I've got both the 2004 and 2005 draft guides here, and here is how the top-10 at each position both years stacks up. 2005 rooks in bold:QBOverall grade 2004 BOverall grade 2005 C8.9 Ben Roethlisberger, Miami OH8.8 Eli Manning, Mississippi8.8 Aaron Rodgers, Cal8.6 Alex Smith, Utah8.4 Philip Rivers, NC St8.0 J.P. Losman, Tulane7.9 Charlie Frye, Akron7.8 Andrew Walter, Arizona St7.4 Jason Campbell, Auburn6.8 Dan Orlovsky, Connecticut6.8 Matt Schaub, Virginia6.7 Derek Anderson, Oregon St6.4 Kyle Orton, Purdue6.1 John Navarre, Michigan5.9 David Greene, Georgia5.7 Josh Harris, Bowling Green5.4 Walter Washington, Temple5.2 Cody Pickett, Washington4.9 Matt Mauck, LSU4.6 Ryan Dinwiddie, Boise StRBOverall grade 2004 BOverall grade 2005 A-8.8 Cedric Benson, Texas8.7 Ronnie Brown, Auburn8.6 Carnell Williams, Auburn8.5 Steven Jackson, Oregon St8.3 Kevin Jones, Virginia Tech8.1 Ciatrick Fason, Florida8.0 Chris Perry, Michigan7.9 Verand Morency, Oklahoma St7.7 Maurice Clarett, Ohio St (2004 ranking)7.6 Greg Jones, Florida St7.1 Eric Shelton, Louisville7.0 T.A. McClendon, NC St6.9 Cedric Cobbs, Arkansas6.9 Julius Jones, Notre Dame6.6 Walter Reyes, Syracuse6.5 Anthony Davis, Wisconsin6.4 Quincy Wilson, W Virginia (says 3.4, but I'm assuming that's a typo)6.2 Marion Barber, Minnesota6.1 Michael Turner, N Illinois5.9 Tatum Bell, Oklahoma StWROverall grade 2004 AOverall grade 2005 B+8.9 Mike Williams, USC (2004 rating)8.9 Larry Fitzgerald, Pittsburgh8.7 Braylon Edwards, Michigan8.7 Roy Williams, Texas8.6 Mike Williams, USC (2005 rating)8.5 Troy Williamson, S Carolina8.4 Reggie Williams, Washington8.4 Michael Clayton, LSU8.2 Mark Clayton, Oklahoma8.1 Lee Evans, Wisconsin7.9 Chris Henry, W Virginia7.9 Michael Jenkins, Ohio St7.6 Devery Henderson, LSU7.5 Roddy White, UAB7.4 Fred Gibson, Georgia7.2 Bernard Berrien, Fresno St7.2 Craphonso Thorpe, Florida St.7.1 Terrence Murphy, Texas A&M7.0 Reggie Brown, GeorgiaTEOverall grade 2004 C+Overall grade 2005 C8.7 Kellen Winslow, Miami8.5 Heath Miler, Virginia8.3 Ben Troupe, Florida7.8 Ben Watson, Georgia7.6 Alex Smith, Stanford6.6 Ben Utecht, Minnesota6.5 Kevin Everett, Miami6.2 Garrett Cross, Cal6.1 Jason Peters, Arkansas5.9 Joel Dreessen, Colorado St5.7 Steve Fleming, Arizona5.7 Ben Hartsock, Ohio St5.5 Chris Cooley, Utah St5.4 Adam Bergen, Lehigh5.2 Ronnie Ghent, Louisville5.1 David Kashetta, Boston College4.8 Alex Holmes, USC4.8 Sean Ryan, Boston College4.4 Eric Knott, Michigan St4.4 Keith Willis, Virginia TechHere is what the numerical grades mean:9.0 - 8.0 = Franchise player.7.9 - 7.0 = Potential Pro Bowl player.6.9 - 6.0 = Could start as a rookie.5.9 - 5.0 = Eventual starter.4.9 - 4.0 = Quality backup.3.9 - 3.0 = Chance to make roster.2.9 - 2.0 = Not likely to make roster.1.9 - 1.0 = Free agent possibility.