SHOULD SMITH'S TD COUNT (1 Viewer)

[flying8balls]

Should you get credit for steve smith's punt return TD,if you start him as a wr?

 

[Shermanator]

In my league, Yes.No credit for yards, but points for td

 

[Tick]

Not in most leagues.

 

[Da Guru]

Yes, the TD points but not the yardage

 

[culdeus]

Depends on your league. If you don't have D/ST and IDP instead then give Smith the TD points. IF you have D/ST then no, don't do it you have a spot for ST Touchdowns. Simple.edit to add: I'm not suggesting you change from whatever you have. Just making the point for leagues in general. Don't change it just because you forgot to add the possiblity of a WR getting a ST TD in. Too late to change.

 

[Couch Potato]

Check your league rules. Any decent set of rules will spell out how punt/KO returns are scored.

 

[Bankerguy]

Check your league rules. Any decent set of rules will spell out how punt/KO returns are scored.

Why is this such a mystery to some people? Check your league rules.

 

[flying8balls]

Its no mystery to me.I'm commissioner of a playoff league and I set it up to not award TDs on special teams to indivual players.I have an owner chirping about it and just wanted see what everyone thought.

 

[Marino13]

I thought this was going to be more about the thrown flag, but yet no penalty call... anyone think the block in the back was valid and the TD should have been nullified?

 

[reg]

Should count, but with an asterik.

 

[John 14:6]

Yes, unless your rules say otherwise.

 

[Bankerguy]

Its no mystery to me.

I'm commissioner of a playoff league and I set it up to

not award TDs on special teams to indivual  players.

I have an owner chirping about it and just

wanted see what everyone thought.

Then why not articulate yourself more clearly. I am sure you will get a much different response.Oh and btw......take off the Caps locks.

That is all!

 

[flying8balls]

Friendly guy, aren't ya.

 

[glock]

In my $$ league, TD's on returns are creditied to the D/ST and individual player. If you started the Carolina D/ST and Smith you garnered 12 points right there.