voting. Woodson was very good but Revis was spectacular and had a season the likes of which we may not see again for quite awhile. He's back to being that good again after struggling initially following the holdout. Megatron, Andre and now TO have all fallen victim to Revis Island.

 
Quick question:Is he really that much better than Nnamdi? Or is it just due to the ridiculous hype he gets.
The difference is Nnamdi has been doing it for 5 years and has had zero help from the rest of the Raiders crappy defense, while Revis has really only been in his league the last 2 years and also plays on an awesome defense. Swap Revis and Nnamdi and Nnamdi may never give up a reception.
 
basically by himself on one side of the field.
He's good but this has to stop.
?? Revis really doesn't have safety help that often. NFL game rewind has a new feature called Film Room where they show coaches tape, and quite often, Revis really is by himself. I'm not sure why so many people don't like to admit this.As for the comparison between Revis and Nnamdi, from what I've seen of the Raiders scheme, Nnamdi will stay on one side of the field and lock it down, while Revis will follow the other team's best player around the field. Revis was in the slot last night against TO, and he was on him every play that wasn't in zone. I'm not saying that as a criticism of Nnamdi, but I think it makes Revis's job a little harder when he follows the best receiver almost exclusively.
 
Nah, he's just average. At least, that's what TO said, and I guess TO showed him up.
TO beat Revis for a sure TD then the safety came from the other side to tip it away at the last second.
Revis knocked it away and you could make a case that TO pushed off to gain the advantage he had.
Two different plays. The TO push off (not saying he did or didn't) was down the sidelines. The "sure TD" was the back center of the endzone where Poole came in and tipped it away. Could have been zone coverage on that play. Revis wasn't around (IIRC) when Poole defended.
 
Posted this in the TO thread as well, but check out these stats.

Notable WRs vs. Darrelle Revis

This Season

Terrell Owens: 8 targets, 3 catches for 17 yds, no TDs

Andre Johnson: 4 targets, 1 catch for 20 yds, no TDs

Calvin Johnson: 4 targets, 1 catch for 13 yds, no TDs

Greg Jennings: 2 targets, 1 catch for 11 yds, no TDs

Bottom line. You need to seriously consider benching your stud WR when he's on Revis island.

 
Nah, he's just average. At least, that's what TO said, and I guess TO showed him up.
TO beat Revis for a sure TD then the safety came from the other side to tip it away at the last second.
Revis knocked it away and you could make a case that TO pushed off to gain the advantage he had.
Two different plays. The TO push off (not saying he did or didn't) was down the sidelines. The "sure TD" was the back center of the endzone where Poole came in and tipped it away. Could have been zone coverage on that play. Revis wasn't around (IIRC) when Poole defended.
It was zone, which is why Poole was in that space. If you see Revis on the play he peels off into a void.
 
I think Revis has almost perfect technique. He has a knack for looking up at the ball before its thrown. I think a qb looks over there and sees Revis looking back at him alot of times. It would make me want to throw somewhere else too.

I haven't seen enough of Nnamdi to comment on him. That was just my observation on Revis.

Deon had amazing speed and, in my opinion, he sometimes compensated for sloppy technique early in his career with it.

Woodson was phenomonal in coverage also, but i don't think either of them were as sure tacklers against the run as Revis. They were both more explosive ball hawks. Darrell Green was more of a dangerous ball hawk also.

Champ Bailey has had some amazing years. I think he has almost perfect technique also. Personally I think Champ Bailey probably goes HOF at some point - so I would say Revis is like a bigger Champ Bailey (for a lack of a better way of describing his technique) and if he continues to perform at this level he goes HOF also.

:lol:

 
He's truly great; future HOF most likely.

But, it amazes me the amount of pulling, pushing, and hand jabbing he gets away with down field. Like most superstars, he apparently has his own set of rules.
this isn't the nba, he doesn't get away with things that a normal cornerback wouldn't. he didn't have super star status going into last year. he takes full advantage of what the rules allow him too.i don't know if namdi is as good or better, but it's least pretty close. he doesn't get the same recognition because he is on a lesser team and he only plays one side of the field. he doesn't get matched up to one wr the entire game. if andre johnson catches 0 passes matched up against namdi and 5 balls matched up against the other corner, it's not as easy to see how dominant he was.

