He's 57% for his career and has never thrown for 4000. Many, many WCO QB's have done better.
IMO, that's not very great reasoning for him not making the probowl. And actually he's 58% for his career, not that it matters.4000 isn't a common landmark. You kinda made it sound like it is. Besides that, he's played most of his career without any real good WRs. The two years he had good WRs were 2004 and this year. In 2004 he became the first QB to ever throw for more than 30 TDs while throwing under 10 picks. Manning, Marino, Young, Montana, Elway, Unitas, none of them have ever done that. He did that while throwing for over 3800 yards. His QB average that year was 104.7, and his completion percentage was 64%, just .7 shy of Peyton Manning when he threw for 49 TDs. His rating in 2004 was about 12 points higher than Brady and his completion percentage was about 7% higher as well.
This past year he was on pace for over 4200 yards and about 29 TDs with just about 10 INTs. His QB rating this year was 95.5, just about 4 points less than Peyton Manning and about 10 points more than Tom Brady.
And that's not counting what he can do with his feet.