Tau837
Footballguy
I think it has more to do with circumstances.First of all, good post with good stats.
Second of all, we now have two OCs that have used Mathews (basically) the same way.
I think it has more to do with Ryan's limitations.
Norv:
2010 - Rookie. Got full workload in game 1, got hurt in game 2 and Tolbert came in and played very well, RBBC rest of the way. Got hurt again in week 9 and missed the next 3 games. Performed well when healthy. No doghouse issues.
2011 - Great season. 1546 YFS on just 272 touches. Averaged 4.9 ypc and 9.1 ypr. Significantly outperformed Tolbert. No doghouse issues.
2012 - Primed for bellcow role but broke collarbone in preseason.
Up to this point his first coaching staff was very happy with his play and planned to make him their feature RB. So I think this largely disproves your statement.
But the team had to play Ronnie Brown in his early absence and continued to give him a role when Mathews returned. Mathews fumbled in his first game back and went into doghouse and shared the workload the rest of the way despite playing reasonably well. (The OL was decimated by injuries, so his performance was better than his numbers. I've posted on this previously.) Then he broke his collarbone again. Some suspected A.J. Smith directed the doghouse treatment for some reason. Either way, it was stupid coaching/management by a coach and GM who were on their way out.
2013 - New regime. Mathews isn't "their guy" but Woodhead is. Is that because of Mathews' limitations or because of bias? Either way, Mathews is performing well, and the recent trend is that he is seeing more snaps and utilization. SameOldSongAndDance has posted about that recently, either in one of the Mathews threads or in the snap counts thread, or both. It makes sense that he is trending up, based on the stats I posted earlier and based on his recent performance on the field.