"Notable WRs vs. Darrelle Revis

This Season

Terrell Owens: 8 targets, 3 catches for 17 yds, no TDs

Andre Johnson: 4 targets, 1 catch for 20 yds, no TDs

Calvin Johnson: 4 targets, 1 catch for 13 yds, no TDs

Greg Jennings: 2 targets, 1 catch for 11 yds, no TDs"

we can't do this kind of straight forward comparison with namdi

i always wanted to watch a highlight tape of him shutting down a wr over the course of a game (unhighlight tape?). any links out there??

 
He's truly great; future HOF most likely.

But, it amazes me the amount of pulling, pushing, and hand jabbing he gets away with down field. Like most superstars, he apparently has his own set of rules.
this isn't the nba, he doesn't get away with things that a normal cornerback wouldn't. he didn't have super star status going into last year. he takes full advantage of what the rules allow him too.i don't know if namdi is as good or better, but it's least pretty close. he doesn't get the same recognition because he is on a lesser team and he only plays one side of the field. he doesn't get matched up to one wr the entire game. if andre johnson catches 0 passes matched up against namdi and 5 balls matched up against the other corner, it's not as easy to see how dominant he was.

"Notable WRs vs. Darrelle Revis

This Season

Terrell Owens: 8 targets, 3 catches for 17 yds, no TDs

Andre Johnson: 4 targets, 1 catch for 20 yds, no TDs

Calvin Johnson: 4 targets, 1 catch for 13 yds, no TDs

Greg Jennings: 2 targets, 1 catch for 11 yds, no TDs"

we can't do this kind of straight forward comparison with namdi

i always wanted to watch a highlight tape of him shutting down a wr over the course of a game (unhighlight tape?). any links out there??
I don't ahve the numbers, but he shut down these players last year:AJ

Moss - twice

Colston

TO - twice

MSW

Steve Smith

Bryant

White

Wayne

85 - twice, one in a playoff

 
I think Revis has almost perfect technique. He has a knack for looking up at the ball before its thrown. I think a qb looks over there and sees Revis looking back at him alot of times. It would make me want to throw somewhere else too.I haven't seen enough of Nnamdi to comment on him. That was just my observation on Revis.Deon had amazing speed and, in my opinion, he sometimes compensated for sloppy technique early in his career with it. Woodson was phenomonal in coverage also, but i don't think either of them were as sure tacklers against the run as Revis. They were both more explosive ball hawks. Darrell Green was more of a dangerous ball hawk also.Champ Bailey has had some amazing years. I think he has almost perfect technique also. Personally I think Champ Bailey probably goes HOF at some point - so I would say Revis is like a bigger Champ Bailey (for a lack of a better way of describing his technique) and if he continues to perform at this level he goes HOF also. :goodposting:
One of Revis' best attributes is how strong he is. He can jam anyone at the LOS, which is why people say that QBs just don't "look his way." Pass patterns are based on intricate timing, and Revis completely disrupts that. A lot of times, he takes the receiver out of the play without even needing to use his incredible coverage skills.
 
Nah, he's just average. At least, that's what TO said, and I guess TO showed him up.
TO beat Revis for a sure TD then the safety came from the other side to tip it away at the last second.
Revis knocked it away and you could make a case that TO pushed off to gain the advantage he had.
Two different plays. The TO push off (not saying he did or didn't) was down the sidelines. The "sure TD" was the back center of the endzone where Poole came in and tipped it away. Could have been zone coverage on that play. Revis wasn't around (IIRC) when Poole defended.
It was zone, which is why Poole was in that space. If you see Revis on the play he peels off into a void.
So I guess we're both pointing out that Revis did not get beat on that play. :goodposting:
 
He's truly great; future HOF most likely.

But, it amazes me the amount of pulling, pushing, and hand jabbing he gets away with down field. Like most superstars, he apparently has his own set of rules.
this isn't the nba, he doesn't get away with things that a normal cornerback wouldn't. he didn't have super star status going into last year. he takes full advantage of what the rules allow him too.i don't know if namdi is as good or better, but it's least pretty close. he doesn't get the same recognition because he is on a lesser team and he only plays one side of the field. he doesn't get matched up to one wr the entire game. if andre johnson catches 0 passes matched up against namdi and 5 balls matched up against the other corner, it's not as easy to see how dominant he was.

