Rickie Weeks or Robinson Cano (1 Viewer)

[NY/NJMFDIVER]

I will be happy to update as the year goes on, and will tip my hat if Cano outperforms Weeks in 2007.

Have not been to the baseball board since I posted recently. Figured I would wait for the season to play out and assess at that point given it was the first time Weeks was playing "fully" healthy all season.

Thanks Limp - no, I didn't look very hard, because I knew the answer - Weeks was more productive and more valuable down the stretch than Cano. Weeks is better.

I mean, not for nothing dude, you don't have to live here or on this forum, and if you got banged for a timeout from the staff, fine, but I think its pretty plain why you weren't in this thread. You were wrong and its cool, none of us are perfect, but man up about it at least. You want to throw out Weeks few games of errors, why don't we throw out his good games too? You take the good with the bad. Cano's defense improved dramatically this year, his walks were up, and I have a hunch he'll be opening some more eyes this postseason. I mean, I can only assume that this is the Andrea Gail, the fishing trip gone wrong!!!

 

[shadyridr]

Isnt 4 the same mental case who said Lebron wasnt clutch and still continued his argument after his Game 7 performance vs DET? I think its safe to say hes a fisherman or just a child who cant admit when hes wrong.

 

[_4_]

I will be happy to update as the year goes on, and will tip my hat if Cano outperforms Weeks in 2007.

Have not been to the baseball board since I posted recently. Figured I would wait for the season to play out and assess at that point given it was the first time Weeks was playing "fully" healthy all season.

Thanks Limp - no, I didn't look very hard, because I knew the answer - Weeks was more productive and more valuable down the stretch than Cano. Weeks is better.

I mean, not for nothing dude, you don't have to live here or on this forum, and if you got banged for a timeout from the staff, fine, but I think its pretty plain why you weren't in this thread. You were wrong and its cool, none of us are perfect, but man up about it at least. You want to throw out Weeks few games of errors, why don't we throw out his good games too? You take the good with the bad. Cano's defense improved dramatically this year, his walks were up, and I have a hunch he'll be opening some more eyes this postseason. I mean, I can only assume that this is the Andrea Gail, the fishing trip gone wrong!!!

I never said throw any game out after his recall from rehab in the minors - I simply stated one game threw his number of errors off. Didn't happen again all year. I wasn't/am not wrong. Weeks is a better baseball player than Cano.And no, I never was in a LeBron discussion. I said Oden was injury prone and wouldn't be a great pro - you could find that.....

 

[NY/NJMFDIVER]

I will be happy to update as the year goes on, and will tip my hat if Cano outperforms Weeks in 2007.

Have not been to the baseball board since I posted recently. Figured I would wait for the season to play out and assess at that point given it was the first time Weeks was playing "fully" healthy all season.

Thanks Limp - no, I didn't look very hard, because I knew the answer - Weeks was more productive and more valuable down the stretch than Cano. Weeks is better.

I mean, not for nothing dude, you don't have to live here or on this forum, and if you got banged for a timeout from the staff, fine, but I think its pretty plain why you weren't in this thread. You were wrong and its cool, none of us are perfect, but man up about it at least. You want to throw out Weeks few games of errors, why don't we throw out his good games too? You take the good with the bad. Cano's defense improved dramatically this year, his walks were up, and I have a hunch he'll be opening some more eyes this postseason. I mean, I can only assume that this is the Andrea Gail, the fishing trip gone wrong!!!

I never said throw any game out after his recall from rehab in the minors - I simply stated one game threw his number of errors off. Didn't happen again all year. I wasn't/am not wrong. Weeks is a better baseball player than Cano.And no, I never was in a LeBron discussion. I said Oden was injury prone and wouldn't be a great pro - you could find that.....

Is staying healthy not part of the game? And when do we get those page one numbers updated?

 

[_4_]

I will be happy to update as the year goes on, and will tip my hat if Cano outperforms Weeks in 2007.

Have not been to the baseball board since I posted recently. Figured I would wait for the season to play out and assess at that point given it was the first time Weeks was playing "fully" healthy all season.

Thanks Limp - no, I didn't look very hard, because I knew the answer - Weeks was more productive and more valuable down the stretch than Cano. Weeks is better.

