Should this trade conern me? (1 Viewer)

[Ripleys]

Just curious of others opinions on this one.

Team A gives: Reggie Bush, AJ, Jacoby Jones, Mercedes Lewis, Jerramy Stevens

Team B gives: Felix Jones, Chris Perry, Sproles, Driver, Josh Reed, Shockey, 2009 Round 1,2, 3rd round picks.

To me, one team is giving up 2 proven PPR elite studs in Bush and AJ. One team is moving backups, average players (Driver & Shockey) and hopeful future talent.

Would any of you move Bush and AJ for those players?

 

[quickhands]

Just curious of others opinions on this one. Team A gives: Reggie Bush, AJ, Jacoby Jones, Mercedes Lewis, Jerramy StevensTeam B gives: Felix Jones, Chris Perry, Sproles, Driver, Josh Reed, Shockey, 2009 Round 1,2, 3rd round picks. To me, one team is giving up 2 proven PPR elite studs in Bush and AJ. One team is moving backups, average players (Driver & Shockey) and hopeful future talent. Would any of you move Bush and AJ for those players?

this is very poorly disguised Asst Coach thread.no....it doesn't look like collusion.

 

[CaptainHook]

Just curious of others opinions on this one. Team A gives: Reggie Bush, AJ, Jacoby Jones, Mercedes Lewis, Jerramy StevensTeam B gives: Felix Jones, Chris Perry, Sproles, Driver, Josh Reed, Shockey, 2009 Round 1,2, 3rd round picks. To me, one team is giving up 2 proven PPR elite studs in Bush and AJ. One team is moving backups, average players (Driver & Shockey) and hopeful future talent. Would any of you move Bush and AJ for those players?

its probably a little lopsided but not anything close to outrageousin a dynasty the value of players is much more subjective

 

[Ripleys]

Just curious of others opinions on this one. Team A gives: Reggie Bush, AJ, Jacoby Jones, Mercedes Lewis, Jerramy StevensTeam B gives: Felix Jones, Chris Perry, Sproles, Driver, Josh Reed, Shockey, 2009 Round 1,2, 3rd round picks. To me, one team is giving up 2 proven PPR elite studs in Bush and AJ. One team is moving backups, average players (Driver & Shockey) and hopeful future talent. Would any of you move Bush and AJ for those players?

its probably a little lopsided but not anything close to outrageousin a dynasty the value of players is much more subjective

This is kind of what I think. And my team is not either one of these, I wanted to get opinions, so I don't see this as the AC thread. I'm not trying to get help about MY team.

 

[tomarken]

We should have this:

> IMPORTANT NOTE ABOUT THE SHARK POOLThreads that are asking for advice on how you should draft or manage your team belong in The Assistant Coach forum.

changed to this:

> IMPORTANT NOTE ABOUT THE SHARK POOLThreads that are asking for advice on how you should draft or manage your team belong in The Assistant Coach forum. Also, you should NEVER veto a trade unless it is obvious collusion. And no one in the Shark Pool knows (or cares) enough about your league to tell you if there is collusion involved. So don't bother asking. Also, TDs scored on fake punts/fake FG's are NOT special teams TDs. HTH.

 

[trader jake]

Should this trade conern me?

No.

 

[blake]

Would any of you move Bush and AJ for those players?

not important, and irrelevant to your question. this trade isn't so great, but it certainly shouldn't concern you. as posted many times before, let people run their own teams how they see fit, until collusion is proven beyond reasonable doubt.

 

[Neil Beaufort Zod]

I think the second guy is getting a decent deal here. Felix Jones, Shockey, Sproles and three top draft picks next year? That's not bad for Bush and an inconsistent AJ.

 

[Road Warriors]

Dynasty trades can't be evaluated on direct talent for talent. The Team A clearly is looking to the future. There is almost no trade I could envision in Dynasty that you can cry foul over. It'll take 2-3 years to determine who wins this trade.

 

[GregR_2]

Just curious of others opinions on this one. Team A gives: Reggie Bush, AJ, Jacoby Jones, Mercedes Lewis, Jerramy StevensTeam B gives: Felix Jones, Chris Perry, Sproles, Driver, Josh Reed, Shockey, 2009 Round 1,2, 3rd round picks. To me, one team is giving up 2 proven PPR elite studs in Bush and AJ. One team is moving backups, average players (Driver & Shockey) and hopeful future talent. Would any of you move Bush and AJ for those players?

Ask the coach of the team you think is getting the shaft to explain why he thinks it is ultimately to his benefit. What we say should matter a lot less than what he says.