Royce or Carlos in trade? (1 Viewer)

[Outnumbered]

The team who has Cousins wants Diggs from me...has offered Carlos Hyde, straight up. However, I'd prefer Royce Freeman, whom he also has.

If you're inclined to trade away Diggs - which of those RBs would you prefer?

1.5 PPR for WRs, 1 PPR for RBs, .5 points per rush. Redraft league. 

The caveat here is that we can start up to 3 RBs (we have 2 flex spots in addition to 1RB & 1WR).

Pertinent roster:

LeVeon (D'OH!), LeSean, Barber, Breida...Diggs, Jarvis, Marvin Jones, BCooks.

 

[Slider]

Freeman would be ok. No way I take Hyde.

 

[Flutie2518]

Freeman hell yeah. Hyde gets hurt every year and once he goes down Chubbs May very well keep the starting job

 

[beerbuff]

Freeman is better but it really isn't enough for Diggs. You should get more.

 

[cousinarnold]

At 1.5 ppr for WR, I wouldn't be trading for either of those RBs. Diggs will outscore them by a large amount. Do you need RB help?

 

[Jax Commish]

I definitely wouldn't trade Diggs for Hyde. If Freeman lives up to his Hype I would do this trade. So no keepers at all?

 

[Dinsy Ejotuz]

Freeman and a 2nd might be enough.  But no chance I'm doing a deal for Hyde.

 

[Survivor7700]

I wouldn't trade Diggs for either one of those RB's unless you were really stacked at WR and really weak at RB.

 

[Jax Commish]

At 1.5 ppr for WR, I wouldn't be trading for either of those RBs. Diggs will outscore them by a large amount. Do you need RB help?

don't forget the RB gets .5 point per rush.

 

[cousinarnold]

don't forget the RB gets .5 point per rush.

That is a good point. Totally missed that in the equation. I still wouldn't do Hyde, but it would make Freeman much more tempting. Still boils down to what you currently have on the roster and if it's a need.

 

[Outnumbered]

I wouldn't trade Diggs for either one of those RB's unless you were really stacked at WR and really weak at RB.

LeVeon is gonna kill me at RB...but otherwise, I'm okay-ish:  LeVeon, LeSean, Barber, Breida.

And my WRs are solid with Diggs, Jarvis, Marvin Jones, and B Cooks.  So I might could afford to lose Diggs.

My preference is to always start RBs when I can. Even at 1.5 PPR, only the very-top WRs score similarly to the top 10-12 RBs.

 

[Survivor7700]

LeVeon is gonna kill me at RB...but otherwise, I'm okay-ish:  LeVeon, LeSean, Barber, Breida.

And my WRs are solid with Diggs, Jarvis, Marvin Jones, and B Cooks.  So I might could afford to lose Diggs.

Still would keep Diggs.