Sort this out for me (1 Viewer)

[32 Counter Pass]

What is the best option? This is a ppr format.

I have really like what I have seen so far from Reggie. He is a focal point of the offense and he has looked good running between the tackles. Hightower has been putting up strong numbers and been declared the starting RB, although I don't have trust in Shanny. The there is FrJax, who is making a strong push for the starting job. FrJax rush numbers will suffer behind this OLine, but he makes up for it with strong receiving numbers.

Thoughts?

 

[glong989]

I like Jackson. Some grumbling about him not being the "starter", but unless Spiller turns it around he will be the workhorse (even if Spiller improves from last season I see Jackon getting more carries).

He was coming on well at the end of last season. However, right now he has a higher ADP in round 6 than the other two so it's hard to really compare them when they are going 1-3 rounds later on average. I expect Bush to gain some hype if he plays well again in the next pre season contest. Hightower could do the same.

 

[zed2283]

Ha... it just so happens I have all three of these guys. Drafted Bush as a rookie and just traded for the other two during the draft. I hope Bush can stay healthy, if last week was any indication of how Miami is going to use him. I think Fred Jackson will do his usual job of forcing the team to use him due to his strong play on the field. I think Hightower will start out as the man, but who knows after that.

 

[eoMMan]

I'd rank them as Bush, Hightower and then FJackson.

 

[Gawain]

I would trade all 3 of them for Gates, but only two of them for Witten.

 

[32 Counter Pass]

I would trade all 3 of them for Gates, but only two of them for Witten.

Thanks for the help. Really appreciated.

 

[Gawain]

I would trade all 3 of them for Gates, but only two of them for Witten.

Thanks for the help. Really appreciated.

You are welcome. You really should add Gates.

 

[rocketsauce]

I'm having this same group of talent staring at me at the 6/7 turn (picking #1 overall) in my 12 team PPR too. Right now I think I go Jackson, Bush, Hightower, but the Bills inept management and coaching has me once again thinking they won't give Jackson the opportunity he deserves, so I'm starting to re-evaluate.

Question, should I assume Cedric Benson is above all of these guys? Cause he's the guy I'm loving seeing at the 6/7 turn, even if he's boring, slow, and unimpressive. Bengals first 5 weeks of the schedule is the softest run D in the league. Milk him while he's healthy, and then trade him before you have to depend on him deeper into the season when things turn uglier and uglier for that team.

 

[32 Counter Pass]

I'm having this same group of talent staring at me at the 6/7 turn (picking #1 overall) in my 12 team PPR too. Right now I think I go Jackson, Bush, Hightower, but the Bills inept management and coaching has me once again thinking they won't give Jackson the opportunity he deserves, so I'm starting to re-evaluate.Question, should I assume Cedric Benson is above all of these guys? Cause he's the guy I'm loving seeing at the 6/7 turn, even if he's boring, slow, and unimpressive. Bengals first 5 weeks of the schedule is the softest run D in the league. Milk him while he's healthy, and then trade him before you have to depend on him deeper into the season when things turn uglier and uglier for that team.

I have remove Benson at this spot in the draft because the QB play is going to drag down everyone's production. It could be an overreaction, but I am not digging the vibe coming from Cincy.

 

[32 Counter Pass]

http://forums.footballguys.com/forum/index.php?showtopic=606618

 

[Instinctive]

Because it belonged in the Assistant Coach Forum.

:lock:

 

[32 Counter Pass]

Help me understand why? I am not asking a WDIS question. I am asking about which player will be more productive in a ppr format.

Besides wouldn't it be moved rather than locked if that was the case?

 

[Ignoratio Elenchi]

Help me understand why? I am not asking a WDIS question. I am asking about which player will be more productive in a ppr format.

There's no material difference. Asking which of three players is better in a specific scoring format isn't general enough to be useful to many people. Threads like that have to get moved, otherwise anyone could simply "disguise" their WDIS post in the Shark Pool.

Besides wouldn't it be moved rather than locked if that was the case?

Usually.Mods> Please reopen OPs thread and move to AC forum. Also, why was the evolution thread axed in the FFA? TIA

 

[Multiple Scores]

So you are now at 2 wasteful threads in one day. Congrats.

 

[rocketsauce]

Well, I thought the thread was a beneficial discussion of those 6th round guys. Sorry OP, the man got you down.

 

[Mystery Achiever]

"Sort this out for me Bush, Hightower or FrJax "..."This is a PPR format"

--- Sounds specific to you , vs a general discussion. Tolerance for "wrong forum posts, and therefore, Locked vs Moved treatment,generally has to do with the volume of those posts and how busy this forum is.

 

[32 Counter Pass]

So you are now at 2 wasteful threads in one day. Congrats.

Really? The post was wasteful huh? Seems like a legitimate question people will be faced with in Rds 6/7. BTW, you post only helps add to the "wasteful" count. Carry on