Rodgers for josh doctson matt ryan and 1.11 (1 Viewer)

[Spookytooth]

Which side would you prefer in a 12 team ppr 1qb league?  Thanks! 

 

[beerbuff]

a lot depends on the scoring and what the rest of your team looks like but on face value I'd go with doctsom/ryan and 1.11

 

[msudaisy26]

a lot depends on the scoring and what the rest of your team looks like but on face value I'd go with doctsom/ryan and 1.11

I like this answer, but scoring and roster space could be a huge factor. In a 12 team start 1 qb league I wouldn't pay more than like 1.07 for a guy like Rodgers. Qb is the easiest spot to replace in these leagues.

 

[Gally]

I like this answer, but scoring and roster space could be a huge factor. In a 12 team start 1 qb league I wouldn't pay more than like 1.07 for a guy like Rodgers. Qb is the easiest spot to replace in these leagues.

Serviceable qb play is easy to replace.  Perennial top 3 qb play is not easily replaced.  I would much rather keep Rodgers over that package of players.  Nothing in that offer is impactful.  Keep Rodgers

 

[Craig_MiamiFL]

Rodgers in a landslide for me.

 

[fightingillini]

This a classic 4 quarters for 1 dollar type deal that I just can't stand.  It's very unlikely that the 1.11 pick will become a star.   Doctson hasn't shown that he can be a WR1...plus his situation in 2018 is completely unknown.  Ryan is a good NFL QB, but an average fantasy QB, it was clear that 2016 was a career year that will never be duplicated.

Keep Rodgers.