BoomBoom
Footballguy
10 team, 5x5 roto keeper league (kept Howard, Hafner, Santana, and Holliday - draft is auction).
My Roster
C Michael Barrett
1B Ryan Howard
2B Brandon Phillips
SS Hanley Ramirez
3B Mike Lowell
MI Ray Durham
CI Paul Konerko
OF Matt Holliday
OF Carl Crawford
OF Moises Alou
Util Travis Hafner
SP Johan Santana
SP Matt Cain
SP Ian Snell
RP Joe Borowski
RP Chad Cordero
P Joakim Soria
P Brian Fuentes
Bench Javy Vazquez
Bench James Shields
Bench Rich Aurilia
Bench Carlos Quentin
Bench David Weathers
DL Francisco Liriano
DL Octavio Dotel
-----
I give up: Paul Konerko, Joe Borowski, David Weathers, Moises Alou
I get: Aaron Harang, Bobby Jenks, Chipper Jones, Magglio Ordonez
-----
I'm thinking this is a no-brainer, right? We can only start 4 closers, and I'm sitting on 5 (although none are great), so to consolidate 2 for 1 and get a guy like Jenks should help. I get a pretty good SP in Harang, upgrade in my OF from Alou to Maggs. Giving up Konerko at my CI spot could hurt some, especially since Chipper is a good bet to miss time, but with daily lineups I can swap in other guys and not miss too much. Guy I'm trading with is hurting because he only has 2 closers (Jenks and BJ Ryan), and he missed out on Frasor and any other closer pickups. Any thoughts would be appreciated.
My Roster
C Michael Barrett
1B Ryan Howard
2B Brandon Phillips
SS Hanley Ramirez
3B Mike Lowell
MI Ray Durham
CI Paul Konerko
OF Matt Holliday
OF Carl Crawford
OF Moises Alou
Util Travis Hafner
SP Johan Santana
SP Matt Cain
SP Ian Snell
RP Joe Borowski
RP Chad Cordero
P Joakim Soria
P Brian Fuentes
Bench Javy Vazquez
Bench James Shields
Bench Rich Aurilia
Bench Carlos Quentin
Bench David Weathers
DL Francisco Liriano
DL Octavio Dotel
-----
I give up: Paul Konerko, Joe Borowski, David Weathers, Moises Alou
I get: Aaron Harang, Bobby Jenks, Chipper Jones, Magglio Ordonez
-----
I'm thinking this is a no-brainer, right? We can only start 4 closers, and I'm sitting on 5 (although none are great), so to consolidate 2 for 1 and get a guy like Jenks should help. I get a pretty good SP in Harang, upgrade in my OF from Alou to Maggs. Giving up Konerko at my CI spot could hurt some, especially since Chipper is a good bet to miss time, but with daily lineups I can swap in other guys and not miss too much. Guy I'm trading with is hurting because he only has 2 closers (Jenks and BJ Ryan), and he missed out on Frasor and any other closer pickups. Any thoughts would be appreciated.