"Notable WRs vs. Darrelle Revis

This Season

Terrell Owens: 8 targets, 3 catches for 17 yds, no TDs

Andre Johnson: 4 targets, 1 catch for 20 yds, no TDs

Calvin Johnson: 4 targets, 1 catch for 13 yds, no TDs

Greg Jennings: 2 targets, 1 catch for 11 yds, no TDs"

we can't do this kind of straight forward comparison with namdi

i always wanted to watch a highlight tape of him shutting down a wr over the course of a game (unhighlight tape?). any links out there??
I don't ahve the numbers, but he shut down these players last year:AJ

Moss - twice

Colston

TO - twice

MSW

Steve Smith

Bryant

White

Wayne

85 - twice, one in a playoff
thats the revis list?here is namdi's:

just from skimming the top wr's of the game list from last year

bmarshall 5 for 67 and 1td

vjax 5 for 56 and 1td

aj 2 for 66

vjax 8 for 103 and 1d

bowe 6 for 91

ocho 4 for 67

austin 7 for 145 and 1td

holmes 8 for 145 and 1 td

bmarshall 7 for 73 and 1td

if these numbers were put up with namdi or revis covering them the entire game, there would be no talk about either being elite corners and probably some talk about them being below average corners. since that's not that case with namdi, i have to assume most of these catches were not when namdi was covering them. this is why namdi doesn't get the recognition that revis does. we can't say 'namdi covered vjax the entire game and he only caught 1 pass' like we can with revis because he oakland does not give him that opportunity

 
The scheme is a huge help for Revis. He's an exceptional cover corner, and Ryan has developed a scheme that enchances and utilizes his skills to the fullest. That's not a knock on him at all - he'd be very good in most schemes. But in THIS scheme, it helps him be dominant. I think Asomugha would be incredible in the Jets scheme as well. As good as Revis? I don't know.

But if you want to know how well some types of CBs fit in it, look at the season Cromartie is having. He was pretty darn good when Revis was on the shelf and has played well since he came back.

I'm not saying Revis is interchangeable. He's great because of who he is. But the Jets scheme is prefectly built to showcase what he does as well.

 
flc735 said:
Stewy said:
He's truly great; future HOF most likely.

But, it amazes me the amount of pulling, pushing, and hand jabbing he gets away with down field. Like most superstars, he apparently has his own set of rules.
this isn't the nba, he doesn't get away with things that a normal cornerback wouldn't. he didn't have super star status going into last year. he takes full advantage of what the rules allow him too.i don't know if namdi is as good or better, but it's least pretty close. he doesn't get the same recognition because he is on a lesser team and he only plays one side of the field. he doesn't get matched up to one wr the entire game. if andre johnson catches 0 passes matched up against namdi and 5 balls matched up against the other corner, it's not as easy to see how dominant he was.

"Notable WRs vs. Darrelle Revis

This Season

Terrell Owens: 8 targets, 3 catches for 17 yds, no TDs

Andre Johnson: 4 targets, 1 catch for 20 yds, no TDs

Calvin Johnson: 4 targets, 1 catch for 13 yds, no TDs

Greg Jennings: 2 targets, 1 catch for 11 yds, no TDs"

we can't do this kind of straight forward comparison with namdi

i always wanted to watch a highlight tape of him shutting down a wr over the course of a game (unhighlight tape?). any links out there??
Except that's not straight forward either because Jennings caught 6 passes for 81 yds that game so you're doing the same thing you would have to do when looking at Nnamdi's stats.
 
flc735 said:
nysportsfan said:
flc735 said:
Stewy said:
He's truly great; future HOF most likely.

But, it amazes me the amount of pulling, pushing, and hand jabbing he gets away with down field. Like most superstars, he apparently has his own set of rules.
this isn't the nba, he doesn't get away with things that a normal cornerback wouldn't. he didn't have super star status going into last year. he takes full advantage of what the rules allow him too.i don't know if namdi is as good or better, but it's least pretty close. he doesn't get the same recognition because he is on a lesser team and he only plays one side of the field. he doesn't get matched up to one wr the entire game. if andre johnson catches 0 passes matched up against namdi and 5 balls matched up against the other corner, it's not as easy to see how dominant he was.