I mean, not for nothing dude, you don't have to live here or on this forum, and if you got banged for a timeout from the staff, fine, but I think its pretty plain why you weren't in this thread. You were wrong and its cool, none of us are perfect, but man up about it at least. You want to throw out Weeks few games of errors, why don't we throw out his good games too? You take the good with the bad. Cano's defense improved dramatically this year, his walks were up, and I have a hunch he'll be opening some more eyes this postseason. I mean, I can only assume that this is the Andrea Gail, the fishing trip gone wrong!!!

I never said throw any game out after his recall from rehab in the minors - I simply stated one game threw his number of errors off. Didn't happen again all year. I wasn't/am not wrong. Weeks is a better baseball player than Cano.And no, I never was in a LeBron discussion. I said Oden was injury prone and wouldn't be a great pro - you could find that.....

Is staying healthy not part of the game? And when do we get those page one numbers updated?

Just look at my sig. Those numbers tell the story - and yes, healthy is important, that's why we'll use the numbers from the sig. The fact that Weeks was better even with the bad wrist should have you shuddering....

 

[NY/NJMFDIVER]

I will be happy to update as the year goes on, and will tip my hat if Cano outperforms Weeks in 2007.

Have not been to the baseball board since I posted recently. Figured I would wait for the season to play out and assess at that point given it was the first time Weeks was playing "fully" healthy all season.

Thanks Limp - no, I didn't look very hard, because I knew the answer - Weeks was more productive and more valuable down the stretch than Cano. Weeks is better.

I mean, not for nothing dude, you don't have to live here or on this forum, and if you got banged for a timeout from the staff, fine, but I think its pretty plain why you weren't in this thread. You were wrong and its cool, none of us are perfect, but man up about it at least. You want to throw out Weeks few games of errors, why don't we throw out his good games too? You take the good with the bad. Cano's defense improved dramatically this year, his walks were up, and I have a hunch he'll be opening some more eyes this postseason. I mean, I can only assume that this is the Andrea Gail, the fishing trip gone wrong!!!

I never said throw any game out after his recall from rehab in the minors - I simply stated one game threw his number of errors off. Didn't happen again all year. I wasn't/am not wrong. Weeks is a better baseball player than Cano.And no, I never was in a LeBron discussion. I said Oden was injury prone and wouldn't be a great pro - you could find that.....

Is staying healthy not part of the game? And when do we get those page one numbers updated?

Just look at my sig. Those numbers tell the story - and yes, healthy is important, that's why we'll use the numbers from the sig. The fact that Weeks was better even with the bad wrist should have you shuddering....

Maybe Cano tired from playing a full season of major league baseball. I look forward to bumping this in perpetuity, reading the latest Weeks excuse of the year.

 

[_4_]

Cano tired? Is that an excuse? :rofl:

 

[Tremendous Upside]

Cano tired? Is that an excuse? :rofl:

Bring something to the table here except for the "look at those six weeks in August and Sept argument"Because as far as I can tell, that's all you have, and frankly, it might e the worst analytical argument I've ever seen regarding baseball...

 

[_4_]

Cano tired? Is that an excuse? :rofl:

Bring something to the table here except for the "look at those six weeks in August and Sept argument"Because as far as I can tell, that's all you have, and frankly, it might e the worst analytical argument I've ever seen regarding baseball...

Check Weeks' stats when healthy this year. Clearly outperformed Rosemary. Check Weeks' stats at the start of the season - clearly held his own with a slight advantage. You are so easy.

 

[Tremendous Upside]

Cano tired? Is that an excuse? :rofl:

Bring something to the table here except for the "look at those six weeks in August and Sept argument"Because as far as I can tell, that's all you have, and frankly, it might e the worst analytical argument I've ever seen regarding baseball...

Check Weeks' stats when healthy this year. Clearly outperformed Rosemary. Check Weeks' stats at the start of the season - clearly held his own with a slight advantage. You are so easy.

If the Yankees made the offer, do you think the Brewers would trade Weeks for Cano?No doubt in my mind they would...

 

[NY/NJMFDIVER]

Cano tired? Is that an excuse? :rofl:

Bring something to the table here except for the "look at those six weeks in August and Sept argument"Because as far as I can tell, that's all you have, and frankly, it might e the worst analytical argument I've ever seen regarding baseball...

