Should I veto this? (1 Viewer)

[billrob]

This is the first trade in my league that has ever been questioned.

Avery and V Davis for Mason and Gates.

It a dynasty and the team getting Avery and Davis is out of it.

These two also made a trade a few weeks ago that raised some eyebrows. It was Favre, Forte and TO for Rivers and Gore.

Should I do anything?

 

[jamil]

no and no.

 

[Nate]

(two normal trades)...Should I do anything?

Yes, you should quit worrying about the balance of every trade. Everyone has different values on different guys. In keeper/dynasty leagues, it's especially impossible to try and guage the long term balance of a trade. If it isn't collusion, butt out.

 

[Kwai Chang Caine]

Come on man. What looks so unbalanced about that trade? Seems fair to me.

 

[Londo]

Good God, there is nothing wrong with any of these trades in a dynasty league.

 

[JHuber77]

uh, NO and this doesn't belong in this forum

 

[AgentMulder]

.......... Don't veto anything before asking me first, and NO don't veto it. If you're going to ask please come with something that actually looks like collusion.

 

[pantagrapher]

You should ban all trades.

 

[Jersey35]

This is the first trade in my league that has ever been questioned.Avery and V Davis for Mason and Gates.It a dynasty and the team getting Avery and Davis is out of it.These two also made a trade a few weeks ago that raised some eyebrows. It was Favre, Forte and TO for Rivers and Gore.Should I do anything?

I don't even see how either trade is even questionable - particularly in dynasty. That being said, your job as commish is not to judge the VALUE of players in a trade - only to police cheating - i.e. collusion. What should you do? Nada.

 

[ninerfanatic492000]

question it if they attempt something like ADP for Shaun Alexander

 

[gman8343]

good trade.

 

[slayer666]

no and no.

 

[tribecalledjeff]

This is a ridiculously fair dynasty trade, the type that should happen between a team that is out of the playoffs and a team that isn't. It's not even close to unfair. If you don't realize this, stop playing fantasy football. Or at least stop being a commish.

 

[mozzy84]

I hope

 

[phthalatemagic]

You should veto it, then quit fantasy football forever.

 

[Black]

Neither of those looks out of whack.

 

[dotman]

I keep opening threads like these hoping that just once it will be a trade that should be vetoed. It hasn't happened yet

 

[fred_1_15301]

I keep opening threads like these hoping that just once it will be a trade that should be vetoed. It hasn't happened yet

Am I the only one who's entertained by these threads......... . Nothing I love more than opening up one of these threads, seeing a completely fair trade and watching the shark pool brethren completely rip into the original poster. I'm sick but it entertains me.

 

[dotman]

I keep opening threads like these hoping that just once it will be a trade that should be vetoed. It hasn't happened yet

Am I the only one who's entertained by these threads......... . Nothing I love more than opening up one of these threads, seeing a completely fair trade and watching the shark pool brethren completely rip into the original poster. I'm sick but it entertains me.

Yeah maybe that's another reason why I read them...also makes me feel better that my league let's me run my team as I want to.

 

[eric rymer]

This is the first trade in my league that has ever been questioned.Avery and V Davis for Mason and Gates.It a dynasty and the team getting Avery and Davis is out of it.These two also made a trade a few weeks ago that raised some eyebrows. It was Favre, Forte and TO for Rivers and Gore.Should I do anything?

I don't even see how either trade is even questionable - particularly in dynasty. That being said, your job as commish is not to judge the VALUE of players in a trade - only to police cheating - i.e. collusion. What should you do? Nada.

Agree 100%

 

[thatguy]

I keep opening threads like these hoping that just once it will be a trade that should be vetoed. It hasn't happened yet

Me too.

 

[dapunisher]

Before opening the thread, I planned to type "NO" before reading the original post. I changed my mind and read the entire thread. Like guessing on the SAT, I should have stuck with my first instinct.

 

[MDSkinner]

I can't fathom how this one even gets questioned.

OR the other one mentioned in this OP.

Both perfectly legit trades that each team could argue helped them in some way.