"Notable WRs vs. Darrelle Revis

This Season

Terrell Owens: 8 targets, 3 catches for 17 yds, no TDs

Andre Johnson: 4 targets, 1 catch for 20 yds, no TDs

Calvin Johnson: 4 targets, 1 catch for 13 yds, no TDs

Greg Jennings: 2 targets, 1 catch for 11 yds, no TDs"

we can't do this kind of straight forward comparison with namdi

i always wanted to watch a highlight tape of him shutting down a wr over the course of a game (unhighlight tape?). any links out there??
I don't ahve the numbers, but he shut down these players last year:AJ

Moss - twice

Colston

TO - twice

MSW

Steve Smith

Bryant

White

Wayne

85 - twice, one in a playoff
thats the revis list?here is namdi's:

just from skimming the top wr's of the game list from last year

bmarshall 5 for 67 and 1td

vjax 5 for 56 and 1td

aj 2 for 66

vjax 8 for 103 and 1d

bowe 6 for 91

ocho 4 for 67

austin 7 for 145 and 1td

holmes 8 for 145 and 1 td

bmarshall 7 for 73 and 1td

if these numbers were put up with namdi or revis covering them the entire game, there would be no talk about either being elite corners and probably some talk about them being below average corners. since that's not that case with namdi, i have to assume most of these catches were not when namdi was covering them. this is why namdi doesn't get the recognition that revis does. we can't say 'namdi covered vjax the entire game and he only caught 1 pass' like we can with revis because he oakland does not give him that opportunity
Here are the entire game stats for these players last year against the Jets:AJ - 4 for 35

Moss - twice; 4 for 24, 5 for 34

Colston - 2 for 33

TO - twice; 3 for 13, 3 for 31

MSW - 3 for 49

Steve Smith - 1 for 5

Bryant - 2 for 22

White - 4 for 33

Wayne - 3 for 33

85 - twice, one in a playoff - 0 for 0, 2 for 28

Omitted TDs, but i don't feel like going back to look again. This is not to say Revis is better than Nnamdi, or vice versa. The stats are what they are, interpret how you see fit.

ETA: From memory, I think Moss scored one game, MSW, too. I think Wayne had a dropped TD, but again, that's from memory.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
As much as I like to watch Namdi from my seats in Section 119.......he doesnt hold Revis' Jock.....The best corner (edited to add "player") on the Raiders is nowhere near the caliber of Revis. He's just a good corner, but so was springs, harper, the list goes on....they are not great. Revis is Great.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
As much as I like to watch Namdi from my seats in Section 119.......he doesnt hold Revis' Jock.....The best corner (edited to add "player") on the Raiders is nowhere near the caliber of Revis. He's just a good corner, but so was springs, harper, the list goes on....they are not great. Revis is Great.
Wow really? Nnamdi has been great for around 5 years. Revis became great when Rex came to town. He was just pretty good before.
 
jamil said:
DepthCharts said:
As much as I like to watch Namdi from my seats in Section 119.......he doesnt hold Revis' Jock.....The best corner (edited to add "player") on the Raiders is nowhere near the caliber of Revis. He's just a good corner, but so was springs, harper, the list goes on....they are not great. Revis is Great.
Wow really? Nnamdi has been great for around 5 years. Revis became great when Rex came to town. He was just pretty good before.
I think Nnamdi is about the same as Revis.But you do realize Revis was only in the league two years before Rex came to the Jets, right? Rex has helped him, of course, but he was definitely on the rise before then.
 
jamil said:
DepthCharts said:
As much as I like to watch Namdi from my seats in Section 119.......he doesnt hold Revis' Jock.....The best corner (edited to add "player") on the Raiders is nowhere near the caliber of Revis. He's just a good corner, but so was springs, harper, the list goes on....they are not great. Revis is Great.
Wow really? Nnamdi has been great for around 5 years. Revis became great when Rex came to town. He was just pretty good before.
uhmmm...what now?
 
jamil said:
DepthCharts said:
As much as I like to watch Namdi from my seats in Section 119.......he doesnt hold Revis' Jock.....The best corner (edited to add "player") on the Raiders is nowhere near the caliber of Revis. He's just a good corner, but so was springs, harper, the list goes on....they are not great. Revis is Great.
Wow really? Nnamdi has been great for around 5 years. Revis became great when Rex came to town. He was just pretty good before.
I think Nnamdi is about the same as Revis.But you do realize Revis was only in the league two years before Rex came to the Jets, right? Rex has helped him, of course, but he was definitely on the rise before then.
Yea, it's well known to me because my Texans drafted Amobi in front of him and Willis. :no: Yea I realize that he was an up and coming corner that's why I said he was pretty good before, but I think if Rex wasn't there he wouldn't be as good as he is now.
 