Check Weeks' stats when healthy this year. Clearly outperformed Rosemary. Check Weeks' stats at the start of the season - clearly held his own with a slight advantage. You are so easy.

If the Yankees made the offer, do you think the Brewers would trade Weeks for Cano?No doubt in my mind they would...

Upside, you may recall, but that was actually the argument elsewhere that inspired this thread. Yes, the Cano being tired thing was a joke, and I really see no reason to post here any longer until Weeks plays a season without a trip to the minors while Cano the great plays 160 big league games. I would also like to cite Cano's two game stretch where he had 7 hits and 3 home runs as evidence that he is not only better than Weeks but the greatest player of all time, if you would only isolate and extrapolate those two games.Oh yeah, had Weeks not tanked his season away, I think _4_ might have found his way back into this thread a bit sooner.

 

[fred_1_15301]

Cano tired? Is that an excuse? :rofl:

Bring something to the table here except for the "look at those six weeks in August and Sept argument"Because as far as I can tell, that's all you have, and frankly, it might e the worst analytical argument I've ever seen regarding baseball...

Check Weeks' stats when healthy this year. Clearly outperformed Rosemary. Check Weeks' stats at the start of the season - clearly held his own with a slight advantage. You are so easy.

Can you guys please provide a game-by-game breakdown of when Cano and Weeks were "healthy"? That would certainly help to determine who the better player is. TIA.

 

[Capella]

If the Yankees made the offer, do you think the Brewers would trade Weeks for Cano?No doubt in my mind they would...

No way would the Brewers do that deal. Come on man..

 

[_4_]

Cano tired? Is that an excuse? :rofl:

Bring something to the table here except for the "look at those six weeks in August and Sept argument"Because as far as I can tell, that's all you have, and frankly, it might e the worst analytical argument I've ever seen regarding baseball...

Check Weeks' stats when healthy this year. Clearly outperformed Rosemary. Check Weeks' stats at the start of the season - clearly held his own with a slight advantage. You are so easy.

Can you guys please provide a game-by-game breakdown of when Cano and Weeks were "healthy"? That would certainly help to determine who the better player is. TIA.

You can use the stats provided in my sig they are applicable for your question.

 

[Tremendous Upside]

If the Yankees made the offer, do you think the Brewers would trade Weeks for Cano?No doubt in my mind they would...

No way would the Brewers do that deal. Come on man..

Really? Why wouldn't they?

 

[shadyridr]

If the Yankees made the offer, do you think the Brewers would trade Weeks for Cano?No doubt in my mind they would...

No way would the Brewers do that deal. Come on man..

Really? Why wouldn't they?

For his UPSIDE

 

[_4_]

If the Yankees made the offer, do you think the Brewers would trade Weeks for Cano?No doubt in my mind they would...

No way would the Brewers do that deal. Come on man..

Really? Why wouldn't they?

Because Weeks is better. Throw in Melky and maybe they would consider it - the Brewers could likely use 5th outfielder if they let Jenkins go.

 

[Darth Cheney]

Let it go guys. Until Weeks can play a full season in the bigs, this is a no-brainer. I mean Weeks has UPSIDE!!!.....but his next level of progression will be equal to Cano's current level.

 

[phthalatemagic]

Weeks is a better baseball player than Cano.

Really? Link?

 

[shadyridr]

Weeks is a better baseball player than Cano.

Really? Link?

Look at his signature. The answer is clearly there

 

[phthalatemagic]

Weeks is a better baseball player than Cano.

Really? Link?

Look at his signature. The answer is clearly there

I have sigs off Is it worth it?

 

[Doctor Detroit]

Cano from here on out in 2009. Just a guess.

 

[shadyridr]

This is one of my favorite threads ever. I used to be a Cano hater and thought Weeks was better but at least I admitted I was wrong fairly early in 2007.

 

[_4_]

Never here anymore... But thought I'd stop by and concede that Cano has turned out to be better than Weeks. At the time Weeks was better...but quite obviously Cano has bested him.

 

[Eviloutsider]

Pretty good line from both as of right now...

Cano-65 runs, 18 HRs, 63 RBIs, 2 SBs, and a .957 OPS

Weeks-65 runs, 19 HRs, 62 RBIs, 6 SBs, and a .858 OPS

Huge numbers from second basemen.

 

[Wrigley]

Cano

 

[rascal]

I voted Cano.