Should I trade Rivera for Giambi? (1 Viewer)

[Tiger Fan]

Here's my team - I need help at 1B, and I'm ready to punt saves. 5x5 h2h

1B

Wigginton,Ty TB

LaRoche,Adam A. PIT

2B

Theriot,Ryan CHC

Hudson,Orlando ARI

3B

Rolen,Scott STL

SS

Tulowitzki,Troy COL

C

Molina,Bengie SF

IR- Lo Duca,Paul NYM

OF Tm

Sheffield,Gary DET

Drew,J.D. BOS

Lee,Carlos N. HOU

Bay,Jason PIT

Dunn,Adam CIN

SP Tm

Olsen,Scott FLA

Glavine,Tom NYM

Sheets,Ben MIL

Oswalt,Roy HOU

Schilling,Curt BOS

Young,Chris R. SD

RP Tm

Sampson,Chris HOU

Crain,Jesse MIN

Broxton,Jonathan LA

Neshek,Pat MIN

Saito,Takashi LA

Rivera,Mariano NYY

 

[Funkley]

With Crain hurt you'll have to replace 2 MR's. Who is available to pick up? Otherwise it seems like a fair deal but Giambi's been dealing with an injury lately (foot, heal, something like that).

 

[Tiger Fan]

With Crain hurt you'll have to replace 2 MR's. Who is available to pick up? Otherwise it seems like a fair deal but Giambi's been dealing with an injury lately (foot, heal, something like that).

Ended up giving Rivera and Saito for Travis Hafner and Linebrink

 

[Funkley]

With Crain hurt you'll have to replace 2 MR's. Who is available to pick up? Otherwise it seems like a fair deal but Giambi's been dealing with an injury lately (foot, heal, something like that).

Ended up giving Rivera and Saito for Travis Hafner and Linebrink

Given your goals I like this deal more.

 

[Tiger Fan]

With Crain hurt you'll have to replace 2 MR's. Who is available to pick up? Otherwise it seems like a fair deal but Giambi's been dealing with an injury lately (foot, heal, something like that).

Ended up giving Rivera and Saito for Travis Hafner and Linebrink

Given your goals I like this deal more.

:highfive:see me MR thread please