DepthCharts said:
As much as I like to watch Namdi from my seats in Section 119.......he doesnt hold Revis' Jock.....The best corner (edited to add "player") on the Raiders is nowhere near the caliber of Revis. He's just a good corner, but so was springs, harper, the list goes on....they are not great. Revis is Great.
Honestly, its because of the style of defense the play. The Raiders do very little exotic and have been overly bland (maybe the most so in the NFL) in the past few years. Though it has changed ever so slightley.And teams have far more choices on what to attack vs Oakland. Meanwhile nothing "helps" Nanmdi in the way that the Jets "help" Revis get big/exciting play opportunities.Nanmdi is great.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
I think week 15 @ steelers he's going to have a tough time if he's stuck on wallace. revis tends to do better vs bigger, stronger receivers who aren't super fast. now of course revis is a superstar and great vs everyone. but if mike wallace can beat his jams and get off the line i think he can run right past revis a couple of times. in that texans game freakin kevin walter's got past him. I am excited to see what happens against wallace, all tho this is thinking ahead and who knows he may end up covering ward who he'd probably completely shut down

 
I think week 15 @ steelers he's going to have a tough time if he's stuck on wallace. revis tends to do better vs bigger, stronger receivers who aren't super fast. now of course revis is a superstar and great vs everyone. but if mike wallace can beat his jams and get off the line i think he can run right past revis a couple of times. in that texans game freakin kevin walter's got past him. I am excited to see what happens against wallace, all tho this is thinking ahead and who knows he may end up covering ward who he'd probably completely shut down
I'm almost positive Cromartie would cover Mike Wallace. Cromartie is the perfect corner for defending Wallace. Wallace isn't particularly physical and he just uses his incredible speed, which is very similar to what Cro does.
 
Deon is still the best cover corner I ever saw ( and unlike revis was a great return man as well - also on offense on occasion ). Bailey isn't even close to Primetime.

Revis and the guy on Oakland are pretty much equal but you don't hear as much about the oakland guy.

 
I think week 15 @ steelers he's going to have a tough time if he's stuck on wallace. revis tends to do better vs bigger, stronger receivers who aren't super fast. now of course revis is a superstar and great vs everyone. but if mike wallace can beat his jams and get off the line i think he can run right past revis a couple of times. in that texans game freakin kevin walter's got past him. I am excited to see what happens against wallace, all tho this is thinking ahead and who knows he may end up covering ward who he'd probably completely shut down
I'm almost positive Cromartie would cover Mike Wallace. Cromartie is the perfect corner for defending Wallace. Wallace isn't particularly physical and he just uses his incredible speed, which is very similar to what Cro does.
Cromartie has become a more physical corner this year. Look at the way he threw around Ocho-cinco this past week.
 
I think week 15 @ steelers he's going to have a tough time if he's stuck on wallace. revis tends to do better vs bigger, stronger receivers who aren't super fast. now of course revis is a superstar and great vs everyone. but if mike wallace can beat his jams and get off the line i think he can run right past revis a couple of times. in that texans game freakin kevin walter's got past him. I am excited to see what happens against wallace, all tho this is thinking ahead and who knows he may end up covering ward who he'd probably completely shut down
I'm almost positive Cromartie would cover Mike Wallace. Cromartie is the perfect corner for defending Wallace. Wallace isn't particularly physical and he just uses his incredible speed, which is very similar to what Cro does.
Cromartie has become a more physical corner this year. Look at the way he threw around Ocho-cinco this past week.
Brandon Marshall 10rec 166yds 1td gave "Hyphen" a physical that night
 
Percy Harvin 5rec 97yds 2tds

Randy Moss 4rec 81yds 1td

who covered these two week5?

I am not knocking Revis. I am merely asking if Revis was playing this game as I do not remember and defensive players were not listed.

 
Percy Harvin 5rec 97yds 2tdsRandy Moss 4rec 81yds 1tdwho covered these two week5?I am not knocking Revis. I am merely asking if Revis was playing this game as I do not remember and defensive players were not listed.
I believe that was the week Revis came back from injury & covered Harvin.
 
Revis in NYC= huge media market

Nnamdi in Oakland= joke of a media market

I know there is ESPN, but don't be fooled by the hype. Nnamdi is awesome.

What I don't understand is who more teams don't put the guy Revis is covering into motion to minimize his ability to jam a stationary target? That is half the battle going against Revis IMO.

 
You shouldn't directly compare Revis and Namdi based on the opposing WR1s stats because Revis typically shadows that WR1 all over the field but Namdi (at least last year) exclusively lined up on one side of the field. (Just goes to show the coaching ineptitude of the Raiders....). In any case, the point made by Football Outsiders is that Namdi basically makes his living on reputation, while Revis makes his defensing passes.

