It's obvious Brady is better just look at this season. Manning can't get out of the way of a Brady punt, Brady recovers it and kicks the game winning FG in OT to beat Manning. Then last week Brady kicks an onside kick and recovers it and then finds a yellow flag in his pocket and uses it in the last minute to call a PI penalty for the win. Then tonight Manning jumps offsides on a punt and kept running on to the field giving Denver 12 men on the field penalties. So Brady is a hero and Manning keeps making stupid mistakes.
The patriots dug themselves into a 21-0 hole in the early minutes of the pats broncos game by fumbling the ball repeatedly, including one by ridley that all but ended his season. Brady led them to 4 tds to come back and beat the broncos. Against cleveland, brady was leading a drive when he threw the ball to gronk, and he tore his acl and mcl. When he finally had a chance to get something going, the defense failed him by letting up an 80 yard strike to josh gordon. When they needed a critical stop in the fourth quarter, they gave up a long drive that was capped by a touchdown to a completely uncovered jordan cameron. Both teams faced adversity, and both qbs had a chance to respond.Against the browns, with two minutes and change left, down by two scores, brady get the ball and leads them to a quick touchdown. Everyone in the stadium, everyone watching on tv said, if they get the ball back, they're really going to do this. And they did. And while you can complain all you want about that pass interference call, brady still had to throw the game winning touchdown, and he did. Two touchdowns in two minutes to lead one of the most improbable comebacks of the season.
Manning last night got the ball back, down one score, with 4 minutes left, and everyone said, he's reallly going to do this. What did he do? He threw an interception that gave san diego the ball in field goal distance. But that's ok, the defense was able to hold them to a field goal and get manning the ball back with two minutes and change left. And sure enough, manning comes out slinging the ball to montee ball over the middle. Then knowshon over the middle. And andre caldwell and jacob tamme in the middle of the field. He never spiked the ball, which kept his completion percentage up, but he threw a ball off the defenders hands at the start of the drive. Still, manning was able to get it done, heroically driving them to a long field goal attempt with half a minute left. If the energy wasn't quite the same with mannings drive, maybe its because manning had taken all that time off the clock just to make up the points that he had handed to the chargers with his late fourth quarter interception, and had taken the field goal so they had a chance to tie, instead of the td so they had a chance to win.
Every team has good breaks and bad breaks. The broncos this year have had their share of both, and the patriots have, too. If you want to compare having your head coach sidelined by heart surgery to losing gronk, hernandez, mayo, wilfork and vereen to the ir, we can. If you want to compare a 12 man on the field penalty which was clearly evident on replay to a penalty that has literally only been called once in the nfl, ever, against the patriots at the end of the game to give the jets a shorter field goal, and then another penalty where the flag was inexplicably picked up at the end of the panthers game, and then say that the patriots only beat the browns because of a bad call and the broncos only lost because of penalties, then you're within your rights, but its not a very good argument.
What we can compare is the individual efforts. And while manning has put up gaudier stats, while throwing to much better targets, his individual efforts in prime time games against the colts, patriots and chargers have been less than stellar. In the patriots and chargers games in particular, he seemed to forget about his best receivers, and he shrunk when the game was on the line. This isn't the first time we've seen it, and I doubt it will be the last, because the broncos are going to another postseason game, where he will throw another game ending interception, and his fans will again blame the defense or the officiating or bad luck or whatever they can blame besides manning himself.