Rookie Draft: Trade these picks or make these picks? Offers within! (1 Viewer)

[Avery]

I was posting about some options for this league, but another offer came in and I thought it would be clear if I reposted with a new offer and a poll so please forgive me for posting about this league again.

Dynasty/Contract PPR league start QB / 1-2 RB / 2-3 WR / TE

QBs: D. Brees
RBs: T. West, D. Lewis, Duke Johnson, T. Coleman, D. Booker 
WRs: O. Beckham, D Bryant, L. Treadwell, K. White
TEs: R. Gronjowski, T. Eifert, K. Rudolph

Draft so far: L. Fournette C. Davis, C. McCaffrey, J. Mixon, D. Cook, O.J. Howard, M. Gillislee, A. Kamara, M. Williams, K. Hunt, Z. Jones, E. Engram, D. Njoku

I'm on the clock with back to back picks at 2.02 and 2.03 and up again at 3.03.

Clearly, this team needs some help.

Draft: The top players on the board (according to general rankings are) J. Ross and S. Perine with as a FA M. Lynch sitting there.  Also, K. Galladay has attracted my attention recently.  Now I don't have strong opinions on the rookies as I don't watch much college ball but Ross does scare me as there is a lot of competition for targets in Cincinnati but things do change quickly.  I do like the arrow on Galladay.

Trade 1: I can give what amounts to 2.02 (pretty much) straight up for Lamar Miller.
I'm somewhat concerned about Foreman lurking but this seems like good value for Miller.

Trade 2: For another RB options I can give 2.03 and K. Rudolph for 2.09 and Ty Montgomery

So, please vote on if I should take the trade either trade (or both!) and if not you vote to not take either (or both!) trades, who should I pick instead?

Thanks so much! You are awesome! 

 

[DaBeers]

Get Miller - he will have a more constant role with HOU, even if Foreman takes some touches.   Ty Montgomery is going to be pushed by a couple of rookies, Rudolph is safe insurance for yyour TE position.

 

[rustyman]

Miller scares me this year. I have him in a keeper & have to hold him, but who knows what he will do this year.

I love Montgomery this year, even with the rookie Williams stealing some looks, I think Monty will be a beast in PPR. Rudolph foe that early 2nd seems like a steep price. If you can still kerp your early 2nd & trade the later 2nd for Montgomery, or counter with 2.03 for Montgomery, I'd do that.

good luck!

 

[Avery]

Get Miller - he will have a more constant role with HOU, even if Foreman takes some touches.   Ty Montgomery is going to be pushed by a couple of rookies, Rudolph is safe insurance for yyour TE position.

Thanks!

My concern with Miller is that, since this is dynasty, will he be irrelevant in a year or two? Not that rookies are any guarantee...

For the Montgomery trade, I still have Eifert behind Gronk so I do like that risk.

 

[Gandalf]

I was posting about some options for this league, but another offer came in and I thought it would be clear if I reposted with a new offer and a poll so please forgive me for posting about this league again.

Dynasty/Contract PPR league start QB / 1-2 RB / 2-3 WR / TE

QBs: D. Brees
RBs: T. West, D. Lewis, Duke Johnson, T. Coleman, D. Booker 
WRs: O. Beckham, D Bryant, L. Treadwell, K. White
TEs: R. Gronjowski, T. Eifert, K. Rudolph

Draft so far: L. Fournette C. Davis, C. McCaffrey, J. Mixon, D. Cook, O.J. Howard, M. Gillislee, A. Kamara, M. Williams, K. Hunt, Z. Jones, E. Engram, D. Njoku

I'm on the clock with back to back picks at 2.02 and 2.03 and up again at 3.03.

Clearly, this team needs some help.

Draft: The top players on the board (according to general rankings are) J. Ross and S. Perine with as a FA M. Lynch sitting there.  Also, K. Galladay has attracted my attention recently.  Now I don't have strong opinions on the rookies as I don't watch much college ball but Ross does scare me as there is a lot of competition for targets in Cincinnati but things do change quickly.  I do like the arrow on Galladay.

Trade 1: I can give what amounts to 2.02 (pretty much) straight up for Lamar Miller.
I'm somewhat concerned about Foreman lurking but this seems like good value for Miller.

Trade 2: For another RB options I can give 2.03 and K. Rudolph for 2.09 and Ty Montgomery

So, please vote on if I should take the trade either trade (or both!) and if not you vote to not take either (or both!) trades, who should I pick instead?

Thanks so much! You are awesome! 

I like both of those deals for you!

 

[travdogg]

I hope you made both of those deals.

 

[UofMAce]

I like the second trade for Montgomery.  You have depth at TE and Montgomery will help your team.  I wouldn't worry too much about Montgomery losing the job early on. 

 

[Avery]

I almost got a deal to get both D. Murray and D. Henry but it fell apart at the end so I ended up taking both deals with some trepidation.

I feel they are both good value but the best analogy I have is that I got a great price on a car I didn't want.  

Anyway, thanks for the advice, all!

 

[Cs33]

I do not trust miller this year.  Take a look at this https://www.numberfire.com/nfl/lists/15839/fantasy-football-11-players-to-avoid-in-2017/lamar-miller-rb-houston-texans-8

I had reservations before I read that. But after reading it im out on him.