For what it's worth, Football Outsiders did some good analysis of both Revis and Namdi. Thought you might find the following excerpts interesting:

On Revis:

Of course, the success of the Jets’ defense became

synonymous with one man’s name over the course

of the season. Well, actually, one man’s property. Re-

ceivers went to “Revis Island” and came back posting

scathing reviews on Twitter, as Darrelle Revis emerged

as the league’s best defensive player in his third season.

The Associated Press voters gave that title to Charles

Woodson; they were wrong. No one had more of an

impact on his defense than Revis, and the Jets’ defense

was better than the Packers’ defense was.

Revis had a very rare mix of both quality and quan-

tity. He led the league in Adjusted Yards per Pass and

Success Rate, which is impressive enough by itself,

but what was more impressive is that he still drew the

sixth-highest target rate of any defensive back in the

league. He was consistently able to convince quar-

terbacks to throw in his direction, and yet, effective

enough to prevent those passes from being completed.

That raises his value compared to a player like Nnam-

di Asomugha, whose greatness simply funnels targets

over to the other, weaker players on the roster.

Placing Revis’ performance in context is difficult.

Charting numbers are far from perfect measures of

performance. More importantly, with only five years

of charting data, there are no obvious reference

points for a historically-great performance, such as

throwing for 50 touchdowns or running for 2,000

yards. What we can do is incorporate a statistical

methodology known as Z-scores — which isolates

the difference between an outlying statistic and an

average — and then translate that into the format of

more traditional statistics.

Revis allowed an adjusted average of 3.5 yards per

pass. The average for qualifying corners was 7.5, while

the standard deviation was 1.37. The Z-Score repre-

sents how many standard deviations above or below

the mean the statistic in question was; in this case, Re-

vis was 2.9 standard deviations below the mean. If we

apply the same analysis to his Success Rate, we find

that he was 3.0 standard deviations above the mean

(above, in this case, because a high Success Rate is

good, while a high Average Yards per Pass is bad).

Splitting the difference between the two suggests that

Revis was playing at a level 2.95 standard deviations

better than the average cornerback.

Now, keep in mind that Revis was also targeted on

96 passes, the fifth-most of any corner in the league.

If we look at the fifth-most frequently used players at

quarterback, running back and wide receiver, and ad-

just their statistical lines on a per-play basis to be 2.95

standard deviations above the average performance

by a qualifying player at their position, the results are

staggering *** See Below. A player playing at Revis’ level

while getting a comparable usage rate at a different

position in 2009 would have set the NFL passing re-

cord by nearly 500 yards, beat out Jerry Rice for the

single-season receiving record, or run for 2,000 yards

while averaging a record-tying 6.4 yards per carry.
This is ridiculous:player | Actual Line | Revis-ized Line

Peyton Manning: 4,640 passing yards 5,532 passing yards

Maurice Jones-Drew: 1,391 rushing yards 2,000 rushing yards

Brandon Marshall: 1,127 receiving yards 1,922 receiving yards

On Namdi:

There is Nnamdi Asomugha and there is everyone else. There’s not much to say about Asomugha at this point

that you don’t already know; yes, he is that good, and yes, he deserves better than his fate. What makes Aso-

mugha different from Darrelle Revis is that Revis was preventing passes last year with great coverage, while

Asomugha was preventing passes simply by virtue of his existence. Every other cornerback with at least 12

starts had more than twice as many targets as Asomugha. Even better, Asomugha brings a strong all-around

game; his numbers on run tackles are consistently excellent, and they’re backed up by watching him play. When

the Broncos threw a throwback pass to Ryan Clady this year, Clady was one-in-one in the open field against

Asomugha. Most corners would be intimidated by a guy that outweighs them by 100-plus pounds; Asomugha

just sprinted towards him and cut out his legs.

The problem is that opponents can easily scheme around Asomugha. Like many defenses, the Raiders gener-

ally leave their cornerbacks on specific sides, with Asomugha on the offensive left and Chris Johnson on the

offensive right. So, of course, Oakland opponents threw only 27 percent of passes to the left, the lowest figure

in the league. A full 50 percent of passes thrown to opposing number-one receivers had either Chris Johnson or

Stanford Routt in coverage. Only 12 percent had Asomugha in coverage. To give one example, last year Kyle

Orton threw 67 passes to Brandon Marshall on the left side of the field. Not a single one of those came in the

two games against Oakland.

This is why the 2009 Raiders were dominated by opposing number-one receivers, and why Chris Johnson

is targeted more than any cornerback in football.
 
Last edited by a moderator:

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top